Posts
Pink Pony shared a photo.
March 20

These cute Triplets are getting excited for the Pink Pony opening May 3!

Image may contain: 3 people
Rose Witt updated her cover photo.

Representing the Pink Pony on the road!

Instagram Post by Lori Randolph • March 2, 2018 at 05:05PM PST
via instagram.com
Photos
Reviews
4.5
1,008 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Shiloh Muethel
· October 26, 2017
Stayed at the Lilac Tree last weekend & we had a breakfast package with our wonderful stay. My husband & I were excited to try the Pink Pony for breakfast since it's always so busy all the time & we ...haven't had a chance to try it yet. The staff was very friendly, sat us near the window so we had a great view. I ordered the french toast in which 2 out of 3 slices were extremely undercooked, very mushy & raw. The server gladly took them to replace them. She returned with fully cooked slices but I have to say for $12 french toast, it was fairly bland & not worth the amount on the menu. While our server was friendly we had to ask for a warm up on our coffee a couple of times. We were passed up when the coffee pot was going around by another server, he looked at our half empty cups & continued walking. Sadly, not impressed & I'm not so sure we'd give it a go for lunch or dinnertime. Did love the Halloween decor though! See More
Sharolyn Macomber Metternich
· October 16, 2017
One of our favorite restaurants when visiting the island! The food is delicious and we've dined in all 4 seating areas. Our favorite is the upper deck or lower patio area outside. Beautiful views of ...the boats and the water. Different menus are served in the different areas so be sure to ask about this when choosing where you want to sit. There are 3 different stands for reserving seating. One for both outside areas(located right outside the back door, walk straight through the lobby of the hotel), One for the main dining area inside located closest to the hotel lobby and one as you enter from the sidewalk on the pink pony bar side. Very friendly staff all season long! Highly recommend!! See More
Chrizzy Miller Neal
· October 16, 2017
We were there in July. I liked your page but never did a review! Our visit on the island that day was lovely. Starting with a bike ride around the busy island. We wanted to eat on the water and your e...stablishment was recommended. Our wait for a seat had a view of the water and we lucked out being seated at a table in front of the nice young man playing guitar and singing "listen to the music". The pink everywhere led to the ambiance of a cheerful happy place. The food was delicious! Keep up the great work! We'll be back! See More
Kelly Burton Turner
· October 17, 2017
My husband and I had a wonderful experience at the Pink Pony today. We were greeted immediately and our request to sit outside was no problem. The service was very good and the food was outstanding!... The smoked whitefish dip was so flavorful! Definitely a favorite. If you like a sweet fruity rum drink, try the Rum Runner. The view was beautiful and relaxing. Would recommend this place!� See More
John Gallegos
· October 16, 2017
Bartender (Lindsay) was phenomenal!! The “manager” (Katie) however was very pushy with staff and unprofessional, she wanted something fixed and said she knew how to do it, turns out she had no knowled...ge of how to do it. Then when she heeded advice on how to fix said item, she took ALL credit and shamed her staff for not knowing how. What a joke of an employee. See More
Wendy Shoup
· October 3, 2017
Ate here 2 days in a row and we always eat here every time we're on the island! Fabulous salads and veggie burger! The patio dining is so beautiful but inside is also gorgeous!
Laura Suarez
· October 11, 2017
Great place! I LOVE the atmosphere...fun and PINK! Adorable place.

We had the Whitefish Finger appetizer and I had a Patty Melt while my husband had a Bacon Cheeseburger. ...

Food was good however I was not a fan of the sweet potato fries (I got those and husband had regular fries). The SPFs were thin krinkle cut and were somewhat dry. They had a sweet tasting seasoning (tasted like it had cinnamon in it)--just wasn't what I expected.

Had a Bloody Mary and it was GREAT!

Love the gift store! I got an adorable shirt and bracelet as mementos from the trip.

Next time I will ask to be seated out doors on the patio over looking the water.

Great place overall!��
See More
Brianne Riemersma
· September 23, 2017
Great food and atmosphere! Our server was very friendly and even though it was busy we didn't have to wait long for our food. I would totally recommend this place and hope to come back in the future!!
April Boggs
· August 27, 2017
My husband and I came to the island for our anniversary, went around the the entire island and were starving and thirsty. After a horrible experience at The Village Inn (hop to their Facebook page to... read) we opted for the pink pony. There was a long wait but we didn't mind as the line was out of the door. We finally got into the doors and I over hear the hostess tell the group in front of us 20 minutes. Larry and I looked at each other and decide "it's ok" because we needed to eat. We got up to the hostess and she tells us it's going to be an hour wait! WHAT? I said to her the couple before us was told 20 minutes, so why would we wait an hour? She started back pedaling stating that "no she didn't say that to the couple in front of us" Well, just so happened that this couple was still standing there so I asked them how long they were told and he said 20 minutes. I looked at the hostess and she looked scared and surprised. I told her that she was an embarrassment to a good establishment and it's a shame that you are the first person that people come into contact with and are not a good person and left! I would love nothing more than to speak with the owner! Please contact me via IM and I will happily give my phone number. I look forward to speaking with you. See More
Peg McElmurry-Davis
· January 2, 2018
Our favorite haunt when staying on the island between the North Channel and the mainland.
Great food, and so much fun....
Myrlaina Giessel
· August 25, 2017
We had a great experience. It was busy so we had a 15-20 minute wait (short for a lunch time in the island). We were promptly seated and our server Madison was fabulous! She made sure that we had full... drinks and that the food was to our liking. She checked in with us often even though she clearly was busy with other tables. Great job! See More
Tricia Buckingham
· October 9, 2017
We have been to the Pink Pony twice this summer, the staff is like non other!! Exceptional!!! Food is excellent! Such a fun spot to hang while enjoying the laid back atmosphere on the Island!!
Candie Meyer
· September 13, 2017
I am astonished at all the negative reviews....excellent service and food....waiter forgot ketchup for the fries....no big deal we are all human and need to be kind and patient!!!
Donny Sanchez
· October 11, 2017
Food was ok, good beer selection. Not a lot of people their because we came in October. Waitress was nice, my wife wasn't as happy but that's another review. Would try someplace else next time we visit.
Debbie Snyder
· September 9, 2017
Our food was delicious. The sweet potatoe french fries were the best I ever had!!

Our server was a little slow, although, everything we did order she brought to us right away from the kitchen, whic...h is downstairs. That has to really SUCK to have to haul a tray of food all the way back up stairs!!

The atmosphere was nice and would likely come back for lunch again.
See More
Sandra R Beall-Daniels
· October 16, 2017
Love the smoked white fish spread. Have it every time on the island and that is just about 1 or 2 times a year.
KeithandLori Maneke
· September 27, 2017
Have been to Mackinaw many many times. Have never ate @ The Pink Pony. Had my chance while on vacation this time. Was sat right away and was waited on really fast. The food was very good.
Mike Martin
· September 20, 2017
Had the worst sangria of my life! My burger was supposed to be cooked medium, but there was uncooked hamburger in the middle. Way over priced, even for Mackinac Island!
Tricia Wiggle-Bazzy
· August 22, 2017
Very upsetting sat down for breakfast server walked by us 6 times never said anything to us so we got up to walk out and 5 servers standing there and didn't say a thing to us never be back again
Karen Stewart
· September 27, 2017
Food and service was great! We always enjoy our time spent here! One of our favorite places to eat on the island!
Videos
What a great season we had! Hard to believe it has already come to a close. Thank you to everyone who hung out with us, and thank you to our fans from afar. See you next year! PONY UP!
76
8