ABS-CBN STATEMENT ON AUG. 23 HOSTAGE TRAGEDY

by ANC 24/7 on Thursday, August 26, 2010 at 12:16am ·

Media's job is to tell the story, but no story is worth even one life.

 

We will always cooperate with authorities in trying to resolve complex situations like the Aug 23 hostage crisis.

 

If the government had called for a news blackout, ABS-CBN would have supported it.

 

We are done with an initial assessment of our coverage and continue to review our policies.

 

We exercised self-restraint on Monday:

1.  We refused to air the hostage taker's threats live about a 3 pm deadline to avoid fuelling public fear.

2.  We refused to air the hostage taker's interview until after negotiations were finished.

3.  We refused to be part of hostage negotiations.

4.  All throughout the day and until the first shots were aired, we kept our cameras 400 meters away from the bus, giving us shaky video that viewers complained about.  Our teams never crossed the police line.

5.  Although we had access to members of the police reaction team, we held back interviews which could compromise their plans and/or location.

6.  After the police tried to arrest the hostage taker's brother, our team physically stepped back to comply with police request. 

7.  After the assault began, we tried to limit our shots to avoid showing police movements.  We stayed with extreme close-ups or wide shots.

8.  We immediately complied when police asked us to turn off our lights explaining the grainy shots viewers complained about.

9.  We avoided tampering with evidence at crime scene.  Instead, we asked Soco to shoot the video instead of entering the bus ourselves.

 

This wasn't enough.

 

We acknowledge airing a report that detailed the position of the police during the assault.

 

During the arrest of Gregorio Mendoza, we considered pulling away from the coverage but a man was crying for help.

 

In other countries around the world, governments set the ground rules for situations like this.  One network cannot unilaterally declare a news blackout.  Press freedom issues take a back seat during situations like this - where the government already has the power to define the terms to media.

 

We are taking the public's views to heart.  Monday's tragic events triggered intense soul-searching for us.  Such is the irony of a profession that wields so much power but relies entirely on self-doubt to gain --- and keep --- its credibility.

 

We ask our broadcast colleagues to join us in an industry review.  Let us unite and work together to put in place measures to collectively decide when we stop live coverage in the absence of government presence of mind.


