Archibald's unpublished column.

by Kyle Whitmire on Monday, April 19, 2010 at 1:58pm ·
Here is the Archibald column the Birmingham News spiked. Publishing it here without their permission probably breaks some law, but to hell with it. If they don't like it, they can come and get me.

One more thing to note, the paragraph breaks were not clear in the copy I received, so I made some guesswork.



John Archibald's unpublished column

It’s hard to look at Ginny MacDonald today and not hear The Neville Brothers in my head, singing their version of that old hymn, “Will the Circle Be Unbroken.”Undertaker, undertaker,Won’t you please drive real slow?That Miss Crazy, that you carry,I sure hate to see her go.I hate to see her go.

Plus, I want to see the bumper snicker on her hearse. What does it say?

Reports of my death have been greatly exacerbated.

No. Ginny Mac — Birmingham News transportation diva and Driver’s Side columnist — is not exactly dead. Not to you, anyway.But today is her last day as a full-timer in the newsroom. She’ll keep writing a weekly column on Mondays, but no more front page stories from her about bridge collapses, speed traps or trooper madness.

Why do I tell you this? Because you buy the paper, most of you, and you know Ginny. You have a right to know that she, like so many experienced and trusted news gatherers, has taken a company buyout.

Today is a dark day at The News. It marks the last day not only for Ginny, but for health writer Anna Velasco. By May veteran political writer Tom Gordon — with more stored memory than an iPad — will be gone. So will young Erin Stock.

It’s not just a News thing, it’s a news thing. They tell us, in fact, that our readership is good and ad revenue is rebounding. But technology and economics have worn on profitability in all news operations. Ours is no exception.

But it hurts. In all, since buyouts were offered in 2008, The News has lost more than 500 years of reporting experience. Decorated reporter Dave Parks — who pretty much discovered “Gulf War Syndrome” — went. State Editor Glenn Stephens, who could pilot a newsroom through a storm with an even keel, is gone. Food writer Jo Ellen O’Hara left us, as did outdoor writer Mike Bolton.

We’ve lost 32 people in the newsroom. Twenty were reporters, the real workhorses.

That may look small next to losses at the Raleigh News & Observer, which has seen its news staff fall from 250 to 115, or the Atlanta Journal Constitution, which cut 93 news staffers in one chunk last year. But it hurts.

If there is good news, it is that The News still has 125 people working to gather the news in Alabama’s largest newsroom.

Still, we mourn the losses to the News family. We mourn the loss to readers, to this community, to the republic.

As legendary editor Gene Roberts told a group of journalists last week in New York, journalism job cuts are more than economic news. They’re a matter of public interest.

“This not just a problem for journalism, this is a problem for democracy,” he said. “What a democratic society does not know, it cannot act upon.”

He is right. You need to know. Think of what you know of your government, and try to separate it from the news. Alabama’s most notable corruptions — Don Siegelman, Guy Hunt, Larry Langford, Jeff Germany, the two-year college system — all started with reporters on the ground. Issues such as the county’s bond debt and crime in neighborhoods bubble to light in the press.

Those of us left in the newsroom will keep digging. For readers. For the republic. For ourselves, for Ginny and Dave and Anna.

We believe there will always be a need, and a market, for news.There better be. News, as Roberts put it, is “democracy’s food.”

“If we are going to come up with solutions, then democratic society has to understand that there is a problem,” he said.It’s not just our problem.

