68 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Crystal Taylor
· December 17, 2017
I went there for the first time lastnight. Our server, Chrissy was just wonderful. When she wasn’t being attentive to us, she was cleaning cleaning cleaning. As a customer, it was nice to see how impo...rtant cleanliness was to the staff. I got the french onion soup as an appetizer, that was great. The Brisket for my entree, which I would gladly get again. Cheesecake for dessert was just delightful. I really have no constructive criticism for Cattlemans. Everything was pretty on point. Food was wonderful, prices were fair, the staff genuinely want you to leave happy and full and the place is super clean. They even had Christmas movies playing on their TV, for a cute holiday touch. My family will definitely be going back. � See More
Marc Mauss
· November 5, 2017
Our Blue Knights chapter, from Long Island, stopped in for lunch while on a motorcycle ride. There were eight of us, and we were treated very well. The food was excellent, the waitress was friendly ...and extremely accommodating. If I had to find something bad to say it would be that the food didn't all come out at the same time, but that was no big deal.

We will definitely stop here again any time we're in the area.
See More
LaFamilia Trinidad
· March 18, 2018
One of our favorite restaurants in Ellenville. Service is great and food is always delicious. We decided to have them cater our event this weekend. They did an amazing job, our guests loved the food a...nd the prices were very reasonable!!! Thank you See More
Joseph Pisano
· November 25, 2017
I had a wrap. Potato salad wasn't that good, the pickle was miniscule, portions were too small, for the price. I will not be going back to the Cattleman's Grill, but at least I tried it.
Petra Stephens Ferraro
· July 11, 2017
Awesome meal! We arrive rather late - about 30 minutes to closing time and we were not turned away. Staff was very attentive. Offered great suggestions and our meal was absolutely delicious. Best lobs...ter tails I have had in a very long time - no additional butter required - so flavorful. Prime rib was like butter and melted in your mouth. Great food, awesome drinks and wonderful company. Can't wait to go back! See More
Iris Goliger
· July 11, 2017
I was excited to try another restaurant in town and so we chose the Cattleman's Grill. What a MISTAKE!

Three if us went for a late lunch on Friday. The place was nearly empty (only one couple eating ...inside in the front corner). We sat outside like we used to do when dining at the old Gabys.

The server was young and inexperienced but very nice. We each ordered $26 ribeyes and asked for double salads, no potatoes. The owner/manager would not make the change for us and sent the server over with the message. Poor girl felt terrible and to be frank, she had reason to be upset because she knew what we didnt--that the food would suck also!

Our meals came out quickly but we all knew theyd be poor as soon as they arrived. The thin and measly steaks we got were of poor quality...seriously! I have bought better choice meat in a second rate supermarket to feed my dogs. I ordered a riveted and got leather!

Inexperienced server, lousy management and poor food. This is not a recipe for success. I hope that they go out soon so that someone who wants to be a oresence in the growing dining scene in Ellenville can open a steakhouse or other eatery worth visiting!

