Glenn Milne's retracted article in The Australian- 29/08/11: "PM A Lost Cause For Warring Unions"

by John Howard on Sunday, August 28, 2011 at 7:01pm ·

Julia Gillard has lost all authority within the broader Labor movement

THE real import of the alleged brothel creeping scandal surrounding Craig Thomson has been missed. And it is this: key factions and unions within the Labor movement are now openly indifferent to the fate of either Julia Gillard or the federal government. They simply don’t care any more.

Gillard has now lost all authority within the broader Labor movement. By their actions in the Thomson saga they have signalled a judgment that she cannot win the next election. Settling internal scores and power struggles is therefore now more important than whatever happens to a lameduck PM who can’t haul her primary voting numbers out of the pathetically fatal mid 20s.

The Mafia-style dirt-covered shovel — code for digging your own grave — dumped on Friday at 3.30am on the doorstop of Kathy Jackson, the union official who had the courage to refer Thomson’s activities to the police, may as well have been delivered to the Lodge. For Gillard it is now that bad. She is simply regarded as collateral damage and large sections in the Labor movement are uninterested about whether she’s terminally wounded or not as they go about their internal bloodletting. It is about to get worse as elements of the Australian Workers’ Union seek to settle up with Thomson’s accusers by demonstrating that Gillard herself was implicated, albeit unknowingly, in a major union fraud of her own before she entered parliament.

On Friday, Michael Smith of 2UE contacted me to check the veracity of material in a statutory declaration drawn up by Bob Kernohan, the former president of the AWU, and dealing with the relationship between Gillard and Bruce Wilson, which I outline below.

On Saturday, Herald Sun and Daily Telegraph columnist Andrew Bolt wrote on his blog: ‘‘On Monday, I’m tipping, a witness with a statutory declaration will come forward and implicate Julia Gillard directly in another scandal involving the misuse of union funds. Gillard herself is not accused of any misbehaviour at all. I do not make that claim, and do not hold that belief. But her judgment — and that of at least one of her ministers — will come under severe question. She will seem compromised. It could be the last straw for Gillard’s leadership.’’

Big call. But I do have a good deal of knowledge regarding Bolt’s claims. On Sunday November 11, 2007, just days before the November 24 election I interviewed Gillard, then deputy leader of the opposition, in my capacity as political editor for News Limited’s Sunday newspapers. The interview concerned the embezzlement of union funds — not disputed — and later the subject of a court conviction by a former boyfriend of Gillard, Bruce Wilson. I had researched the piece for months. It was the most heavily lawyered article I have ever been involved in writing. The story said that as a solicitor acting on instructions, she set up an association later used by her lover to defraud the AWU. But she has strenuously denied ever knowing what the association’s bank accounts were used for.

Gillard, then in her early 30s, was a lawyer with Melbournebased Labor firm Slater & Gordon. At the time of the fraud she acted for the AWU. She met Wilson, then the West Australian AWU secretary, while representing the union in the Industrial Relations Commission. Wilson later moved to Melbourne to become Victorian secretary of the union.

‘‘These matters happened between 12 and 15 years ago,’’ Gillard told me. ‘‘I was young and naive. I was in a relationship, which I ended, and obviously it was all very distressing. I am by no means the first person to find out that someone close turns out to be different to what you had believed them to be. It’s an ordinary human error.

‘‘I was obviously hurt, when I was later falsely accused publicly of wrongdoing. I didn’t do anything wrong and to have false allegations in the media was distressing.’’

What the lawyers would not allow to be reported was the fact that Gillard shared a home in Fitzroy bought by Wilson using the embezzled funds. There is or was no suggestion Gillard knew about the origin of the money. We now await the issue to which Bolt refers.

If it comes, and if it is powerful as Bolt suggests, it will be further evidence that the Victorian Right represented by the AWU is involved in a life and death struggle with the Right as represented by the Hospital Services Union. Thomson was a senior official of the HSU for 20 years before entering parliament via the seat of Dobell.

