Legal Wrangling over Obama Hope Poster--Right or Wrong?

Displaying all 7 posts by 5 people.
Post #1
1 reply
Portfolio Creative Staffing wroteon February 6, 2009 at 5:48am
Street artist Shepard Fairey is in hot water over using a photo reference for the now-famous Obama Hope poster. AP is alleging copyright infringement for the photo reference he used, the artist says he changed it significantly enough that there is no infringement.

Full story is here: http://ping.fm/PmHYB

What do you think? Artists use photo-reference, swipe, inspiration boards, competitive shopping and a million other sources every day. Does this cross the line?
Post #2
Portfolio Creative Staffing wroteon February 6, 2009 at 5:48am
Catherine Lang-Cline:

As an artist, I hate when this kind of stuff happens. On one hand, he used the photo. But on the other it is his interpretation. And its WAY cooler then the photo. :-)
Post #3
Portfolio Creative Staffing wroteon February 6, 2009 at 5:49am
Tammy Hershey:

I agree with Catherine, it's a boring photo, but a way cool poster...
Post #4
Daniel wroteon February 6, 2009 at 7:01am
Good day,

As a professional photographer I have been seeing this kind of thing everywhere, especially with President Obamas likeness. Mr. Fairey is just in hot water because he attempted to use someones copyrighted work and pass it off as original without permission or credit for the originator. He would be just as unhappy if someone had photographed his work and marketed it ass their own and made a bundle.

Regards,

Dan Floss
Post #5
Bill wroteon February 6, 2009 at 7:27am
Good artists copy. Great artists steal.

~ Pablo Picasso

http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Artist
Post deleted on February 8, 2009 at 6:17am
Post #7
Brooke replied to Portfolio Creative Staffing's poston February 17, 2009 at 8:04pm
Shepard Fairey has made his whole career out of presenting the work of others (photos, silkscreens, etc) through his own cool aesthetic. While his images certainly stand on their own, I think that he is a plagiarist in that he isn't crediting his source.