84 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Heather Davis Kolling
· January 22, 2018
I sent Tiffany a photo of the baby shower invitation and some general ideas. Not only did she come through with the most perfect cookies, but she made an activity I wanted to do even better! ( baby shaped cookies.) In addition to being adorable, they were also very delicious. Everyone at the shower was asking who made them for me- they were a hit!! Highly recommend and will definitely use again. See More
Kaitlyn Green
· December 17, 2017
Lets just say, Tiffany NEVER disappoints!! Her cookies are just as big of a hit at a party as the party it’s self!! They are so beautifully made and taste even better! And those cake balls, you just ...have to try them to understand the deliciousness!! ��� thanks for adding another special touch to our party! See More
Beth Brisbin McKinney
· February 18, 2018
I received many compliments on the cookies for our Alice in Wonderland themed bridal shower. The artwork was on point, the colors were CoLoRfuLL and the cookies were fresh! I chose Tiffany on words of... others......will most certainly be ordering again� See More
Gena Meadows Lemmink
· December 6, 2017
We had cookies for my son's engagement party and also for the rehearsal dinner. They were fantastic! Now for another son's graduation.
Leah Warnemunde
· February 8, 2018
My entire experience was awesome. The cookies were just as cute as I imagined. Very reasonably priced & they tasted delicious :)
Kristin Martin
· December 11, 2017
Tiffany is fabulous! Such pretty cookies. Almost too pretty to eat. Almost! :)
Julie Morrison Moore
· November 20, 2017
Best cookies ever! She does and great job every time. Always fresh and amazing detail.
Andrea Hofmeyer
· November 2, 2017
Amazing ! I am so glad I came to Tiffany. The cookies turned out so much better than I could have imagined.
Courtney Fassler
· June 5, 2016
Got my first order of cookies today and couldn't be happier. The cookies turned out so beautiful and added the perfect personal touch to my son's baptism gathering. It's hard to find a beautiful cooki...e that taste good... so happy my friend recommended Tiffany! I will be telling all my friends about Tiffany so I can eat delicious cookies at all our parties Thank you!! See More
Jamie Brown
· November 3, 2017
Always delicious and super cute! Getting ready to order again soon!
Katie Maddock
· January 16, 2017
Hands down the best cake I have ever had! Everyone was raving about how delicious the cake was. My sons basketball themed cake was amazing down to the hand made chocolate basketball hoops. The we ordered for my dads retirement party were delicious! Delicious goodies and amazing prices! See More
Jessica Dickerson
· October 13, 2017
Cookie were decorated beautifully and tasted amazing.
Beth Keller Finan
· February 12, 2017
Tiffany has a talent like no other. You tell her what you want and bam! Not only do you have some adorable cookies, but they are amazingly tasty too! Cake balls are out of this world.
Barbara Poe Mills
· January 16, 2017
Topher's birthday cake was absolutely the best. Loved the buttercream icing cake was fresh and so yummy. Basketball court so cute. Reminds me of a Jenny Kenny cake.
Highly recommend Tiffanys .
Missy Johnson
· March 28, 2017
Tiffany's cookies are amazing! They were adorable and tasted delicious! I got so many compliments on them. I can't wait to have another special event so I can order more!
Kim Flamm
· December 18, 2016
Cookies are absolutely adorable and incredibly delicious as well!!! Tiffany is so flexible, can do any design, and is a delight to work with!!!! Thanks many times over!!!!
Jen Rolfert Boehner
· January 14, 2015
Simply fantastic! I've ordered hundreds of cake balls for several occasions. A formal fundraiser, golf outings and parties I've hosted. The cake balls taste amazing + always look beautiful. I'm so imp...ressed with the variety of options for customized cookies as well. Tiffany is a great person + puts her heart into each order. Highly recommend!! See More
Melissa Osborne
· July 13, 2014
I've ordered cakes many times from Tiffany and have always been very impressed with the quality of the cookies. Today I picked up cookies from Tiffany for my son's 5th birthday party which was a theme. She even individually bagged the cookies for me since I was using them as favors. The cookies were a huge hit and everyone was really impressed. Thank you for making Carter's day special! See More
Tara Mullins Sand
· April 21, 2016
Needed baby shower cookies very last minute and Tiffany's came recommended. She was easy to work with and provided us with the most creative and elegant cookies for our shower and yummy too. They were... the talk of the party. Thank you soooo much!!!! See More
Sandi Jackson
· February 14, 2017
The most professional perfect cookies ever! Better than any store bought or bakery cookie I've ever bought. Decorating was impeccable! Tasted even better than they looked! Will definitely order from again!

