GOT CULTURE? Um, actually no

by Kate Armstrong on Thursday, September 3, 2009 at 9:54pm ·

B.C. Liberal government has cut funding for arts and cultural organizations by 50 percent this fiscal year, and by 92 percent for 2010–11.

Imagine a 92 percent reduction in your company’s income. How would your industry fare if that was implemented across the board?

The numbers are like this: 47.8 million (2008) down to 3.75 million (2010-2011)

Reasons This Makes No Sense Economically:
• B.C.’s arts and culture sector employs more than 78,000 people and contributes over $5 billion each year to the provincial economy
• Yes, billion.
• The B.C. government’s own research has demonstrated that for every dollar invested in the arts, $1.38 comes back in taxes
• Contrast this move with the response to financial downturn in Ontario: Ontario increased their core arts spending by approximately 130 million in this year’s budget

How Does This Affect You?
• Arts foundations, non-profits and galleries will close or reduce their programming or services. Example: Between the announcement Friday, August 28 and Wednesday, September 3, 2009, 2 Vancouver galleries have announced that they are being forced to close their doors.
• Creative people will leave B.C. in droves
• Drastically reduced opportunities for cultural exposure in the province for yourselves and your children
• Huge damage to the reputation of B.C. - do you want to live in and bring up your children in a cultural wasteland? Was there a reason you chose to live in a city and not in a closet?
• Everything you attend, view, take your children to, or see in a cultural framework is partly subsidized by provincial infrastructure. Arts Umbrella? Children’s Festival? Vancouver Art Gallery? Gallery openings? Ballet BC? BYE!

Common Misconceptions
• Artists are not spending their time at champagne soirees at the taxpayer’s expense. Artists are among the most underpaid professions in our society.
• Culture is an industry, not something that just “happens”. You’re thinking of people who make pictures of owls using bottle caps.
• Not a hobby. Don’t argue that running the Children’s Festival or arranging an international visual art exhibition is something we’re supposed to do in our spare time.
• Artists are not “fancy”. Art is a hugely important part of our shared culture. Were the cave paintings fancy? Do you like written language? Have you ever seen a movie or worn a nice shirt or walked through a public space?
• You cannot argue that the cultural sector must be commercially viable or die. A huge amount of heavy lifting in terms of ideas, social good and cultural visioning is performed by the creative industries and this does not neatly align with commercial engagement.
• These grants we’re talking about do not entirely pay for the operations of these cultural associations so forget the word “parasite” when you make your economic argument. They represent a small but crucially important portion of total support and income.
• Art is not about artists, it is about communities and culture.
• This discussion is not only art, it is dance, film, heritage, publishing, media, sound, music, design, theatre, social outreach, community festivals.
• People in these industries work hard, have jobs and have families too, and are already underpaid.
• A healthy arts sector is essential for healthy communities.

The idea that this is about supporting art vs feeding needy children is a shell game. We need to do both.

Share
  • Yvonne Louise Chadwick, Ree Tourettes, Stevie G. Roland and 93 others like this.
  • 1 share1 share
    • Beth Carruthers
      So, what is this cut taxes and burn culture thing? Thanks, but I'd rather pay heftier taxes and breathe, drown in, arts and culture - especially when things look gloomier in the world. I'd rather stay home. You're right Kate. No arts and cu...lture will simply send people like me packing - and guess what? We'll happily pay our taxes somewhere else - somewhere we can live with and in arts & culture! It will also turn away tourists in droves. "Oh, Vancouver... you mean that culturally impoverished place with the nice mountains - and oh, yes, big social problems - way out there at the edge of the known world? No, not really. I really think Montreal or France offer great value for our vacation money..."See More
      September 3, 2009 at 11:30pm
    • Lindsay Brown Thanks for doing this, Kate. So smart, and I even laughed, in spite of the gloom and fury.
      September 4, 2009 at 9:41am
    • Keith Higgins This is great -- would you mind posting a link, or reposting, on our fb group? http://www.facebook.com/groups/group.php?gid=129278437702
      September 4, 2009 at 10:27am
    • Jessica Wadsworth
      Thanks so much for taking the time to write this. It brings a lot more to the discussion than just the $1.38, which I fear is getting too loud again.

