44 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Roy Fisher
· March 31, 2018
I loved this little shoppe downtown...freshly baked goodies !
Roxanna White
· January 30, 2017
I wasn't going to do a Facebook review but Sift popped up in my feed today and I decided I would. I am Gluten Free because I have Celiac Disease. Let me say first that I am thankful there are out there who offer safe treats so that I can enjoy things that I used to. We ordered my birthday cake from Sift. I normally order from a different Gluten Free Bakery but had heard of Sift and think their store is adorable and has pretty cakes so we thought we would give it a try. I placed my order over Facebook Messenger and appreciated the convenience of that and the prompt replies. The person I 'spoke' to via Messenger was very friendly, helpful, and polite. The cake was pricey at $32 for a six inch cake. I was willing to pay that though being that I knew it would be pretty and tasty. Sadly it really was neither one!!!! It was decorated very generically (which again I could have overlooked that part) but it was not edible!That part cannot be overlooked. It was VERY dry and tasted old, stale. It just wasn't good. It was my birthday and I had to throw my entire birthday cake in the trash. $32 in the trash. Maybe I just got a dud but at that price point I obviously won't be ordering again. Sorry! See More
Andre Salazar
· March 31, 2017
Not only the sift bakehouse shop is adorable but the sugar shack @ the Sarasota Farmer's market is too, they always have a super friendly attitude and delicious cookies muffins and scones. I know for ...a fact that the products baked are from scratch and they use quality ingreadients. Keep up with the good work Christine!!! See More
Jordan Kohn-Foley
· May 7, 2016
I ordered a lemon coconut cake from here and it was probably the best cake I have ever tasted. The lemon curd filling was perfect and the frosting was incredible. Will definitely be back for more. Als...o, I had previously ordered a chocolate peanut butter cake, which was delicious as well. Sift really is an amazing bakery. See More
Angela Briguglio
· March 15, 2016
Woman behind counter was so rude and unfriendly and she probably knew that last cookie of the batch she was selling us was stale. Although the cupcake and pecan bar were good, won't go back, or recomm...end it, too many other places with friendly service. See More
Bree Meredith
· August 15, 2015
Went into the bakery for some yummy treats and left with a Lucy Mae cake! Hands down one of the freshest and moist cakes we have had in Sarasota! Really enjoy this quaint bake shop and vintage vibe. D...efinitely will be ordering more :) See More
Emily Belt
· April 30, 2015
Had a salted caramel "The Shakes" this morning, with cold brew espresso and a banana chocolate chip coffee cake muffin from this beautiful new bakery on the way to work. Great new spot to grab on the way to work! See More
Molly Gallagher Dennehy
· March 31, 2017
This is the best bakery in town! She can do everything! I've gotten custom logo cookies to send to a client, and the most heavenly cakes! I'm getting so hungry just thinking about it!
Lucy Hope
· May 28, 2016
Sift made an AMAZING carrot cake for my father-in-law's birthday. The taste, texture and design were all on point. This is my go-to bakery for exceptional desserts and treats in Sarasota.
Beatrice Sims
· May 11, 2015
Best place for the best baked good in Sarasota! My mom loved the breakfast cookies she made and my aunt is coming back for more cake! I'll be stopping by here for my Mom's Birthday!
Karen Cook
· October 3, 2015
Very cute special bakery delicious the real deal pumpkin muffin triple berry muffin my mom enjoyed
Canning goods available wonderful
Cakes organic delicious roast coffee !!
Assunta Swier
· May 20, 2016
Best chocolate layered birthday cake ever! Loaded with homemade cream cheese frosting! I ate all of it, we'll all the leftovers thanks for being awesome! Shop local! Eat local!
Candice S. Paul
· April 11, 2015
Great combination of baked goods, juices, salads in jars and when new store opens on April 28th, Jimmy's Java Euphoria Cold Brew Espresso on tap as well as their wonderful hot brewed coffee!
Holly Hobbs Shen
· September 7, 2015
we ordered a lemon cake on the fly for our neighbor's birthday. sift took the order at 8am, made us a custom order cake that was DELICIOUS by 3pm. about to place our next order. BRAVO.
Lauren Stockman
· December 20, 2016
You probably get this all day, but girl you rocked it out of the park!! My cake was so beautiful and perfect ���
Rachael Almy
· December 7, 2016
Omg the best cookies cupcakes and cakes I've ever tasted!! Wonderful sweet helpful employee helped me. And created the perfect birthday cake for my mom's recent birthday. Definitely worth stoping in f...or a taste!!! See More
Tiffany Pitre-Zampol
· April 29, 2015
I just went to Sift and bought the most delicious muffin! I also sampled some of their most yummy goods! I will definitely be back for more!
Jim Benson
· November 23, 2016
AMAZING cakes for our wedding! We just told Christine to make the most awesome cakes she's ever made and she exceeded our wildest dreams. Months later they're still talking about the CAKES!!
Erin Henshaw
· December 2, 2016
Best bakery! Love the Lucy Mae, cookies, scones, biscotti, brownies, lemon bars, did I mention Lucy Mae?
Cj Cooley
· May 2, 2015
If you know me, you know how much I Peanut Butter!! Elvis Lives is love at first bite. Also tried sifts watermelon lemonade . Refreshing. I will be back for more of her tasty treats
Denise Turcotte
· July 17, 2015
Visited for the first time today...highly recommend the lemon raspberry oat bars!
Selena Wyckoff
· March 27, 2016
Sift bakehouse is just simply amazing, they have wonderful products and lovely staff members!!
Natalie Nanjara Šupe
· May 7, 2015
Picked up some goodies for my kids teachers this morning, then came back to get something for myself!! Delicious!!!!
Christa Ryczywot
· March 21, 2015
I had heard rave reviews about sift at the farmers market so I decided what the heck I'll try them out I was very disappointed with the cookies we got it tasted like something was missing it was bland... and maybe had 2 chocolate chips in it! I'm sorry but even Macdonalds cookies would have tasted better See More
David Potenza
· April 7, 2015
Great baker and wonderful person. Her muffins are to die for!!!
Larry Stewart
· March 23, 2015
Christine's cookies and muffins are yummmmmy! Can't wait to check out the other goodies when the new store opens!
Lynne Latimer-Hill
· April 6, 2015
Tried several different cookies and they were terrible, very stale and too much artificial ingredients.
Beth Jacobson
· June 29, 2015
My son's baptism cake (the Lucy Mae) tasted like HEAVEN!!! Christine was a pleasure to work with!! We will definitely be back!
Alana Madure-Johnson
· October 9, 2016
The gingersnap cookies & cupcakes are delicious!!!
Rich Schineller
· March 31, 2017
I'm a Cookie Monster and I love their cookies
Lou Rindner
· March 3, 2014
Great stuff. great deal for your money
Louise Coble
· May 2, 2015
Made from scratch, all fresh ingredients, a must visit site.
Britt Rader
· March 31, 2017
Always delicious scones at the Farmer's Market :) ♥
Julie Fleming Lautermilch
· May 23, 2015
Best Muffin EVER!! So excited to have Sift right down the street!
Dh Public Relations
April 8, 2015
Olessia Klimenko Rabin sprinkles us with her grace, beauty and good taste. Thanks for coming by and bringing style to the party!
We're super excited about our *NEW* Apple Pie Oat Crumb Muffins and Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Scones! Come get em! 7a-1pm today at the @sarasotafarmersmarket 💕💕
Ganache // Bittersweet chocolate and warm cream // yum
Small Batch // From Scratch

When you're 90 you can eat all the Reeses you want...

No automatic alt text available.