206 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Ginger Dahl
· October 23, 2017
We made the mistake of going here for a bite on Sweetest Day. There was one other table with a family of 4 and a guy I think just using the WiFi? We had gone here when they first opened and got that tasted like a doctored mix. After years I saw a post with a pork burrito that looked good and we decided to give the food part a try. We're told the pork burrito was no longer available even though it was on the menu board still. Decided to try the "spicy" Mac and cheese and the beer cheese and pretzels. We were anticipating fresh baked pretzels since it is a bakery. About 5 mins after we ordered our "food" was brought out so we could tell it was just microwaved quickly or was pre-prepared and sitting. The pretzels were "breadsticks" that looked nearly burnt. There was no salt on them. (How can you do pretzels without salt?!) The outside was hot and the middles were nearly cold and squishy. There was one tiny cup of runny "beer cheese" that under normal circumstances wouldn't be enough but it was so bland and flavorless we didn't eat it anyway. The "spicy" Mac and cheese was some of the worst I had. Undercooked and cold mostacioli noodles with I think the same bland beer cheese poured over it. With a $9 beer (yikes!) and pop we were up to nearly $30 as the cashier graciously turned the register screen which prompted for a tip before service and food. It was so bad we left it all at our table and walked out. We had to go to another restaurant in town where we paid less and got better food. $30 down the drain just like that! See More
Steve Hopkins
· November 9, 2017
Great sandwiches, great desserts, many craft beer varieties, very friendly staff, and fun trivia on Wednesday nights!! Natalie, you've carved out a nice little niche here!! Definitely worth the 1 hour... drive from Delaware!! See More
Elizabeth Aldridge
· October 8, 2017
I picked up a selection of your cupcakes this past Friday for a Bachelorette Party. The bride to be is a Heidelberg Grad and knew exactly where the cupcakes came from before I even got a chance to tel...l her. She was so happy to have a nostalgic treat from college. The cupcakes were amazing as always! See More
Ben Miller
· October 15, 2017
I have played this venue 4 times, so far... the food is interesting and flavor filled. The drinks are swell... ill be there one Thursday per month to play some blues on ceegar box guitars and my 69 Gibson
Alicia Smith Warnecke
· August 31, 2017
I am amazed at how Natalie has progressed from making cakes (she made our wedding cake 7 years ago) to opening her own shop! Proud of you- the food and cupcakes are great 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Janel Elizabeth
· September 12, 2017
Fantastic place! Great food, out of this world dessert and very kind service. Definitely a place to check out if you are in Tiffin! Oh and they have good beer selection!
Kaethe Maelstrom
· January 21, 2018
Truly an amazing customer service experience, coupled with an extensive drink list and the best bread pudding I've ever had, I cannot wait to go back! ♥
Becky Miller
· January 19, 2018
My daughter and I went for a cupcake and ended up with 6! Couldn't pass up getting more then one! Great service!
Lloyd Sonny Roberts
· November 13, 2017
Drive 40 miles more than once to eat at Phat Cakes and was never disappointed, food was excellent.
Kay Mae
· November 7, 2017
All the soups are amazing and I recently had the chili Mac. Highly recommend!
Andrew James Felter
· December 9, 2017
Great food and drinks! Entertainment was out of this world. My Social Uniform rocks!!!!
Kristen Walkins
· October 28, 2017
First time here and picked up some cupcakes. They where amazing! Will definitely be back for sure!!
Aaron Montz
· January 28, 2017
Phat Cakes is a great spot whether you're looking for an entire meal or just dessert. The soups are homemade and very filling and the sandwiches have lots of flavor and made to order. Their slices of ...cheesecake are huge and the selection of unique cupcakes is second to none. If you're a bread pudding fan you're going to love Phat Cakes bread pudding as well. The worst part is trying to decide from all the delicious sweets available. See More
Jenny Lund
· February 6, 2018
Love going here for lunch! The wraps are my favorite!
Austin Moneer
· September 8, 2017
Love the people who work there always so friendly and the owner is super funny
Chris Ludwick
· September 23, 2017
The staff is very pleasant and friendly. The food and d rinks was amazing.
Michelle Tuite
· January 28, 2017
This small town cafe is the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with friends or co-workers. It also makes the best place to snuggle up with your honey to share a yummy, freshly made dessert. You always feel ...welcomed and at home!!! See More
Ryan Niederkohr
· March 25, 2017
With an emphasis on quality not quantity, excellent drink selection and outstanding service this place is a gem in a sea of places trying to imitate. Brian was very helpful and knowledgeable about the... products they offer. Definitely will be returning! See More
Christine Waters
· January 20, 2017
Great paninis, my fave is turkey reuben with side of slaw, and awesome variety of sweet treats* Adult beverages as well as live music add to a great 'every1' atmosphere**
Bill Heck
· February 16, 2017
Have eaten here many times, with results ranging from really good to wonderful. Constantly changing rotation of draft beers just makes it even better. Add the friendly people and you can't go wrong.

Subscribe & share this link with your friends for Phat specials and more!

