40 Reviews
People talk aboutcreamy garlic dressing
Tell people what you think
Chris Smith
· September 23, 2017
We tried this place after reading some reviews it was not far from the zoo so we thought why not. This place is awesome. The food is delicious, reasonably priced and great service. The hot dogs were... delicious and the sandwiches were outstanding. The homemade garlic dressing for their salads and pizza is like crack. We love trying local places when we visit Seattle and this place did not disappoint. See More
Jim Zahora
· August 13, 2017
Die hard pizza man here, and a Chicagoan. Ordered a Large Pepperoni, and I must say this is not a true representation of what makes a Chicago Deep Dish Pizza. Crust is to soft, and too thin overall, ...and to thick on the bottom, cheese reminds me of the lower end cheese you get in mozzarella sticks. A true Chicago deep dish has the toppings in the middle hence why in Chicago its not called "Deep Dish" in most places but a "Stuffed Pie". For Seattle pizza its not bad but to put "Chicago" in the name is somewhat sacrileges. For pizza in Seattle I'd give it a 6.5 out of 10, compared to places like Lou Malnati's (which is what this somewhat resembles) I'd say 4.8 out of 10 and compared to places like Giordano's, Home Run Inn, there's not even a point to compare them. Overall while not being bad pizza you could not serve this in Chicago and stay in business. See More
Cherry Cuff
· August 12, 2017
This place is super good! Excellent deep dish ... My mouth was in heaven... Great service and atmosphere too!
Chuck Reichert
· May 22, 2017
Ben is a delightful guy from Chicago's West Side. He understands deep dish Chicago pizza, Italian Beef and most importantly creamy garlic dressing.

They have an excellent variety of local craft, good wines and Chicago style hot dogs to seal the deal! For a refugee from Chicago, I found a sanctuary joint! See More
Dani Marie Page
· March 18, 2017
I'm from Bloomington, IL and moved out to the Seattle area a few years ago. I've been wanting to try Benito's for forever. So glad we came in! Everyone was friendly, the food was AMAZING, and we loved... feeling a little at home all the wait out here. We will definitely be back😃! See More
Ryan Hester
· June 20, 2015
The absolute finest deep dish this side of south-side Chicago and one of Seattle's best small businesses. The cornmeal crust and fresh's epic!
Isaac Curtis
· April 24, 2017
My boyfriend is from Chicago and he took me here to get as close as I could to the real thing. OMG. So so so good. Get double sausage.
Patti Lebeau
· June 30, 2017
Best Chicago style �, hot beef sandwich, go here! You will not be disappointed.
Rob Mathison
· June 14, 2016
I seriously love this pizza and the people who work there. Saucy, thick, tasty pizza. My only complaint is I wish I could eat more than 2 pieces without my stomach hurting. :)
Julie Darling
· March 27, 2016
If you find yourself in Seattle be sure to stop in and say hi to the crew at Benito's. Warm, welcoming, great food, good times, and reasonably priced! Worth the stop and highly recommended. XOXO
Chris Shatto Osbjornsen
· May 20, 2017
Great food Nice people. Great dj aswome place To eat at
Elli Ot
· April 18, 2016
Chicago deep dish, Chicago dogs, and Italian beef all in one place?? Hells yeah!
Steven Bradford
· October 24, 2015
Very good deep dish, salads and sandwiches. My BF is from Chicago and he confirms this.
Sarah D Fast
· November 6, 2016
First time in and the Chicago dog was excellent! Highly recommend.
Michelle Hernandez
· July 18, 2015
Yummy yummy pepperoni slice with creamy garlic dressing and a coke to wash it down ;-)!!
Chase Bottorff
· April 29, 2014
You're not going to find better Chicago-style food anywhere in Seattle!
You're only regret will be you didn't get there sooner...
Ricky Rossi
· August 5, 2016
Do I have the option of having my sandwich dipped?
Benito's Chicago Eatery is feeling hungry.
February 9

Hey’s National Pizza Day!! Mmmmmm Deep Dish!!!