      I think the uphill battle is convincing certain factions that when they put on their favo...urite Nickelback album and pick up a copy of BC Outdoor Sport Fishing magazine that provincial and federal funds directly supported the development of these industries (Canadian music and Magazines Canada). Illuminating that it's not just "fancy" art that is threatened and that our tax dollars create a very wide spectrum of arts, culture and entertainment which has become part of the fabric of Canadian life is relevant when thinking about how we will bring this message to the public at large. It might sound silly, but honestly, we are charged with the task of changing public perception outside of the arts community -- and that may mean we have to ask rhetorical questions like "What would the world be like without Nickelback?"See More
      September 4, 2009 at 11:09am
    • Zoe M. Peled Amen. Why can we only say we 'like' something once on Facebook? I like times ten.
      September 4, 2009 at 11:43am
    • Lindsay Brown I hate making the 1.38 argument, because it's neo-conservative, but we can't afford not to be making that argument too right now. But Jessica I agree, the Nickelback argument is smart. The shortest shortcut to getting this message across to Nickelback fans? Getting Nickelback to make a public statement. If Nickelback comes out for the arts, I will personally go out and buy a Nickelback album.
      September 4, 2009 at 11:59am
    • Camille Baker you should all move en mass to England - there's culture here and people pay for it and appreciate its value to society. i gave up on BC and Canada in general... or at least move to Montreal where they get it...
      September 4, 2009 at 12:02pm
    • Jessica Wadsworth Absolutely Lindsay! To the politicians we speak in a language that they can understand, but for the public at large we absolutely must get them to understand that they ARE stakeholders in the cultural industry. Sport, Culture and Tourism are so interwoven into the lives of Canadians that it's taken for granted -- but it's the same pool of money. Hmmm, maybe Chad Kroeger is on facebook...
      September 4, 2009 at 12:35pm
    • Kate Armstrong I'm always blown away by the general ignorance of the public about the nature of the culture industries. People who are otherwise very cool and interesting are mystified completely by what an artist actually does.
      September 4, 2009 at 12:38pm
    • Camille Baker
      Beth - i think people elsewhere already think Vancouver is culturally impoverised with pretty mountains and most don't even bother coming out that far as they know they'll get culture in Montreal but the rest of Canada (at least what i've h...eard since i moved to the UK) is viewed as still cowboys and to some degree that's true ... that said i've seen shite here as well as amazing art but the artists we have in Vancouver and likely the rest of BC do still hold their own against artists elsewhere and there are some amazing BC artists and artworks that i can still feel proud to be from there.

      thanks Kate for fighting the good fight (since people like me gave up) !!
      See More
      September 4, 2009 at 1:58pm
    • Andra Norton I find it absolutely incredible that they're doing this right before we host the olympics... way to look bad when our province is on the world stage!
      September 4, 2009 at 2:06pm
    • Jim Bizzocchi Excellent statement, Kate!
      September 4, 2009 at 3:48pm
    • Colin Griffiths
      Nickleback?

      Hmm, OK, so then also pitch the concept to other BC music gazillionaires like Diana Krall, Elvis Costello, Bryan Adams, Randy Bachman, Sarah McLachlan, Joni Mitchell, Bill Henderson, Colin James, Nelly Furtado, Bob Rock, Micha...el Buble, and other huge names that have a BC connection.

      Persuade BC artists w/ international name recognition to join in articulating the value of a vibrant arts and cultural community in the creation of a healthy society.

