Difference between EDS III and other kinds of hypermobility
Displaying all 6 posts.

Post #1
1 reply
Emily wroteon August 19, 2009 at 11:09am
I saw a geneticist a while ago to see if I have EDS III, and after the appointment I am still not sure. lol He said I don't have the dangerous kind of EDS (which I already knew) but then he went back and forth calling what I do have non-EDS hypermobility and EDS III. What is the difference between the two, or are they the same thing? I guess it doesn't matter because dysautonomia is my main problem, but it would be nice to know just in case the treatment is different.

Post #2
Holly wroteon August 19, 2009 at 12:28pm
My geneticist explained it that hypermobility syndrome is the presence of hypermobile joints and pain. EDS III is a genetic collagen disorder which can therefore cause problems with other connective tissues (e.g. uterine prolapse and issues with pregnancy/childbirth). some specialists believe that they are the same disorder...and they are obviously very similar. I find that doctors take my EDS diagnosis more seriously than firends i know who are DX with HMS.

Post #3
Sarah wroteon August 21, 2009 at 5:38am
It is possible to have more than one type of EDS at the same time, every person is different but within the same spectrum of symptoms.
It is also now being considered by many doctors that HMS is actually EDS.
There is little treatment that is standard either, just different coping methods.
It is also now being considered by many doctors that HMS is actually EDS.
There is little treatment that is standard either, just different coping methods.

Post #4
Emily wroteon August 21, 2009 at 11:43am
That probably explains why I am so confused :0) Thanks!

Post #5
Melissa replied to Emily's poston August 22, 2009 at 8:20am
Hello Emily,
Check out the Benign Hypermobility Syndrome discussion topic here. It is several pages back, but it tackles this topic quite well, I think, and I believe will give you your answers. Here, Dr. Brad Tinkle states his view that EDS III and HMS are the same thing. Also, he has written a book on EDS III and HMS that is also very helpful. He refers to them both as one intenity = EDS-HMS. Check it out.
Check out the Benign Hypermobility Syndrome discussion topic here. It is several pages back, but it tackles this topic quite well, I think, and I believe will give you your answers. Here, Dr. Brad Tinkle states his view that EDS III and HMS are the same thing. Also, he has written a book on EDS III and HMS that is also very helpful. He refers to them both as one intenity = EDS-HMS. Check it out.

Post #6
Melissa wroteon August 22, 2009 at 8:23am
Also, treatment is the same for both.
I also feel patients with EDS diagnosis are taken more seriously.
I also feel patients with EDS diagnosis are taken more seriously.