· Comment · Share
  • Liz Mercado, Mercy Oliveros Desaluna, Lon Cee and 30 others like this.
    • Red Dais
      To all concerned, huwag na tayong magsinungaling sa sarili natin. The blame for this carnage partially rests on the authorities. But media aggaravated the circumstances and led to the shootings. And of course prime blame goes to the hostage... taker and his brother.Why media? Did they restrain themselves? No, of course not. We know how media works, they get paid, they earn money. So they cannot say that this pure service to the people, like some self-serving hero wannabes. Grateful if its for the interest of the people, but hypocrisy if they don't admit that they also put the gore, the sensational stories to compete in ratings. Imagine, police positions? maybe even sniper locations? And they have the gall to issue apologies like these which actually just damage control if you ask me. They even got "played" by the hostage takers brother. Kumbaga pinagsamantalahan sila nung kapatid dahil alam nya na ang media ay matakaw sa scoop. Sabi nila, dapat daw hinarang sila ng pulis, dapat may cordon. So kapag walang cordon yung pulis ok lang na ilabas yung mga police positions, yung mga sensitive events, kasi hindi naman napigilan ng pulis ang media eh. Ganun ba yun? Ayan tuloy uminit ang nasirang ulo ni mendoza. Namaril na. The cops had no choice by then but to launch an assault. Ang problema, pulpol at bagito sa ganung sitwasyon at kulang sa gamit. Naging katatawanan tuloy sa buong mundoSee More
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves Tanong ko lang sa galit na coverage ng ABSCBN at GMA, bkit gnun pag CNN ang may special coverage tinatangap agad ninyo pero pag news natin hindi! Natural lang na ipalabas yan ng live coverage dahil nasa time slot ng news programs! Sa totoo lang nakakahiya tayo dahil imbes na magtulungan at magdasal, nagsisihan pa tayo! Kaya wag kayong magtaka kung may taga hongkong na pinagtatawanan tayo dahil din sa mga ginagawa nyo!
    • Rachel Lim It's so obvious they're after ratings! How can you ignore all the footages being shown on CNN with the ANC logo?
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves Tanong ko lang sa galit na coverage ng ABSCBN at GMA, bkit gnun pag CNN ang may special coverage tinatangap agad ninyo pero pag news natin hindi! Natural lang na ipalabas yan ng live coverage dahil nasa time slot ng news programs! Sa totoo lang nakakahiya tayo dahil imbes na magtulungan at magdasal, nagsisihan pa tayo! Kaya wag kayong magtaka kung may taga hongkong na pinagtatawanan tayo dahil din sa mga ginagawa nyo!
    • Eden Claribel Dunas Dupali ‎@Kz Abesamis: THE MAIN concern of some people is..BAKIT DAW INERE ng media yung nangyayari sa kapatid ni mendoza which might have triggered the anger of Mr. mendoza dahil napanood niya yung nangyayari dun sa TV MONITOR sa loob ng bus na naging dahilan kung bakit siya nagpaputok. Yung image thingy..it's only the 2nd concern when talking about the involvement of the media.
    • Aldrin N. Divera Nanood din ako sa BBC at CNN pero yung broadcast nila e delayed by 15 to 20 sec. E bakit dito sa atin d nila nagawa yon e kung nag self-regulate cla.....Ang government at PNP nag apologize na pero ang media kahit kunting sorry d magawa....
    • Jayrox Crux taas ng rating ng comment ngayon dba...
    • Patrick Mendoza di ako agree sa news blackout, parang nawala na rin ung free speech natin..
    • Francis Espina ‎@Brian: That's f***in' A man!! They should have that.
    • James Black and if the bbc can air it delayed and they not even based here but the local tv has to air it live. Im sure the outcome gave them filthy jounos a great day at the office.
    • Francis Espina Me live coverage ba ang international media nung Monday? Pardon me for asking because I was watching ANC only at that time kasi. :D
    • Patrick Mendoza ‎@francis napanood ko ung the same night sa BBC, wala silang live pero may filipino reporter ang nag bobroadcast kung anong nagyayari sa manila.
    • Ronald Louie Sadiz This is just a SELF SERVING SELF RIGHTEOUS statement from the ABS CBN then point the blame at the government. I dont buy your "crying for help reasoning". Make a backstory for him if you are really concerned for his safety.
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves Meron! Kaya wag yung local media natin ang pulaan nyo kasi maski global news org pabor sa ginawa nting yun!
    • Mary Joselle Dilig Villafuerte I was on my home and was listening to the radio when your reporter(Ron Gagalac) was vividly describing the arrest of the hostage taker's brother, the shots fired,the position of the SWAT team in relation to the bus--Nope--there was no restraint--I felt like I was there, my children heard everything...we felt helpless and horrified for the hostages...
    • Francis Espina So, the adage is true, "Birds of the same feather, flock together".
    • Eden Claribel Dunas Dupali ‎@Patrick Mendoza: Para sa akin..EXCEPTION sa sinasabing freedom of speech yung hostage taking na yun kapatid. Common sense na kapag gan0n na at stake ang buhay ng mga ta0..the media should step back. I'm not blaming the media for what happened..I am just dispensing my opinion about what you've just said.
    • Mac Espinola Gomez
      not acceptable ABS! alam ng field reporter nyo that time na si julius babao ang consequence ang media coverage nyo habang inaaresto ung kapatid ni capt. mendoza. sinasabi nya ke ted failon na bka magtrigger ung incident na yun pra gumawa ng... ndi maganda c capt. mendoza. bakit patuloy kau nag live broadcast? kc scoop yun di ba? aminin nyo!