      Celebrity moments cannot be ignored; the lesson of the Québecois arts response to the Tories demonstrates that politicos, media and the public HAVE to watch, and - eventually - respond.
      See More
      September 4, 2009 at 4:13pm
    • Jessica Wadsworth I think that's what we're going to do as a long term approach Colin. Hopefully making short video clips and hoping for a response close to that of the Quebecois. Thanks for the names listed.
      September 4, 2009 at 8:28pm
    • Colin Griffiths OK, great to hear there's momentum on the concept: please let me know how I can assist.
      September 4, 2009 at 8:33pm
    • Valerie Senyk Thak you for making a sensible and gritty argument Kate - - i will pass this on!
      September 5, 2009 at 9:48am
    • Oliver Hockenhull
      Everyone is going to be negatively effected by the this if the so-called Liberals have their way. The major art groups in this Province should seriously consider putting together a series of video responses ...in the manner of this

      http://...www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uhgv85m852Q

      The clip most definitely helped to give the Conservatives a kick where it hurts and damaged their hope for a majority.... Read More

      The people of BC are proud of being BC'ers...that would be the angle I would suggest. Sure if you can get Sarah Maclaughlin and Joni Mitchell, etc. But they should be paired with people unknown...otherwise the argument goes, that hey the Real Talent rises to the top via capitalism, and all we need is the Top Ten...

      I do have some gear and some experience making films and would be happy to be involved, does anyone know if the major players are doing anything or are they just wringing their hands and too stunned by the severity of the cuts?
      See More
      September 5, 2009 at 10:08pm
    • Jessica Wadsworth Which video should we be looking at? The link takes you to a general page Oliver.
      September 5, 2009 at 10:12pm
    • Oliver Hockenhull No, I is correct to this:
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uhgv85m852Q

      It is called

      "Culture in Danger"
      September 5, 2009 at 10:15pm
    • Jessica Wadsworth Aha! I got it now (for some reason it went elsewhere before).

      I think it's very funny. We will definitely shoot for humour. I'll contact you when I know more about these video clips.
      September 5, 2009 at 10:32pm
    • Oliver Hockenhull A suggestion: what could work in the BC context me thinks is kids...parents laughing and denigrating their kids aspirations say to be 'a dancer' or 'a musician' or 'an artist'...show how insane a British Columbia would be without the aspiration of culture. Culture as the breath of life itself. That the so-called Liberals are taking the breath out of life...ended it be getting the viewer to do a particular action...
      September 5, 2009 at 10:46pm
    • Jessica Wadsworth Thanks Oliver. Let's move this discussion to a thread on the Organizing against Campbell's cuts group. I'd like to open it up to everyone to think of ideas, and there's over 2000 people actively chatting on that page. Could you cut and paste this in there please?
      September 5, 2009 at 11:12pm
    • Jason Neron Campbell is a complete and utter crook. He's selling off BC to his crony friends and driving it into debt at a record pace.
      September 8, 2009 at 2:22pm
    • Don Robinson
      what Gordo is doing is bad business plain and simple .. how do you justify cutting a revenue stream 1.00 = 1.38 back -- um wheres the problem .. oh wait that's right -- he's been privatising profitable crown corporations, so now we pay more... for less... way to go .. and for those of you who couldn't be bothered to VOTE last time around (under 40% turn-out is pathetic) .. this is what you get!!

      Excellent essay Kate .. I hope that all of the media outlets and every single MLA has a copy of this in their inbox.
      See More
      September 9, 2009 at 5:25pm
    • Martin Gover the thing is a totally subsidised organisation (the government) has no real understanding that everyone else is not actually living off subsidies
      September 9, 2009 at 8:23pm
    • Donato Mancini best piece about this crisis that i've seen so far
      September 12, 2009 at 1:34pm
    • Lance Blomgren nice one!
      September 12, 2009 at 3:06pm
    • Jason Nemeth Interesting article, but can you post a citation for the $1.38 thing. Its the ONLY argument that has any interest for those of us more concerned about MSP premiums (which thew buggers also raised) than Ballet tickets. That said, I'd like to see the research that shows this stuff is financially beneficial.
      September 14, 2009 at 8:34am
    • Kate Armstrong The statistic is cited a lot of places but I guess I read it in an article like this CBC one, via Spencer Herbert. http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/cbc/090831/canada/canada_britishcolumbia_bc_arts_funding_cuts_gaming_grants_7
      September 15, 2009 at 6:02pm
    • Adam Buhler looks like i wont be having any exhibits anytime soon....not in BC anyways
      September 16, 2009 at 3:30pm
    • Leigh Christie This is outrageous. What were they thinking??
      September 16, 2009 at 5:34pm