Slammed this week/weekend. Holidays in the middle of the week always throw my schedule off! So grateful you all think of me for your events.

Don’t forget to book early.......Graduation, Weddings, First Communion, birthdays....we do it all!

Februrary is booking is never to early to reserve your date. Remember first communion, birthdays, graduation, weddings.....we do it all!!!!


Super Bowl we start with football cookies!!! This is a collection of pictures from the last few weeks!

Remember your sweetheart on the 14th, spoil them with cake balls or cookies just to say “I love you”!!

The year has started off with a bang.....I have been terrible with pictures as I am always working last minute😬 I love working on all your orders and can’t believe how many of you are on the ball for the year. So many orders coming in, I LOVE IT!!!

So with a little help from my creative Mother, this is the “Fiona” Hippo cookie we came up with. I am beyond thrilled with how cute she is😁 I am taking orders for this sweet girl!

No automatic alt text available.

*******BAD NEWS EVERYONE*******
I am not allowed to fill any orders for the Fiona cookie pictured. The company that owns the artwork has asked me to stop. I did not realize when i pulled the image off the internet to copy from that it was an issue. I do apologize to those customers that already placed an order. We can do Hippo cookies, just not the one pictured. I will see if I can come up with a new design to please everyone.

No automatic alt text available.

WOW......2017 was an AMAZING year for Tiffany’s Cake Ball Creations. I can not thank you all enough for your loyalty, referrals and praise. I truly do enjoy what I do and could not grow this business without you. I can not wait to see what 2018 brings.
Enjoy the last few pictures of 2017, bring on the New Year!!!



Christmas Nativity PYO set! 10 cookies, 3 edible paint palettes, 10 paint brushes all boxed up and ready to go! These will be available starting December 17th thru December 23rd. I will take the first 50 people that respond to this post!...
Cost is $35.00.

I will confirm your request! Thank you!!!!

See More
No automatic alt text available.
No automatic alt text available.
No automatic alt text available.


This post brought in an overwhelming positive response. Stay tuned for flash Christmas orders up for grabs!


Thanks to everyone who ordered.....please don’t forget to pick up your elves!!

In 10 biggest enemy comes to visit, he stays for 25 days and causes me to loose sleep! My kids however think he is magical, amazing and so much fun! That’s right, the ELF ON THE SHELF makes his return😬

What better to celebrate his return than having him bring your kids, and even yourself a personalized Elf cookie. You know he owes you that much!!!

Cookies are $3.00 each, personalized and bagged/ribbon tied and will be ready when you are!!!

Please respond to this post with cookie amount and names! I will have them ready when you want!

See More
No automatic alt text available.
Image may contain: food

The holidays are here, my busiest time of the year!!!
Don’t worry, I still have openings for Christmas. Don’t forget to get your orders in. Cookies and Cake balls are perfect for teachers, holiday parties, co-workers, bosses, Santa and even a treat yourself!!

Kicking off the first weekend in November with a bang!!!! Lots and lots and lots of cookies, so many different themes. Cookies really can be customized for any occasion!

Another 2 weeks has flown by....I was a little better with pictures this time. New cakes, new designs, new color schemes, each week brings me something I have never done before. I love the challenge.

The holidays are just around the corner. Get your orders in early. Don’t forget to order cookies to wow them at your holiday parties, give to co-workers, leave for Santa or just as a treat for yourself!

The last few weeks have been crazy busy! Running a business and raising a family gets overwhelming at times......cookie pictures suffer when I get rushed!
Enjoy the few I did get and feel free to add your own!
Don’t forget to get your holiday orders in early😉

The last few weeks have been crazy busy! I have been terrible with pictures, so I only have a few to post. My favorite time of the year is coming....FALL....I will be putting together some Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas platters. I will be posting in the next few weeks. I am booking up fast so make sure to get your orders in!!!!!

Ok everyone, I did a show tonight and have lots of goodies left over.......
These make great teacher gifts, gifts for yourself or just a little something to brighten a friends day!!!
Let me know if you are interested!

They say if you do what you love, it is not a job......I love creating cookies, cakes, cake balls, etc. to help celebrate your events! Enjoy the past two weeks of photos.

Remember, I am still taking back to school orders on my Giant Pencil and Large Apple cookies. My kids start back this week but I know many kids have a few weeks to go😀