Image may contain: food

Ok it is that time of year is time for Benito’s Chicago Eatery to take their bi-annual vacation!!! We will be taking Christmas Eve 12/24/17 thru 1/2/18 off for some R&R!! We shall reopen on Wednesday 1/3/18. We will be running our normal hours till close on Saturday 12/23/18.

Have a very Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays and Happy New Year to all of our wonderful patrons!!

-Benito and Staff

No automatic alt text available.

Good evening friends and patrons! We regret to inform you that we will be closed for dinner service tonight due to a maintenance issue in our building. But never fear, we will be open again Wednesday on normal winter hours!

Thanks for your understanding
-Benito's staff

Good afternoon! We would like to inform our patrons that we will be closing at 5pm today for a company function. We will be open again Wednesday on normal winter business hours.

Thank you for your patronage, and belated Happy Thanksgiving!

Mr. Loucious would like inform you that Benito’s Chicago Eatery is going to try something new! We are going to switch to winter hours. We will still be open Wednesday thru Sunday and closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, but our hours will be as follows;
Wednesday’s and Thursday’s 11:30am till 9:00pm
Friday’s and Saturday’s 11:30am till 10:00pm and Sunday’s 12:00pm till 9:00pm

We will continue our policy of stopping pizzas one hour before we close as usual.


Thanks as always for your support and patronage!!

-Benito & Staff

See More
Image may contain: dog, sky, outdoor, nature and water

Eddy regrets telling you that we are not going to do lunch for one more week. We will open for dinner at 4:00p 8/30/17-9/2/17. We will do lunch and dinner Sunday 9/3/17.
Starting Wednesday 9/6/17 we will resume normal lunch and dinner service. We have found a new server!
Thanks for your patients and sorry for any inconvenience!

Image may contain: dog

Loucious hates to inform everybody that lunch will be suspended again this week, 8/23-8/26. We will open for dinner service those days at 4pm. Sunday 8/27 lunch and dinner will be served. Again our apologies for any inconvenience.

Image may contain: dog

Benito is vexed......still having trouble with staffing! Because of this we are forced to suspend lunch for this week 8/16- 8/19. We will do lunch and dinner service Sunday 8/20. The restaurant will open for dinner service at 4pm for the next 4 days. We will do our best to find a few good servers to fill the roster, until then we will play lunch service by ear. Thanks and sorry for any inconvenience.

Image may contain: 1 person, selfie and closeup

Poor Jason is just wearing a splash apron cause of the unusually high temperatures! That's too hot, so we decided to suspend lunch service for Wednesday, Thursday and Friday. We will play Saturday and Sunday by ear.

We will be doing dinner all week. Dinner service will start at 4 pm and run till our usual closing times.




See More
Image may contain: 1 person, standing and indoor

A picture is worth a 1,000 this case bowl of super awesome Gazpacho!!!! Ice cold and refreshing!!

No automatic alt text available.

Fast Eddy says it's "Meaty, Beefy, Big & Blusey" tonight!! Starts 6ish and goes till?? So, be one of the cool kids and come on down for ice cold beer and phenomenal deep dish pizza!!

Image may contain: dog

OK.....boss is feeling twitchy again, so it is time for vacation!! Benito's Chicago Eatery will close starting 5/27/17 and we will reopen on Wednesday 6/7/17 for the start of our 6th year!! Thanks to all for the fantastic support!!

Image may contain: 2 people, people smiling, people sitting

Blues Night from 6:15 to 9:15! Bring your vinyl and your appetite!

Happy birthday to our fearless leader, Chef Benito! This guy works all day, every day, to make your experience at Benito's an amazing one. Make sure to stop by soon to wish him well and eat some of his delicious food. We love you, Ben!!

Image may contain: 3 people, people smiling, sunglasses, drink and text

Heads up, ya'll, no blues night tonight. Instead of spinning records Jason will be serving, so make sure to still come in and say hey to your favorite DJ!