50 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Denise Bates Kean
· November 29, 2017
I bought a used saddle from a tack sale, and it's the best saddle I've ever had! I am very fortunate that the saddle was made by Jay's!! It fits me and my horse perfectly, and I love it!! Just bought ...a Jay's bridle to go with it. Very happy with the quality and the fit for both of us!! Thank you, Jay!!!! See More
Daniel Jerrolds
· July 11, 2016
Jay is the man. My wife bought a Trail Lite saddle and saddle bags here last year and I liked them so much she just bought me a matching set today. Jay has so many types of saddles/tack with quality a...nd prices both of which no one else can compete its impressive. Any type of saddle you want (trail, endurance, trooper, roper, Reiner, etc) he has or will make. It'll be the best you can find as well. Along with all the other products he turns out of this place it's worth driving across the state just to see. See More
Lindsey Foster
· January 14, 2016
Bought a custom saddle from these guys and the packaging alone for shipping was fantastic! No room for the saddle to get damaged or move.
The saddle is absolutely stunning and great quality! I tugged... and pulled on everything and it's very well put together, it's comfortable, fashionable and affordable! Great bang for your buck! Will be a returning customer from NJ! See More
Tara Murphy
· November 1, 2017
Beautiful quality, fantastic prices and delightful people providing excellent service!
Becca Snider
· June 1, 2017
Bought a used saddle that Jay had made but the fenders were way way to long. Sent him the fenders, had them back in a week exactly how I wanted them! So great when people are helpful, kind, and prov...ide quality service! See More
Stacy Lewis
· July 4, 2016
Liked the looks of the saddles so I had one made with what I liked best from the ones they already had. Have a great lady's wade tree saddle that I love now. They made it within 6 weeks of the 8 promi...sed. Great price, great saddle and fantastic customer service!!! See More
Doramy Morgan
· July 21, 2014
Purchased new saddle and bridle/breast collar and cinches from Jay on July 17 2014 - very happy with purchases - rode in new saddle yesterday - fits horse beautifully (I was lucky enough to be able to... bring my horse to Jay to ensure we got the right saddle tree size - Tucker saddle was pinching his withers - Jay explained a lot re: saddle tree/sizing/fitting which was very educational) Saddle is very comfortable to ride in. Even non-horsey husband admired the tack and said he thought it was well priced. Thank you Jay! See More
Allison White Morgan
· August 26, 2014
I've only been to the store once and can't wait to go back for a longer shopping spree. His leather work is excellent quality and I was so impressed at his shop. The new Trail Lite saddle with floral ...tooling made my mouth water! Beautiful!! See More
Sheena Villa
· February 3, 2017
Love this place. We vacationed in TN and absolutely went nuts/broke in here :). The prices were great, and the people were nice and helpful. We will definitely be back when we come back to TN.
Kristine Davenport
· May 19, 2015
I have had my Jay's Custom reining saddle for about 5 months now and I couldn't be happier! High quality, great fit and comfort, and absolutely GORGEOUS!! Very reasonable prices for the quality that you get!
Robbie Manning
· May 28, 2014
Just bought some chinks, pulling collar and various other items this past Memorial Day weekend. Jay is a SUPER nice person, very attentive, and helpful. Made sure my chinks fitted and the quality of t...he items is superb! Will definitely stop by any time I'm in the area. See More
Tim Ditmore
· October 31, 2015
Visited with Jay Friday first rate fellow took great care of my daughter and her horses needs. Top notch service and very good people.
Trey Terry
· December 5, 2013
I can honestly say I'm one of Jays toughest customers. He's very attentive to his customers wants, needs, and attention to detail is hands down the best anyone will find. Thank you Jay for your great work.
Kate Hoteko
· July 7, 2014
I have a breast collar with sheepskin on the plate,its stamped made by Arron Bauman muddy pond,would that be a relative of yours.
Catherine Starr
· April 10, 2016
I purchased a very nice, comfortable, light-weight saddle from Jay, that he promised would not sore my high-withered horse. He was right! He makes high quality products at competitive prices. And h...e is a good horseman. See More
Alison Morgan
· September 27, 2014
I've bought many items from Jay's over the years...great products, well-made, not outrageously priced, and great customer service!
Bobbie Abell
· November 30, 2016
Nice to meet wonderful and profession craftsman. Thank you for sharing your talent and allowing others to know that what they are purchasing will make a difference.
Wiggins Sirrena
· November 9, 2016
Rode in one of your custom saddles last week while working in Crossville! Great work!
Robert Livingston
· June 3, 2015
Jay is a wonderful resource for area riders; he knows saddles and tack inside and out and can make or mend anything. We're lucky to have him just down the road!
Danny Goss
· October 16, 2014
Great place to visit. He has a good operation and can make and repair saddles and tack too.
Teaching the next generation how its done.
CMSA Awards

Merry Christmas from all of us at Jay's Custom Leather!
Our shop will be closed for the holidays, DECEMBER 25-JANUARY 2. See y'all next year!

Image may contain: 7 people, people smiling, people standing

Our shop will be closed Wednesday,November 22nd and Thursday November 23rd. We will resume our normal hours on Friday and Saturday. HAVE A HAPPY THANKSGIVING!!!