181 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Dave Brooks
· October 13, 2017
My wife and I opted to go gluten free and were having difficulty finding a good gluten free pizza until we discovered Tyeger's offers one and also subs. We have been very happy with the taste and qual...ity. Another pizza place (which we won't name) has a gluten free crust that is like eating burnt cardboard. Tyeger's is cooked just right and very tasty. We will definitely recommend Tyeger's to anyone we know that is on this diet and of course will definitely return. See More
Michele Bowling
· December 2, 2017
This place is a gem! I have Celiac Disease and have to be very careful where I eat because of the risk of cross contamination. I've never gotten sick because they take extreme care! We love this p...lace! Not only do they have great food but the staff is knowledgeable and friendly. They treat you like family when you go in! I highly, highly recommend! Thanks! See More
Billie Jo
· October 13, 2017
Went there for the first time with my son an the pizza was the best I have ever had, the owner was friendly an it was a very nice place to eat an enjoy a good meal. The pizza was hot an the toppings w...ere excellent an the bread was baked perfect. My son was right when he said I had to go there an try the food..Im glad I did cause now I want to go back. We will definitely be going back soon... See More
Brett Bauer
· October 1, 2017
Very good. Came highly recommended from a few friends and tried it for the first time last night and was very impressed. Love the pizza and the Guinness bread was good also. Looking forward to trying ...some other things on their menu. See More
Zak Dobson
· December 11, 2017
The best pizza place there is. Never disappointing, complete with great service and great food.
Narda A Linn-Lewis
· August 11, 2017
I have yet to find anything I didn't like here! The service as well as the food is excellent! Definitely recommend them! If you haven't tried the food it is worth the trip!!! Way to Go!!!
Kathy Raynee Prater-Ames
· August 24, 2017
First time trying Tygers Pizza. Had the Large Bono and the Guinness Bread and let me tell ya it was delicious. The thing I enjoyed the most is that it tastes like it was made with good quality ingredients.
Ashley Wheatley
· June 19, 2017
Tried this place for the 1st time yesterday and everything was so delicious! We each got a different kind of pizza and shared. Great job and if you end up opening another pizza place, I recommend Hunt...ington. Lol Until then we will make the drive to Bluffton. It's worth the drive! See More
Richard A. Johnloz Jr.
· October 30, 2017
Best pizza not only in Bluffton, but best I have had in any city or state.
Derek Pillie
· August 18, 2017
Friendly service, tasty food, great atmosphere... all for a great value! I'm not sure what more you could ask for other than slightly longer lunch hours! ;)
Amanda Hamilton
· January 14, 2018
Best pizza in Bluffton. Had a dairy free option and it was amazing.
Troy McAfee
· April 20, 2017
Best pizza place around! Love the variety you can choose from and all the different toppings especially ones you wouldn't expect on pizza! Have taken friends and family here and now they love it! Iris...h loaded baked potato is my favorite and the service is very friendly and fast! Pizza of the months are also great to try! The Guinness bread beats any breadstick! And of course the Irish theme is awesome! Would recommend to anyone especially if you want to try something different and delicious. See More
Ben Renkenberger
· August 30, 2017
This little pizza joint makes me smile! Their pizza is as good as you'll find!! Check them out and Bluffton, IN!
Gayle Smith Stuhrberg Fick
· May 31, 2017
Perfect day for a bike ride to Bluffton for Tyeger's pizza...we've been meaning to get down there ever since Ryan Duvall's column in the J-G. They deserve the rave review he gave them...almost thin cr...ust, sauce made daily, heaping toppings and everything done in house. AND Tyeger, and his tiger decor, is a hoot! See More
Brenda Y Hernández Sodi
· August 11, 2017
A pizza to die for !!.. i highly recommend the paddy roll
Phill Dilley
· December 31, 2016
This place is absolutely fantastic. I've had pizza from basically everywhere around Fort Wayne and the surrounding areas and this place is one of the best ! Be sure to grab an order of the Garlic bread to go with the pizza! The hot subs are fantastic as well! See More
Dustin Reynolds
· May 6, 2017
I've eaten at Tyeger's pretty regularly ever since it first opened, and I've never had a negative experience. The food is amazing and the friendly service is just as good.
Jerod Clampitt
· November 10, 2015