John Archibald’s column appears Sundays, Wednesdays and Fridays. Write him atjarchibald@bhamnews.comJohn Archibald eating lunch at Archibald's BBQ. (Ribs were amazing.)
Share
    • Sonja Renea You are such a rebel...
    • Perle Champion Thanks for the update. I don't think the news is listening. Slowly but surely, the Birmingham News is devolving - not to trivialize, but I hit tilt when Scarritt's column a few Sunday's back explained the downsizing of the sunday comics's. I ranted on my blog**, and sent him a rant with link. Got no response whatsoever. Not even a gth... **http://tinyurl.com/y7t3wym Sad :(
    • Perle Champion Charles - if I thought I could get in, I would. Applied for job some time back with the failed 'Lipstick Mag' and getting past security is a feat.
    • Karl Seitz Leave it to The Birmingham News to try to suppress confirmation of what is obvious to anybody who reads it: The paper is on a course to give up its right to be called a NEWSpaper.
    • Kyle Whitmire Please link and share with your Facebook friends.
    • Sonja Renea Done!
    • Michael Willard
      OK, as a N.C. resident now, I admit I don't see the News often. But when I come home, I see the print edition, often several days' worth. My parents are loooooong time subscribers and as such are likely to blame/responsible for my own journ...alism career. That digression may taint perception of my comments, but I'll forge ahead.
      One of the first things I always read: Driving Miss Crazy. I don't even live in your Tragic City, and yet, Ginny Mac was always a must read. And now The News has up and bought her out. Its a shame.
      An even bigger shame is the fact that when John offered a real explanation for all these missing faces, a perfectly logical, totally P-C reason, Scarritt and the big boys at the top axed it. Not only do I not see any problems in this column, I think it completely illustrates the lack of spine for the people driving that sinking ship.
      Archibald makes great points for the work we of the ink-in-our-blood set accomplish. It is a fucking shame the Birmingham News no longer supports the essential missions to which reporters and journalists dedicate themselves - a quest for truth. Why else would they hide it?
      With that in mind, I wish The News good luck in its future life as a bird-cage liner and window washer. It is no longer good enough to serve as MY fishwrapper.
      See More
    • Charles Kennedy
      It is a very sad day when an honestly-written column like this doesn't get published in the Birmingham News. I cannot for the life of me think of why this shouldn't have been published. It is certainly true the the times are changing, with ...print media very much on the wane. Cutbacks of one sort are inevitable. Nevertheless, the owner of the Birmingham News (in actuality a corporation outside of our state that happens to own many other newspapers), in offering incentives to local reporters to leave, is only hastening its demise. As more and more of these seasoned local reporters have left the scene, all that will be left is a shell of a paper that mainly prints news coming from about five or six corporate-owned media conglomerations. Local news, which is the most important news for all of us (especially in these urgent times), will suffer. The more earnestly concerned among us will, in turn, look to the various local alternative media and blogs on the internet that will pop up in compensation to the lack of quality local reporting at the News, in order to find out what is going on. Perhaps the Birmingham News itself will come to its end, as few will want to be bothered with a mere skeleton of a paper.

      One of the keys to the preservation of a free society is a free press, and that begins at the local level. Tragically, we have lost a true free press in our newspapers with respect to national and world news Again, I point to the five or six corporations that provide most of our national and world news: what is wrong with this picture?

      For the record, I have not subscribed the Birmingham News for nearly a year now, and I am in no hurry to resume my subscription (I can find it in the recycling bins in my building). Also, I must reveal that I have yet to pick up a Birmingham Weekly since Kyle's last column. Maybe that isn't fair. But I am very thankful for the good, honest journalism and thoughtful writing of people like John Archibald and Kyle Whitmire - even if I don't always agree with everything that is said... and that is perfectly OK and just how it should be in a free society.
      See More
    • Gerry Daniel Kyle, thanks for publishing John's column, the issue of journalists that will help keep an eye on things and alert the public to issues is a vital resource
    • Helen Rivas Thanks, Kyle. I sent a note immediately to Erin Stock, who has been doing a lot of good reporting.

      What can be done to support responsible, professional journalism?
    • Punky Burwinkle Thanks, Kyle. We owe you yet another one. And I couldn't see one thing in that column worthy of disclaimer by The News. Good grief! A sad commentary indeed.
    • Jamie Harding I hope he doesn't get fired over this. There won't be anyone left. I will be honest in stating that there has been some extremely inaccurate (especially recently) reporting about my employer, Regions. I have about given up on any kind of thorough reporting there.
    • Kim Downs Thanks for printing the column. We need people like you and John in Birmingham to get all the facts.
    • Scott Schablow
      In 1964 my family picked up stakes and moved to Alabama from the Midwest. Political and racial unrest was beginning to boil. Alabama was, at the time, anything but progressive. My mother told me years later how she was saddened when she pic...ked up a copy of the Birmingham News and said it was just a 'pitiful excuse for a paper" (comparing it to Chicago & Milwaukee). She said she held the paper and wept. Over the years the paper has grown, talent has blossomed and The Birmingham News became a 'real paper' - as in respected and award-winning. Now I will be the one that will soon hold what I fear it will become: modern society's excuse for a newspaper. I'll shed a tear not for the distribution method (paper or digital) but for the talent, the experience, the insight, the checks and balances we have lost. And inevitably, eventually, our free society.

