408 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Karen Haven Killingsworth
· January 6, 2018
A few months ago my husband and I ate one of the best steaks at Conestoga that we have ever eaten anywhere. It was cooked to perfection, tender, juicy, and we could practically cut it with our fork...s. We has been anticipating another wonderful steak all week, but were frankly quite disappointed last night. We ordered the 12 ounce ribeye which, by the way, was on special. Both of our steaks were very dry, overcooked, and extremely tough. We sawed through the steaks with our knives. Our waitress who, by the way, was absolutely wonderful (Brittany) offered to bring us another steak. I kept mine and suffered through a few more bites while my husband accepted her offer and they brought him another one. Unfortunately, it was just as bad as the first one. The sweet potato was amazing though, and the baked potato was okay as well. The service was outstanding, but the steak very disappointing. They did offer my husband's meal for free and gave me mine for half price, but we would have rather had the mouthwatering steak we went there for and paid full price for the meal. Instead, we ended up throwing away 3 steaks except for the few bites we struggled through to chew and swallow. Just not a good night for us. See More
Sue Hoover
· December 27, 2017
We were visiting our daughter in Ozark for Christmas and she suggested we try Conestoga. We have been visiting her for several years but never made it to this place until last night. Wow! We sure have... missed out all these years as it was so delicious! The 8oz. filet was so big and so tender. Also got a baked potato and house salad and was so pleased with everything. Thsnk you to our daughter Alicia for taking us to Conestoga for dinner and for one of the best steaks I have ever eaten! Scrumptious!! See More
Michele Marlene Huntzinger Lee
· December 3, 2017
Me and my daughter have been there twice and haven't yet been dissatisfied. The food is delicious. They have the best steak that I have ever eaten at a steak house. The sauce is amazing
I'd love a ...gallon of it to go. Lol. Everyone needs to go to this restaurant. Definitely a friendly environment. See More
Mark Rosser
· November 16, 2017
Conestoga is for serious steak lovers. Don’t come here if you’re looking for menu variety. You’ll only find about 5 or 6 items...and they’re all steaks. But man do they have great steaks...and the hot... yeast rolls are fabulous. They’ve been around for years and haven’t changed. See More
Matt Griggs
· October 27, 2017
The bomb steak! The atmosphere leaves something to be desired but for a steak the is second to only a home cooked piece of meat off a big green egg. Ask for the extra sauce in the side to dip steak in.
Jason Owens
· September 16, 2017
Have eaten here several times and would say hands down, best steak in the wiregrass. Other places i've been to, like El Dorado, Texas Roadhouse, etc, have their off days where the steaks or service is...n't always consistent, but Conestoga has always tasted super. All my family that I've introduced to it have always loved it too. Hamburger steak and the sides aren't bad either, and the service has always been great no matter how crowded. See More
Michael Connell
· January 27, 2018
Best steak on the planet! I have been eating here with friends and family for over ten years. At one point we went every weekend for about a year. Consistent quality every time!
Mo Ostrander
· November 22, 2017
It’s not known fir the decor,
but it’s famous for the best steak in town!
Hand cut fries are great too.
Not to mention the amazing yeast rolls that are the best!
Jessie Lynn Holmes
· November 27, 2017
Mine and my husbands favorite place to go when we have a dinner night! We don’t go anywhere else. Service and food is always perfect!
Stephanie Edwards Gardner
· October 7, 2017
My family and I came into Conestoga for dinner tonight (10/07/17) we were waiting to be seated and a man I assume to be manager or owner came up front and was talking to an employee at the front desk.... The way he spoke to this girl was so disrespectful, the way he spoke to her made us decide we would never dine at Conestoga ever again. We were disgusted and we left without being seated. My family and I do not wish to support a business that allows managers to speak to their employees that way. He was extremely rude to her and she left the building in tears. No one should speak to his or her employees or co-workers the way this man spoke to that young girl. Very dissapointed. See More
Olivia Starling
· December 20, 2017
The best steak in town. I am a foodie so I know good food, and I definitely know good steak, and Conestoga has the best steak ever.
Laurie Brown
· June 5, 2017
It was my birthday. We wanted to go someplace new for my special day. We heard how good Conestoga was so we decided to try it. My salad came and was totally smothered in dressing. So much so that I c...ouldn't see the vegetables. Our dinners were brought out and my fiance was given a MR steak and the waitress gave mine to me and said," Here is your Well done steak. " I told her that I ordered it cooked Medium. She said , "No it was supposed to be well done." My fiance backed me up. She took my dinner back. My fiance ate his and she came back and said the cook read her ticket wrong. I waited. My food was delivered as he was finishing his steak. The steak was now cooked perfectly but my sweet potato was hard and not cooked. It took a while to get another sweet potato. My fiance had to wait and watch me eat. The steak was delicious once the order was made right but when you are paying what we did and it is a special occasion, you would prefer to eat together. Not impressed. See More
Bo Bland
· July 24, 2017
I have yet to receive a bad meal or service here! My wife, daughter, and in-laws go out together at least once a month and we always choose Conestoga Steak House! Best T-bones and Ribeyes in Dothan! K...eep up the good work guys! (Remember to tip the waitresses gracefully, they work hard) See More
Tami Smith McNeil
· September 24, 2017
we’ve eaten there more times than I can count and not once have we had a bad experience! Great service and food!
Samantha Miller
· February 10, 2018
Best steak I've had in a long time Gena was our waitress and she was wonderful definitely be back
Tony Smith
· October 7, 2017
Great steaks, great prices and great service. Always a place we head for when in Dothan
Danny McLeod
· September 6, 2017
Wife had New York strip and I had the T-Bone, both were very tough and tasteless. I mentioned it to cashier and heard the co-cashier say that I should have put more salt on it. First time I have ever a bad steak here. See More
Jean Timmel
· June 27, 2017
Used to live in Dothan. Made a point to stop when i was in town. I love steak and have had many good steaks but the steaks here defy description. Just that amazingly delicious.
Blake Foley
· December 23, 2017
Excellent food and service!!! We love it and can’t wait to go back!!! Best steak in the south!!!
Jimmy Taylor
· January 31, 2018
Best steak house on the planet!!!
I’ve been eating steaks there off and on for over thirty years, the consistency is unparalleled �

Feb. 12th thru Feb. 17th
8 oz. FILET $19.99
5 oz. FILET $17.49...

“Treat your sweetheart to the best steak in town”

See More

February 9th thru February 10th
SPECIAL: 12oz. RIBEYE $19.99

Don’t forget to pickup a Gift Certificate for your sweetheart ❤️


12 oz. Ribeye $19.99
Looking forward to seeing you !!!

Thru the month of December, buy a $100.00 dollars worth of gift certificates, get a $10.00 gift certificate FREE 🎄☃️
Don’t forget to book your Christmas Party🎄☃️

12 oz. RIBEYE $19.99
Nov. 15 thru Nov. 18

8 oz. FILET $19.99 + tax

September 15 & September 16
12 oz. RIBEYE $19.99

Let us take care of Dinner!...
Get it to go!

See More

Sorry, we will be closed tonite due to hurricane Irma

12 oz. RIBEYE $19.99
September 1 and September 2nd
We will be closed on Monday September 4th

Thursday July 20th thru Saturday July 22nd
12 oz. RIBEYE $19.99

We would like to say THANK YOU for voting us Best of the Wiregrass!!!

JUNE 19 thru JUNE 24
8 oz. FILET $19.99

8 oz. FILET $19.99
JUNE 13th. thru JUNE 17th.
Welcome and good luck to all Future Masters Contestants!!!

MAY 22 thru MAY 27
8 oz. FILET $19.99

April 18 thru April 22
8 oz. FILET $19.99

12 oz. RIBEYE $19.99
HAPPY EASTER everybody!!!

March 18
12 oz. RIBEYE $19.99