110 Reviews
People talk aboutbakery items, donut holes and special order
Tell people what you think
Betsy Crawford
· December 7, 2017
They made my wedding cake and cupcakes for our 300 person wedding. Their flavors, frosting, and cake were phenomenal. We went with a small cutting cake, almond with raspberry filling and butter cream ...frosting�, which was divine and perfect for my wedding party. We did 3 flavors of cupcakes, chocolate, yellow, and almond-all with different frosting, they looked great and tasted amazing. We chose one of their designs they had in their reference book and it turned out great. We had provided our topper, few cupcake stands, and rented a stand from them. We never worried and they came through for us on our big day. We would recommend them for any wedding or special occassion. Thank you for making our day extra special.
The Crawfords
See More
Nathan Smith
· December 24, 2017
My family and I ventured out in the snow this morning to try Neat-O's Bakery. We tried a white iced donut with sprinkles, an Apple Fritter, Chocolate Bismarks, Cherry Turnover, Sausage and Cheese fill...ed croissant, Ham and Cheese Quiche and Ham, Mushroom and Cheese Quiche. We were AMAZED at the flavors, textures and quality ingredients that we experienced in all of the baked goods! The staff was extremely kind, humble and helpful! I highly recommend this bakery to anyone looking for a A++ experience! See More
Kaitlyn Jacobs
· January 21, 2018
We had our cake testing for our wedding and not only were the cupcakes amazing, but my very particular fiancé enjoyed it! They were friendly and welcoming, can’t wait to see our wedding cake!
Brenda Prettyman
· August 9, 2017
I stopped in last Saturday looking for a raised chocolate with chocolate frosting donut for my 83 year old dad. He remembered getting this type on donut when he was younger. The shop did not carry the...m but after checking with the baker they made me a dozen. They were great and it made my father very happy! Thank you for going above, great customer service. See More
Miranda Pickett
· October 2, 2017
Neat-O's has been there for us through a gender reveal, our daughter's first birthday, and more recently our wedding! Their service is great, their decorating is fantastic, and the cakes taste even be...tter!! Thank you so much! See More
Kitty Squeeka Pims
· September 29, 2017
My dad turned 60 this year and he had one request - celebrate by cooking out and fishing at Devil's Lake. We're from Illinois, but we've spent so much time in Baraboo that it feels like home. When we ...started planning the camping trip, I KNEW we had to get the cake from Neat-O's. And let me tell you.... My un-shockable dad was SHOCKED. He loved the cake, which turned out perfectly. It had a beautiful fish theme and was easily the best, moistest carrot cake I've ever tasted. The frosting was nice and light and the decorating blew us away. Thank you for making our Baraboo theme fishing/camping birthday trip extra special. See More
Nikki Wollin
· September 18, 2017
They are exceptional. We had them bake 12 loafs of medieval style bread rolls for our wedding and we ended up with no left overs! They where amazing and just what we needed!
Donna Gahm
· October 17, 2017
Ordered our Grandsons 1st Birthday cake and could not have been happier. Decorated perfect and the frosting was awesome. Could not have been nicer to deal with
Jennifer Tomasik
· September 21, 2017
Everytime i go i get the best service, the muffins are amazing. The donuts are huge an so good.
Nicole Shaire
· January 20, 2018
Thank you guys so much for the homer style donuts! Best bday cake ever!
Tammy Paulson
· December 7, 2017
Cookies, cakes, and donuts.....oh my!! I love it all!
Richie Braatz
· May 14, 2016
Been coming here since we moved to Baraboo three years ago and have yet to be disappointed by anything Iv tried and Iv tried a lot. Got myself the root beer float cup cake this morning and was iffy on... how that would taste but was definitely not disappointed. The decorative candy straw that came in it however turned out to be a real straw lol See More
Fiorella Neira
· December 22, 2014
As an event coordinator and designer, I'm lucky to have found one of the only bakeries in Wisconsin who won't turn you down when asking for a 6ft tall cake.
I have the freedom to sit with Amanda cre...ate drawings and she always says "Yes! We can do that." Then she adds the Neat-O's touch to create beautiful edible art! Thanks for everything! See More
Heather Lauter
· February 14, 2017
Not only was our cake beautiful, and delicious - the owner and manager went above and beyond by allowing us to pick up the cake after hours! Also the size they recommended was perfect!! Thank you so so much!!!
Caroline Phoenix
· August 15, 2015
I had a special order and suddenly had to move up the order date by two days which they graciously accomodated. I would not have been able to get my son's birthday cake anywhere else in that small win...dow of time! And most important, it was delicious!!! Plain white cake but it was excellent! See More
Kassandra Yamileth
· March 21, 2017
Love their donut holes! Their glaze is amazing and it's not to sweet either like other glazes in other places. Really enjoy going their early in the morning with my 2yr old baby girl � she gets excit...ed everytime we walk in �
And the price is definitely not crazy $$ at all
See More
Jennifer Lynn Roberts
· June 17, 2017
I was in Baraboo today for a family birthday party. My cousin Betsy had purchased your brat buns for lunch and they were delicious!! Wish I lived closer so I could try more items!
Kaicey Ann von Stockhausen
· October 15, 2015
We used Neat-O's for our wedding cake and it was awesome!
Everything from the tasting to delivery was handled very professionally and the staff is very easy to work with. Our cake was phenomenal and... it looked exactly like our picture! See More
Tiffany Williamson
· March 21, 2016
Amanda and Tony have been doing my cakes for years and I wouldn't dream of anyone else. My girls tend to get very creative with their cakes and Neatos has always made their dream come true. not to men...tion the amazing FROSTING. so good. See More
Danielle Miller
· February 9, 2016
We loved our wedding cake from Neat-Os! It was delicious and beautiful. We really enjoyed the tasting experience too, and chose almond cake with raspberry filling. I sent in two pictures of cakes and ...asked for part of each, and it turned out exactly how I wanted! See More
We got you covered for Halloween!
Tony, and I, my sister and her family are on vacation to surprise my mom for Christmas! She had no idea that all of her kids and grand kids were coming!
Yep! It really is cake!