Tyeger's is a great pizza place ran by an amazing family. They pride themselves on taste not crust, so the amount of toppings are perfect. Their pizza of the month specials come up with interesting th...emes that taste great. Go to Bluffton and give them a try you won't be disappointed. See More
Zack Anderson
· December 31, 2015
The best around! Nowhere else will you find the quality or diversity of food. The service is hands down the best. Ty always remembers my name and even my order when calling by phone. Tygers is the bes...t and will be for years to come! See More
Shannon Musselman
· October 2, 2016
It was ok. I don't know if I really like the sweet taste to the pizza sauce. The pizza was decent. I'm not saying it's bad. Probably would go back to try other items. Nice clean place and friendly service.
GrantandHeather La Vigne
· May 28, 2016
The best pizzas and subs are found at Tyegers Pizza. Stopped in tonight for a few subs and saw the ad for Memorial Day specials, Irish meatloaf pizza & taco pizza. I'll be back for that taco pizza thi...s weekend! See More
Lisa Privett
· September 17, 2017
Be pizza ever!! Love this place will be going back!
Sharon Smith Strickling
· March 5, 2017
Some of the best pizza ever - good unusual variety plus regulars; we always love to visit with the owner; he gives great, friendly service.
Blake Fiechter
· January 7, 2017
The absolute best pizza! You have to ask for the pizza of the month! Loaded with toppings and awesome flavors!
Wesley Chubb
· April 13, 2017
Yup I'm hooked!! Great place to get the best pizza and subs in town!! Love the meal deal for a quick lunch.
Ryan Pimpinhos Purvis
· September 18, 2016
Heard about this place from a highly successful friend from out of state,that I used to work with in Seattle. And yes it is that damn good.
Greg Love
· March 16, 2014
I'm only basing this on 1 visit, but I'm going to say I like this place. tyeger was very friendly, he even remembered mom being in there the night before. I had the Reuben Sandwich and its much better... than the Reuben from Arbys. I look forward to eating everything on the menu this year. See More
Russ Peterson
· March 30, 2016
The blarney pizza is one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten! The staff are wonderful friendly people.
Kelsey Jean Marshall
· July 15, 2016
Best pizza by far! My favorite part about Tyeger's pizza is the unique combination and toppings that this place offers! I love trying new things and this pizza is awesome!
Mike Cayot
· December 6, 2016
A got to try place. Great food and different takes on pizza that you won't find anywhere else.
Tara Drumm
· November 5, 2016
Fantastic food and great service. We had a pepper steak and a Hawaiian pizza and their baked pasta. All delicious!! :)
Natalie Raines
· August 29, 2015
we have tried twice on a weekend to eat here. Driven 1.5 hours from home, enjoyed Ouabache State Park only to arrive at their location to find "special" hours on a normal Saturday night. Had even ch...ecked website before leaving. They may have good food but to not be open on a Saturday night and not to inform on their website is POOR customer relations. Needless to say we will NEVER EVER try to eat here again. See More
Daniel J Allen
· January 22, 2016
Had the pizza and garlic bread sticks was very good will be back for more great food
Nick Huffman
· March 10, 2017
Some of the best pizza you will ever try! They also have really good subs!!
Brad Schoeff
· August 16, 2014
The only pizza to consider. Creativity with fresh ingredients and the friendliest of owners makes this the best restaurant in Bluffton.
Jeff McLaughlin
· August 21, 2016
Everything you make is a(maize) the Cuban today loved it! If you haven't tried it you need too!!! Go Blue!!
Betty Masterson
· October 1, 2015
love this pizza, very friendly staff and affordable prices, best pizza around!
Junior Copeland
· September 30, 2014
Hands down best pizza in town...better than some of the over priced.... no names mentioned places !!
Delmar Jackson
· April 8, 2017
Best pizza in North east Indiana!!! And the best pizza I've had since living in California!!!
Jason Baker
· March 9, 2014
The best pizza place in Bluffton. Forget Pizza King, Tyeger's is where it's at!!
Officially announcing our 6th Win in 6 Years via the fort wayne newspapers (Sentinal & Gazette) and!!! We are super excited to have served northeast Indiana for the past 6 years & look forward to the next 6 years, with a greater commitment to excellent customer service, the best ingredients, creative offerings for your family & a never ending supply of sheer pizza perfection!! *** Fun Rap Video written, directed & starring Pamela Dolphin Walton for Tyeger's 6th Best Pizza Win in 6 Years!! Thanks to all our fans, going for 7th Win starting NOW!!!!! (awesome share, Pamela, very cool) ♥ (does contain the B-word at the end, for parents discretion)