      at ininterview pa ni ted failon ung kapatid ni capt. mendoza na patunay na nakisawsaw talaga kau ng husto sa sitwasyon. you should also be held liable for that situation ang not only the police. kc ang natural reaction nung iyaking kapatid ni capt. mendoza ay maglupasay kc me live coverage ang media.
      See More
    • Lester Jeff Banatao I saw Sol Aragones in the brother's face with a microphone as he was being restrained on the ground. I saw ABS-CBN, GMA and TV5 microphones closer to the family on the ground than police. I saw reporters squeezing their way between police officers to get scoop. I saw ABS-CBN microphones running towards the driver as he escaped.
    • Lester Jeff Banatao
      Funny how the official statement asks all media colleagues to unite, and yet Maria Ressa washed ABS-CBN's hands clean and indirectly placed blame on the network's competitors. "Mendoza was not watching ABS-CBN." What is that supposed to me...an? All TV stations were showing the exact same thing. All TV stations crossed the line, did not show self-restraint, did not respect common journalistic sense, nor common human sense. And still, with this statement, ABS-CBN News and Current Affairs does not take responsibility for their mistakes, instead defending them. It has nothing to do with press freedom and everything to do with thinking about lives hanging in the balance. Monday's coverage from ABS-CBN and all networks showed the hunger for the "first" scoop and the "exclusive" over human life. See More
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves
      Sa mga komentong ganito sa palagay nyo may panalo?! Yan ang kasiraan ng mga Pilipino nung ginagawa ng local media natin yung live coverage ni-goberyerno walang ginawang aksyon dhl pti sila nanonood dn! Ginawa man yun ng ABSCBN at GMA ayos l...ang sa akin para maging inform tayo! Kung Ch. 4, 9 o 13 yung nag cover nun, manonood ka pa ba sa ABSCBN at GMA? Sinasabi nyo ngayon dapat ABSCBN ang gumawa ng Pagbabago, bkit ikaw bilang Pilipino ginawa mo ba ang parte mo?!See More
    • Brian Enrique Avanceña ‎@Lester I used to have high regard for Ms. Ressa. But after her latest attempts at crisis management, she's been looking more like another paid hack who's trying to save face for her bosses. Disappointing.
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves Imbes na ubusin nyo yung galit nyo sa local media natin na gumawa lang ng kanilang tungkulin, bkt hndi kayo magalit sa mga Hong Kong nationals na nagsasabing tanga, alipin, bobo, tirahan ng ipis(pinas) at ipis ang mga Pilipino sa buong mundo! Dun kayo mainis!
    • Lester Jeff Banatao ‎@Brian, I honestly found Maria Ressa's comments since Monday very irresponsible and almost embarrassing. Instead of admitting faults, she was pointing fingers when instead they should be looking to fix an obviously broken and neglected media system.
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves Imbes na ubusin nyo yung galit nyo sa local media natin na gumawa lang ng kanilang tungkulin, bkt hndi kayo magalit sa mga Hong Kong nationals na nagsasabing tanga, alipin, bobo, tirahan ng ipis(pinas) at ipis ang mga Pilipino sa buong mundo! Dun kayo mainis!
    • Eden Claribel Dunas Dupali
      ‎@Ken Yawhu Talde Teves: We drew the first blood so wala tayo sa posisyon para magalit sa kanilang mga sinasabi..WHO'S at fault? ANG PILIPINAS. OO pareho2 tayong apektado..pero sila ang MAS biktima dit0..reputasyon ang nadumihan sa atin, sa... kanila BUHAY ang nawala. Bakit kami maiinis o magagalit sa kanila gayong may basehan naman sila para magkomento ng ganon? DIBA?

      IT is more proper to say na..kesa magsisihan ay bakit hindi tayo gumawa ng paraan para malinis ang reputation ng Pilipinas. Makiisa na lang tayo sa mga pilipino na nagtwitwit at nagpopost para linisin ang pangalan ng pilipinas.
      See More
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves ‎@eden_ you're ryt! Im proud being a Filipino thats why Im using Filipino symbol in my Prime pic! Sana wag nang mbuo ang away sa pagitan ng isat isa!
      @abet_who will be on her shoe will do the same!
    • Rey Mandreza so your current guest on ANC just point out the exact opposite side of what you guys or maria_ressa pointed out that you need to be told by the police for a news black out in order to comply. this guy just said its not necessary and you, the media should not give the police that power. so, in essence, would we, your viewers, be hearing ABS CBN admitting its errors in monday's bloodbath?
    • Serpent Prophet ABS reporters