Did you say Easter Donut? Hop on in to the shoppe today and grab some! And while you’re here, check out all the new varieties of donuts, our selection of other Easter goodies, and pick up a pecan roll or two!

Image may contain: dessert and food
Image may contain: food
Image may contain: dessert, food and indoor
Image may contain: food

Last week was the Midwest Foodservice Expo in Milwaukee and we are excited to share that Amanda took home a gold medal for her food themed Extreme Groom’s Cake! She also won a gold medal and People’s Choice trophy for her entry in the Extreme Wedding Cake- Non Fondant category! Yes, those crates with the chipping, peeling paint are edible and totally fondant free!

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: 1 person

Hey Neat-O’s Peeps! We are super egg-cited to be in the running for Sweetest Bakery in America! Hop on over and vote for us! You can vote every day! It’s super easy so there’s no eggs-cuses! Ok that’s enough Easter puns for now...…/neat-os-bake-shoppe/…

No automatic alt text available.

We are now taking orders for all of your Easter needs! And don’t forget our gold medal winning pies!!

Also, stop on over here…/neat-os-bake-shoppe/… to vote and help us be the Sweetest Bakery in America!
Thank you!

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: food
Image may contain: food and text
Image may contain: food

We’re currently 6th in the state! Keep voting and help us be the Sweetest Bakery in America! You can vote online every day and we also have paper ballots in store!…/neat-os-bake-shoppe/…

No automatic alt text available.

Don’t forget to vote for us for the Sweetest Bakery in America! You can vote every day from now until July 31st!…/neat-os-bake-shoppe/…

Vote for Neat-O’s Bake Shoppe located in Wisconsin!

It’s Pi Day! And guess what!?! Our blueberry pie just won first place at the Midwest Foodservice Expo in Milwaukee! So come on down to the shop and get some of our gold-medal-winning pie!

Image may contain: food

Guess what! We’re in the running for Sweetest Bakery in America! Stop over to
to vote for us! You can vote every day from now until July 31st! We also have a ballot box in the shop!
Show your Neat-O’s love and vote!
Thank you!!

No automatic alt text available.

Custom hand made cake toppers? You bet! Call us today to set up your tasting appointment!

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: dessert, food and indoor

Getting married? Time to pick out your cake! We can help, call us today! 608 448 4400

Image may contain: outdoor and food

Want your wedding cake made by a multiple award winning bakery?
Call us today! 608 448 4400

Image may contain: 1 person, food

Getting married? Congratulations!! Call us today to schedule a tasting! 608 448 4400

Image may contain: food

Looking for breakfast or lunch? We have ham and Swiss sliders, Cubans and Chicago style with roast beef, cheddar and peppers! If you’re looking for something special we put the love in Bakalova............pick up your King cake along with several flavors of paczki's . Date, Prune, Lemon and Strawberry!
Soup is Califlower!

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: food
Image may contain: dessert and food

Getting married? We can help! Call us today! 608 448 4400

Image may contain: flower

We are booking fast for 2018! Schedule your tasting today! 608 448 4400

Image may contain: food