The HSU split several years ago into two factions. Thomson was supported by Jeff Jackson, Kathy Jackson’s former husband. This so-called old guard was the support base for Victorian right-wing power boss, David Feeney. Feeney is now looking for a parliamentary seat because Gillard’s abysmal numbers have made his third Senate spot vulnerable.

A defeat for the old guard by way of a successful prosecution of Thomson by police, would leave Feeney powerless and without a base or a seat.

Jackson himself has been accused of using union money on escorts with enemies of the Victorian HSU boss releasing bank statements showing payments to the same Sydney brothel where federal MP Thomson’s credit card was allegedly used. Jackson has denied the claims. Ultimately at issue here could be the succession to Gillard, and I’ll explain why.

When Kathy Jackson called in the wallopers, the stakes were high. Because a federal defeat for Thomson and his allies would enhance the power base of Victoria’s two other factional king makers, Bill Shorten and Stephen Conroy who are both aligned with the new guard in the HSU. And we all know what Shorten’s ultimate ambition is.

What a tangled web we weave especially when you consider Thomson is married to Zoe Arnold, a former Transport Workers Union official and adviser to former NSW Health Minister Reba Meagher. Alex Williamson, daughter of HSU national president Mike Williamson, is an adviser to Gillard. And, of course, as mentioned, Kathy Jackson, who blew the whistle on Thomson, was married to former Victorian state HSU secretary Jeff Jackson.

Truly the NSW Disease has arrived in Canberra.

Meanwhile amid all this interbred internecine manoeuvring Gillard attempts to adopt the high ground, attacking shadow attorney-general George Brandis for intervening in the course of justice. On Thursday morning Gillard attacked Brandis for speaking to NSW Police Minister Michael Gallacher at a time when the allegations against Thomson were being assessed by NSW Police. Unfortunately she got her facts wrong because the NSW police only announced they were conducting an assessment four days after Brandis spoke to Gallacher and in fact only got Brandis’s dossier three days after he spoke to Gallacher.

A small point but one that indicates the pressure is beginning to show on Gillard as she desperately searches for points of deflection. During the same press conference she also vainly tried to defend Thomson’s decision not to make a statement to the parliament on the facts. We all know why; if he lies he’s finished as an MP and Gillard is washed up as Prime Minister. Gillard and Thomson are shackled together just as surely as two First Fleet convicts.

Oh, and here’s a small postscript on which to end. On September 7 at the Wyong Christian School at 2pm there will be the opening of a new hall built with funds from Gillard’s time overseeing the Building the Education Revolution. Thomson is scheduled to attend as the local member. My gut instinct is that both he and the Prime Minister will be otherwise engaged.