Shrimp pizzas & subs available every Friday through the Lenten season starting tomorrow - We can also do a few past potms like the Bunratty Shrimp (our garlic butter Cajun) or the BBQ Shrimp & Pineapple Belfaster!! Our usual Lent cheese pizza special is also avail on Fridays for $12.50 for a large cheese pizza (no substitutions). We have BBQ Ribs & Chicken subs this Fri - Weds for $7.50!!!

Tyeger's will be closed March 2 (Fri) thru March 4 (Sun) for a private event - Please sign up for the St. Paddy's Day pizza eating contest at the shop, thank you!!!

Image may contain: pizza and food

Preparations for St. Patrick's Day Bono Eating Contest are going on. Know anyone who wants to be a contestant or try again this **March 17th (Saturday) at 7pm? You will be competing against last year's winner, so head's up!! Let Tyeger know at the shop or send me a PM to enter.

** must be available from 645pm until 730pm - each contestant is given a medium Bono (everything) pizza - spaces are limited - contest begins promptly at 7pm 🐯🍕🐯🍕

Image may contain: food

Take a photo of you and your family adopting a precious new furry family member this February from the Bluffton Animal Shelter & show it to us here at the shop and you can walk away with a FREE medium, 2 topping pizza to celebrate the love!!!!

WC Friends of the Shelter

❤️❤️❤️ Need a Valentine? ❤️❤️❤️ HALF-PRICE adoptions on cats throughout the month of February at the Bluffton Animal Shelter!!! Stop searching for a Valentine and adopt one today!

Look at who made the February edition of the Fort Wayne Magazine!!!! We are so blessed to have the most wonderful fans in the universe!! Yes, the universe, y'all rock, thank you!!

Our potm is our BBQ Ribs & Chicken pizza - have a great week, friends, cya for dinner soon!!! 🍕🐯🍕🐯

Image may contain: text and food
Image may contain: text
Image may contain: text

Please spread the word...

The Wells-Bluffton Animal Shelter is looking for emergency help taking care of several horses that were recently seized from a Uniondale farm.

A local animal shelter is looking for help after 10 horses were seized from a Uniondale farm.

New month, new potm!! Our BBQ Ribs & Chicken (you read that correctly) pizza also has corn & cheese on it!! We DO have sweet cannolis (3/ $4.50) this week

SuperBowl Sunday hours & group special: open for lunch (11am - 1pm) & dinner (open at 4pm) - Get 3 large, one topping pizzas and 3 full orders of garlic bread w/cheese for $49.99

Image may contain: food

We have sweet ricotta & chocolate chip cannolis this week!! 3 for $3 - last week for the potm, Steak Salad pizza!!

Image may contain: dessert, table, food and indoor

Ricotta Week here at Tyeger's!!! We LOVE this Italian cheese famous for it's slightly sweet taste and creamy white color - half the year, our Ricotta arrives from an organic small farm in California (March - August) & Vermont (September - February), we are privileged to provide from cows fed w/pecans & fresh oranges as snacks!!

Thurs - Sun:: free ricotta on any medium or large pizza ordered - just ask!!!! Food shouldn't be boring!!!! (1/18-1/21)

Image may contain: food
No automatic alt text available.
Bluffton Parks

Daddy Daughter Galaxy Dance – Dads bring your daughter to a dance that is out of this world. Enjoy quality time with your little girl with refreshments, photos ...and door prizes for each child. A variety of Star Wars characters will be roaming the dance floor so be sure to bring your camera. Attire is either Star Wars costumes or black and white semi formal. Tickets are on sale in the Clerk Treasurer’s office at City Hall for $5 per person. The dance will be held at the 4-H building from 6-8pm on Sunday Feb 18th.

See More

New year, new month, new potm!! Our Steak Salad pizza is on our Italian dressing with steak, tomato, spinach, green pepper, onion & cheese - pictured below!!

Image may contain: food

All weekend long, Chicago Dog pizzas available thru NYEve (make it vegetarian by substituting for a veggie)!!!

Normal hours this week with the exception of NYEve, open from 4pm - 9pm - please have a SAFE evening full of holiday cheer, surrounded by fam & friends - Have a great new year!!!!

Image may contain: food

Thursday!! Santa arrives at 6pm and will be here until 7pm!! Bring the kiddies and a camera!!

Holiday schedule: Closed December 24th thru December 27th - NYEve open from 4pm - 9pm & Chicago Dog pizza available that weekend!!

Santa is coming to Tyeger's!! Bring the kiddies & your camera on Thursday, Dec. 21st from 6p - 7p for a visit with the big man, himself

Image may contain: 2 people, people sitting