      Mon says: nagsitakbuhan na lahat ng media, ako nalang ang natira dito
      Maan says: malapit lang ako sa bus, nagsitakbuhan na lahat ng media ako nalang ang natira dito malapit sa bus.
      Julius says: malapit lang ako sa bus, aatras lang ako ng konti nagsialisan na lahat ng media dito.

      lahat sila malapit sa bus at proud pa ang mga pasaway at mga sinungaling.
    • Cora V. Ines God help us,.It happened already panay pa rin ang finger pointing,complaining will not bring us in the promise land,we made mistake and we learned from it,we have to start all over again to regain our dignity as nation and as a Fil. people..we can only achieve it if we work together to rebuild a better Phil.Move on!
    • Ken Yawhu Talde Teves Sabihin na nating kasalanan ng lahat ng media, ano ang kanilang dapat gawin? Kung hindi nila ginawa hanggang ganito na lang tayo, nagbabangayan?! Bakit hindi natin simulan ang isang hakbang sa ating sarili!
    • Concon Mariposque If only the police from the start had put the isolation line/tape& had the media briefed of what can&cannot air in that particular situation I'm sure the media would oblige. The media just did a job expected from them while the police force did not, it's just as simple as that.
    • Melvin Dionisio
      Mahirap magpaliwanag sa mga taong ayaw makinig ng paliwanag. Obviously, all they want to share on this thread are their vindictives against abs-cbn. You need to watch all the networks who aired the hostage taking incident before you place y...our 'judgement' on one network. They all committed a blunder. Worst are those radio commentator and tv anchor who was talking to the hostage taker minutes before he went bersek. And that mighty anchor who was commentating during the comotion 'rapido rapido'? Most awarded news station 'rapido rapido'See More
    • Eden Claribel Dunas Dupali ‎@DOC MELVIN: yeah that "RAPIDO RAPIDO" and "NARIRINIG MO BA YUNG MGA PUTOK?". LOL
    • Gil Valencia II nangyari na.....wag ng mag malinis sa mga bagay na nangyari na,,..ayusin nlang ang mga pagkakamali at magsimula ulit tungo sa tamang landas :)
    • Rachel Lim She Teodoro: "kaya pasalamat nlng tayo atleast we're informed, fully pa. @She Teodoro: I'd rather be uninformed on the basis that my ignorance might have saved lives.
    • Melvin Dionisio Ang daming hate comments, infairness lahat sila nakatutok sa abs-cbn c: I hope nga nakakatutok sila sa abs kasi insulto naman sa pagkatao ng nagkokomento tapos di naman pala sya nakatutok. Pero ganun pa man, mahirap magpaliwanag sa taong ayaw makinig ng paliwanag... ang tawa dun ay b??o, di ba? Again, your opinion is just an idea and it is not a Fact c: happy viewing to all!
    • Jada Logronio
      Geez.I'm so disappointed with you..HELLOOOOOOO!The nerve of you guys to wash your hands off of what happened when you were also televising the police's EVERY move!And if you were REALLY thinking or concerned,then you should've done that new...s blackout on your own disgression!All media members have faults in the bloody ending of that hostage crisis because everyone knows that the suspect will be watching everything on the TV on board that bus but everyone still kept covering everything that was happening!
      See More
    • Jed Nolan Ramos
      ‎6. After the police tried to arrest the hostage taker's brother, our team physically stepped back to comply with police request

      - this isn't true. you even interviewed gregorio mendoza right when the police is taking him. there is even a...nd EXCLUSIVE interview made by ted failon. i saw all of that on tv and there's no denying it. if it wasn't for that interview, rolando mendoza wouldn't have a chance to see all of it. maria ressa told on anc the other night that someone informed her that mendoza was not watching abs-cbn or anc for that matter, but that's not the case. we're criticizing how you guys cover such a delicate matter such as this tragedy. what happened was media interfered, although not deliberately and intended. for that part, wouldn't it just help for you guys to admit that you had some mistakes? i think people would understand naman, because the likes of this tragedy don't happen everyday. it's understandable for the media to have mistakes on covering such cases because of lack of experience in hostage taking scenarios. and it's not all the media's fault. in the first place, the police should have stern rules and regulations that they should have imposed on the media! sabi nga ni maria ressa, madali naman silang kausap. but the problem is, wala namang kumakausap sa media, walang leadership, walang nag-assume ng command sa buong fiasco on the part of the police.