· Comment · Share
  • Dorena Black, Adrian Profke, Ruth Bonnett and 50 others like this.
  • 1 share1 share
    • Terrance Mulloy I miss you, John. You were the best PM this country ever had.
    • Truda Cooper Thank you Mr Howard - you're a champ......we miss you so badly!!
    • Colin Capon I didnt read the Austrlian, does this mean the articale was retracted as in not published?
    • Theresia D'Arcy yes! and the people that voted him out are hanging their heads in SHAME..i'm so happy i'm not one of them.
    • Colin Capon ok I found it, the Australian pulled the article and issued an apology. Obviously there was a bit in this article that couold have got them in trouble. I would love to know which bit of the article they considered defamatory
    • Tony Griggs
      Hi John. Now let me ge this right.....there is union support for an enquiry into the newspapers and their reporting. Its probably because articles that tell it as it is like Glenn Milne's are a severe embarassment. Well, this article is abo...ut to be disseminated Australia wide on the internet. Its a classic piece that shows the core of rotten behaviour that is pervading this socialist government. It's also an article that highlights the inept nature of our contemporary system of democracy by the popular press not being able to report the truth for fear of legal action and thuggery by the unions. And these unionists are running our country whilst this sort of corrupt behaviour is going on behind the scenes. Sadly, it doesnt surprise me. In fact not a lot surprises me anymore. Either I am growing older and wiser or older and cynical!!!See More
    • Howard Beale Labor's worst nightmare "Hookergate" becomes "Uniongate" and a Royal Commission wipes out the union powebase
    • Douglas Cummins Never before has a country so needed strong leadership as now, Australia is crying out for a leader with direction to pull us from this quagmire we currently find ourselves in and the name on every bodies lips is John Winston Howard. Mr Howard your county needs no calls upon you to once again take control of our future and lead us back on to the path of prosperity and good morals. Please answer that call, we beg you.
    • Lloyd Robbins Gillard and Thompson may be shackled together but dont be surprised if she chews her own arm off in the coming weeks to try and save her self. This is the woman who stabbed Rudd in the back and " won " the last election on a blatant lie, She's not about to be taken down by a devient like Craig Thompson.
    • David Rees Thanks John . I always had my suspicions about this cind of thing happening . Now you have confirmed it .
    • Jacquie Moses cannot believe the Australian apologised !
    • David Daniel Ball
      I am glad Milne wrote it. I am sorry he retracted it. I don't see the harm in it, it all seems to be public knowledge. I don't think it goes far enough in some of its assertions. The government has crumbled, but it will be a time before we ...see what that means. It will mean bad decisions are made daily and hard decisions are shelved. In those terms it is business as usual. My own issue of fighting for justice for Hamidur Rahman touches on these people elliptically. What we are seeing is the internal workings of the ALP as it has functioned since the Razor Gang days. The only really surprising thing is that we are seeing it. And it should be disturbing for those who are aware that union dues account for over a $billion each year and union secretaries are not bound to tight fiscal rules of expenditure.See More
    • Steve Pepper Hookergate. Love it !
    • George Mcmillan John, Thanks for posting that article.
    • Isabelle Vallin-Thorpe Great read....
    • Antonio Osmar tenha um bom dia e uma segunda-feira cheia de felicidades!
    • Chris Sherlock ‎"Hospital Services Union". Can't even get basic facts right. Nice one.
    • David Daniel Ball Chris, that is a historical name?
    • David Daniel Ball There is regional issues within the nationwide union. In Queensland it only covers certain peoples ..
    • Andrea Kleeven There wouldn't be anyone that could even invent a story as good as this to sell as a soap opera. It has more twists and turns than roller coaster in a Speilberg movie.
    • Jenny Fuller Tangled web indeed, can't wait to see them all trapped in it.
    • Mike J Warr
      Its a sea of nepotism and corruption. The real question is when and who has the intestinal fortitiude to reign in the unions and make them accountable by registering them as a non profit corporation under the corporations act. This would me...an that their books are externally auditted and they had to do quarterly and annual returns. You run a block of homeunits or a charity or a business like this, yet we cant run a staff association like this. The members pay a fee, that is for a service. Once of the implied services of the union is the proper financial governance and accountability.See More
    • Mike J Warr
      Dear Prime Minister John Howard, There is a photo of you on the internet sipping Champagne in your retirement that is captioned "How is that change working out for you ? " I am not sure whether you like the photo, however, many people do. I...nspired by that question, sir, despite its appropriateness, I would just like to say that the change has not worked out for either, Australia, the Future Fund, The future of Australia, Governance, Fiscal Restraint or democracy as a whole. Thank you for your leadership and I am sure there are many people that share this view.See More
    • Leeanne Meredith Oschmanns
      Daniel Katz, you have certainly hit the nail on the head here. This is so incredibly shameful and I shudder to think how we look on the world stage. People were quick to knock Mr Howard. The point is, he showed leadership, and not everythin...g that a leader does will be liked by the people. But, witness what we now have. I would venture to say that not only is the grass from before greener, it is glowing luninescent. Things are so bad, that we maybe need John Howard to come out of retirement and fix things. But ofcourse, that is not going to happen. Eventually, Christopher Pyne may hold future promise for the leadership of this country. As for Andrew Bolt, thank God for journo's like him!See More
    • David MacKenzie What an amazing process of Corruption and Nepotism. Thank you Mr Howard for showing us the Tax Payer and the Voter as to what the ALP and Unions get up to behind their walls of secrecy
    • Ruth Bonnett Could everyone who reads this please 'like' and 'share'? This message must get out. Thanks Isabelle Vallin-Thorpe for sharing.