Stay up to date with our monthly events including beer & wine tastings, live music, benefits, game nights & trivia nights!

PLUS! If we are feeling froggy we'll send out specials, deals, give-aways & other great stuff!

... See More
Phat Cakes & Cafe Email Forms

TAP it!
$3 craft beer on tap, $2 tacos & LIVE music with Blind Dog Benny start now!

Image may contain: 1 person, meme and text
Phat Cakes

When you love the food you eat...the rest comes easy!
Our Phat Reuben's are made with grade A angus beef, slow roasted & pulled, sauerkraut, melted swiss & thousand Island on toasted rye served with a side of your choice.

Image may contain: food
Phat Cakes

If our math serves us right...
Melts + Spicy Mac & Cheese + a Pint = LOVE!
Some say three is a crowd...we say bring it on!!

PLUS, live music tonight, $3 select pints & $2 tacos!

No automatic alt text available.
Image may contain: food

Dinner, Drinks & Trivia TONIGHT!....Bring a team or bring yourself!! Team sizes range from 1-8ppl:)

Things you should have learned in middle school had you been paying attention🤔😉


We look forward to serving you!

See More
Image may contain: text
No automatic alt text available.

Winter Luau Beach Blast Beer Tasting!
Featuring Magic Hat Brewing
**To Benefit United Way**

Tie on your grass skirts and sip on some brews at our luau beer tasting event! ...
Featuring Magic Hat Brewery give-a-ways, samples,
live music from "The Tuesday Crowd", Tropical themed taco bar, cash bar, give-a-ways, 50/50, tropical costume contest and more!
(Tickets available at Phat Cakes)

Tropical Themed Taco Bar:
Your choice of 3 tacos including:
Hawaiian Style Smoked Kalua Pork & Jamaican Jerk Chicken
Pineapple Pico de Gallo, Corn Salsa, Cheese, Shredded lettuce, Sour Cream, BBQ sauce & Jamaican Jerk Crema
Island Coleslaw / Coconut Rice / Jasmine Rice / Chips / Macaroni Salad / Fruit Tray & Dessert

See More

Dinner & Show EVERY Thursday!
Looking to relax before the weekend hits?

Gather your co-workers & friends for THIRSTY Thursday starting EVERY Thursday@5p with Live Music starting@6:30p


Stop in for Seasoned Beef & Smoked Pulled Pork Tacos & select Craft Beers on tap!

Also serving up:
Wine, Bottled Craft & Domestic Beer, Beer Paddles, Meads & Cocktails.
Full Menu available with over 25 rotating gourmet desserts

Now Booking Musicians! Call 567-220-6118.

Cheers to finding time to relax

See More

Open late for food & drinks!

Fri 10:00 PM ESTPhat CakesTiffin, OH

The only Weekly Wednesday Trivia Night in Tiffin is at Phat Cakes!
Bring your brains & your buddies because drinking while thinking with friends makes everything more fun!
Trivia starts promptly at 6:30p.
Come early to get dinner, drinks and first choice on our desserts!
Then, download the free app to your mobile device or tablet. ...
Our host will ask the questions while projecting them as well.
There will be three rounds of 20 questions with a themed Bonus round at the end & a short break in between rounds.
(Past examples: halloween movie scenes, disney songs, 70's music, things you should have learned in middle school had been paying attention, vintage toys, christmas movies...)
Your team will answer questions with multiple choice, choosing the beginning of the letter of your answer or off of a picture sent to your device.
Questions are general knowledge and can easily be answered by all ages.
Top team wins a prize to Phat Cakes or from our trivia sponsors.
Please share our events with your friends so we can support more great events like this!

*ps. Looking for a team building night with your company? Let us host a Trivia Night for you! Call 567-220-6118 to book a date!

Don't forget to check out our page for our Weekly Live Music & other events including our next Beer Tasting!

Thanks for all your support!

See you soon!

See More

A very HaPpY Un-A-Birthday to YOU....yes YOU!
How do we celebrate our everyday UnBirthday?
With wine & cheesecake of course!

Our variety of wine paired with our dreamy layered cheesecakes will make your UnBirThDaY...worth celebrating everyday! ...
Have a friend you would like to celebrate with?
"SHARE" this post & Tag them below for your chance to win a FREE slice of our PHAT CHEESECAKE!

See More
From Disney's "Alice in Wonderland" (1951).

Drink Specials, Tacos & Timber Run...Music starts@6:30p!

No automatic alt text available.
Phat Cakes

Calling all Disney Princesses & Queen trivia buffs for our weekly Wednesday Trivia Bonus Round tonight!

Trivia Starts@6:30 sharp, we recommend getting here at 6p to download the free app & get cozy with dinner & drinks!

Top team wins a prize! 🍻

Image may contain: text
Phat Cakes

Drive throughs eating up your lunch time?
Call in your order & we'll have it ready for a quick pickup!

Image may contain: 1 person, meme and text
Image may contain: food
It looks like you may be having problems playing this video. If so, please try restarting your browser.
Posted by Phat Cakes
It looks like you may be having problems playing this video. If so, please try restarting your browser.
Posted by Phat Cakes