      P.S. John Archibald is the reason I still subscribe to the News. He doesn't pull any punches. Too bad his management does not subscribe to the same high standards.
      See More
    • Kyle Whitmire It occurs to me that somebody might eventually try to make me take this down. So if anyone wants to contribute to the cause, please feel free to copy this and paste it in a note on your Facebook pages. If a lot of people do this, the column will never die.
    • Phillip Edens Someone ought to take a full page ad out in The News and just run it there. Would they seriously turn down the money?
    • J Matthew Cobb Thanks Kyle for posting this. This is sad. I know how bad the written press is hurting now. All of us are hurting. But what pains me the most is when we fail to be transparent with out readers and listeners. Goodness, that's what they expect from us. To tell the news. Birminghamians and abroad need to really read this column...and face the music. It's such a sad tune.
    • Sandra Storm
      It is sad. But not really news. Everyone knows that all newspapers are hurting. Look at the NYTimes. I agree that this is scary for us. I read a front page article in the morning News and knew it was not researched and that the headli...ne was misleading but hey, I still want my paper with my coffee. A computer screen will never be the same for me. Hard times but some good editing and fact digging would help. Just hard times. Sorry for all the good people at the News.See More
    • Punky Burwinkle
      I hear you. There is just something about the daily ritual of going out to fetch the morning paper that cannot be duplicated by clicking a few keys. Maybe it is a generational thing, but there is just something about being able to hold in... your hand what you are reading; to be able to turn the pages and make rustly sounds. The Bham News has lost so many good reporters, and has shrunk so. It is indeed sad that the management killed a column that didn't tell us anything we didn't already know, except some some of the names.

      Would Watergate have happened without a newspaper? Without good reporters and a brave editor? And would we even have Superman without The Daily Planet?

      The whole thing is just tragic. And makes me sad. As I sit here in front of my computer, reading and typing. Ironic, huh?
      See More
    • Wade Kwon Kyle was kind enough to allow Media of Birmingham to repost the column. We added some additional context and relevant links:

      http://mediaofbirmingham.com/2010/04/20/john-archibald-column-the-birmingham-news-buyout/
    • Franklin Biggs
      Kyle, John and all the other journalists...thanks for all the years and hard work. It saddens me to think about all of the shenanigans that will go on because of a lack of reporter presence, which in itself keeps things somewhat honest. Y...es, it is too bad that we cannot trust people to do the right thing just because it is the right thing...at least fear of reporters keep some folks and businesses on the straight and narrow. A sad commentary on our times.See More
    • Ron Council
      The first dollar I earned, other than mowing lawns, was as a news photographer for Ensley's Industrial Press, and I subsequently served the Post-Herald, UPI, The Camden New Jersey Courier Post, The St. Petersburg Times and the Sun Papers he...re in Birmingham as a photographer, reporter and editor. I am saddened by some media friends retiring early and the shrinking of news print media. Let's pray that we don't lose another American "USA" treasured institution and tradition envied in all the world. Unfortunately the culprit is education or our inattention to it. We are growing population and not growing in literacy or education at an alarming rate. If we don't remedy this, say "so long" to newspapers, magazines, driving manuals, printed instructions, etc., adinfinitum!See More
    • Helen Rivas Scott: John, Eddie, Tom Spencer, Joey, Robin, Bob, Ginny ''sí'
      I talked to Erin Stock yesterday, she's going for a master's at the Clinton School for Public Service in Little Rock, a plan made earlier.