      i think it's too late to play the blame game at this point. i think what the media can do is to learn from the experience para sa mga future incidents like this eh alam na ang gagawin.
      See More
    • Red Dais
      And maybe media can set their own protocols too. We all know how puny the police handled the case. Media rightly so, must evaluate themselves. Media is not blind, because the people are speaking. I know they will modify their coverage of th...ese kind of situation in the future, pero sana wala na.

      Are people here pointing out media's mistakes perfect themselves? No of course not. But we thrive to be better I believe. It is everyone's responsibility, media, police, whoever. It's just that, if nobody points something wrong, then sooner or later, people would see it as right. Huwag matakot pumuna, hindi mali ang pag-puna. Punahin ang paligid, punahin ang sarili.
      See More
    • Conrad Mallonga
      To ABS CBN: It is sad that all of your points are about safety on your part. About compliance to space and following a set of rules when the fact of the matter is you could have at least gone beyond the call of duty and actually played an a...ctive role.

      The media should be a tool for positive influence and not a hindrance as was shown.

      I think its just and right that you are soul searching but i suggest more soul searching be done before we lose even more lives. And when lives are at stake, sometimes the rules do not matter. What is worth more anyway a life or an hour of footage?
      See More
    • Brian Nebres
      Wait, this is a full story about that:
      They do their own broadcast about hostage in Quirino Grandstand. Since they are LIVE broadcasting, we expect to please go away from the bus 400m away. The issue is how they critizise their network sinc...e the hostage? If it is not reported, the people will say "Why didn't you tell us earlier? Are you sastified for your work?" Then Hong Kong would be more angry to our country. And of course, no one will get their complaint as they do their efforts to get the news quickly and fast. So, How they did it? As you say to us that we are not united? Even other major foreign networks did their jobs. And please for all Philippine network who cover the hostage, don't air it LIVE if you saw really dead people. Because if they air it, people will get angry and dissapointed in their networks. Don't get air it MATURE and NUDITSM. Please, I get some dissapointed with networks. Don't cover if they are gunning. We must say this to all networks to prevent things. And if they want declared a news blackout, I DON'T. Please be extra careful to things. Being a media men is not very easy...See More
    • Brian Nebres Sorry, my statement has doubled.
    • Happy Pat-c ‎@ Patrick Mendoza. I work here in Indonesia and so sad my area don't have TFC. CNN and BBC were doing a live coverage. I was watching both channels alternately in real time.
    • Happy Pat-c
      ‎@ Conrad Mallonga. I believe that ANC did the best they could to be out of the way since police authorities were around. It is okay that they explain to the public how they cooperated by keeping out of the way, but at the same time vigilan...t that something from our police force might do abusively if media weren't around. You would have done the same if it were you.

      If they haven't explained their side, you as well as others will continue to whine on what they did that we ourselves could never ever have achieved despite the risks. Yes, there were failures on their part. But we fail to recognize that we have all failed on that day.

      Their soul searching is but proper so that they will further know their limitations and learn from those. You and I also need to soul search because we are Filipinos and it happened on our very soil.
      See More
    • Ivy Krabye the most scary thing is when the media is hiding something from the people. the truth can be hursh but the truth must come out. when the media will try to hide something from us, then something wrong is going on. it was the police fault because responded very badly and they were very unprofessional.
    • Rowie Azada-Palacios Five of these examples are just examples of following the law (e.g., not tampering with evidence) or of complying with police instructions. Those are things that anyone *should* do. Those aren't examples of "self-restraint."
    • Leon Kuw bakit di nalang gumamit ng salitang tagalog ang mga nasa fact finding board para sa mga tanong nila pati ang mga sasagot eh nag kakandabulol na sila sa kakasalita ng english..............................