Cattleman's Grill sucks. What a terrible dining experience that lost this "business" some Ellenville restaurant diners who really wanted to love it!
See More
Candice Gomes
· October 15, 2017
The food is fantastic! Thank you to our waitress Colleen, for taking such great care of us. Your the best!! 😊👍🏻
Jaclyn Martucci Holmes
· October 21, 2017
Amazing service and food ! We had the filet special and it was cooked perfect and served very fast!
Ruben Katie Reyes
· February 17, 2018
Good food one dinner was enough for 2 people. I would go back 100 times
Nakisha Juliet Martinez
· October 3, 2017
Overheard the owner telling the waitstaff they they will be taking their tips.
I’m pretty sure that isn’t legal, my husband and I will be looking into that.
Manal Mady
· March 17, 2018
Corned beef and cabbage was��! Thank you for a delicious lunch!!
Kisha Juliet
· May 12, 2017
Sheesh. An hour and a half we waited. Where's the salad? Oh it came after the leather steaks. The gentleman who waited on us was so awesome though. As I sat there on the verge of tears offering him a ...taste of what was on my plate. The gentleman didn't charge us a cent although I wanted to pay for my kids food, he wouldn't allow it. That's good customer service even if I had a horrible experience. See More
Adele Bonné
· February 12, 2018
Service was excellent. Server was very helpful nothing was too much trouble.
The food that my Husband and I chose was lovely. My steak was cooked perfectly. Would definitely return.
Ellen Hamilton Salovich
· April 6, 2017
I went yesterday with my husband. I had the fried chicken with a baked potatoe. my husband had ribs. the salad was great and dressing homemade. bread with dip excellent. ribs were fall of the bone ten...der. my chicken, unfortunately was over cooked twice. I will def go back. love the menu but won't get the chicken again. The baked potatoe tasted boiled to me as well. Fries were amazing. See More
Sally Ward
· August 7, 2017
Hand-cut french fries great burgers and awesome pulled pork. Margaritas are delicious and the staff was awesome. A must-try
Ronnie Belner Weissman
· June 7, 2017
I believe your menu ihas to many options
I think you should concentrate on a few things that you make great! Then you can have specials. We ate here I liked mine but not everyone at the table was happ...y with what there got. Good Luck! See More
Brian VanDemark
· March 9, 2018
Had the Prime rib that was absolutely delicious. Looking forward to the next time going.
Diane Andrade
· September 15, 2016
We have been there several times and I must say I am very impressed. The wait staff is very good and the food is amazing!!! Where else in Ellenville can you get fresh blue point oysters and soft she...ll crab. From the London broil sandwiches to fresh homemade soups, and their awesome seafood and oh yes they DO have amazing fries. They also have a wonderful brunch that is a MUST try on Sundays you will not be disapointed. Oh yeah and their turtle cheesecake is to die for See More
Barbara Holland Kelly
· January 3, 2017
This was a great find for us, we don't get to Ellenville often, had never heard of it before. We were very impressed..the food was awesome! I had chicken orzo soup that was delicious! My Reuben and hi...s tacos were also excellent. Our waitress ,Colleen , was so helpful and personable! I was glad we got to meet the cook, Luis, to thank him in person.. See More
Melissa Wilhelm
· January 28, 2017
Food was good and our waitress was very efficient. The only complaint was that after the first basket of bread (which was 1 slice for each person) they charged for additional slices. That was a big tu...rn off. I've never been to a restaurant that charged for a bread basket. See More

corned beef & cabbage

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: people sitting, drink and indoor
Image may contain: food
Image may contain: drink and indoor
Image may contain: 1 person, sitting, table, drink and indoor
Cattleman's Grill added 4 new photos.

Saint patrick’s day weekend specials . good food and good drinks


Saint patrick’s day weekend specials . good food and good drinks

Image may contain: people sitting, drink and indoor
Image may contain: food
Image may contain: drink and indoor
Image may contain: 1 person, sitting, table, drink and indoor

every wednesday’s wing night $60cents pc . buffalo or bbq

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: food

corned beef & cabbage. saints patrick’s day weekend.

Image may contain: food

$7.95 cheeseburger w/ french fries every tuesday

welcome to cattleman’s grill group of what’s cooking sullivan county

No automatic alt text available.
Image may contain: food
Cattleman's Grill

every tuesday $8 regular cheeseburger
(please mentioned this offer)

thanks to everyone who attended st valentine’s day event yesterday .. it was a success!

happy valentine’s day 🌹 🌹

Image may contain: people sitting, table, living room and indoor

ready for tomorrow. happy valentine’s day . #surfandturf

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: food
Cattleman's Grill shared their event.
February 3

booking reservations . happy valentine’s day💘

Wed 11:00 AM ESTCattleman's GrillEllenville, NY
14 people interested
Cattleman's Grill shared their post.
January 31
Image may contain: food
Image may contain: food
Cattleman's Grill added 2 new photos.

🏈🏈🏈Pre-order your superbowl wings today!! 50 wings for $40!!!!! Ask us about our other superbowl specials!!!🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Cattleman's Grill shared their event.
January 26

make your reservations:)

Wed 11:00 AM ESTCattleman's GrillEllenville, NY
14 people interested