67 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Ann-Marie Redder
· October 11, 2017
This is the best cake I’ve ever eaten. I’m still dreaming about it.

I ordered a two tier wedding cake, white with cassata filling, and 200 cupcakes for my wedding on 9/16/17, chocolate/chocolate, wh...ite/white, yellow/chocolate, and strawberry/ champagne. Each with a candy heart with an R on it.

My cake and cupcakes were gorgeous and so delicious that I didn’t even have any leftovers. None!

Do yourself a favor and order your cake from here.
See More
Sondra Elizabeth
· October 22, 2017
Diane is the literal best. Our wedding cake was to die for and working with her was a joy!!!!
Lindsay Harlock
· May 5, 2017
Caramici's provided my wedding cake, which was absolutely delicious and memorable!! One of the best parts of the day, aside from marrying my husband of course. �Since then, she has baked cakes for spe...cial birthdays in my family. I'm planning on ordering from her for years to come. Very worth the money! See More
Melanie Gregg McGovern
· April 12, 2017
Diane made us an amazing wedding cake three years ago. She also remembered me when I called for an anniversary cake. I was so moved when I saw that anniversary I cried and hugged her. People still tal...k about our cake to this day. Do yourself a favor and hire her to make your wedding or any other cake. You won't regret it! Thank you! See More
Tyrone Moore
· August 23, 2017
I highly recommend this location for any dessert your looking for your event. Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. Two thumbs up.
Stephanie Ritchey
· October 1, 2016
Caramici's made all of the cakes for our wedding. We had a two tiered cake for our table and then 17 other cakes for each table. Everyone loved them-each and every unique flavor was perfect!!
Emily McNulty
· February 9, 2016
I love Diane! She did a full dessert reception for my wedding, everything from cupcakes, cannoli's, cookies, cake pops, and even special Batman cutout cookies, surprise for my groom. All my guests wer...e raving about how delicious and elegant everything was. See More
Nicole Margaret
· September 11, 2016
Diane did and amazing job with our wedding cake! I was so impressed and amazed at how it turned out! Not only was it beautiful but it was delicious! Thank you so much!!
Krista Ilecki
· October 9, 2016
I couldn't have asked for a more beautiful looking and even better tasting cassata cake. Diane did such an amazing job and I can't wait to order from here again!
Maureen Brady
· September 26, 2013
We had a delicious dinner at Caramici's tonight (chicken parm and spaghetti and meatballs)! Their chocolate chip truffle cookie was also delicious, and we brought some cookies home for our kids. All... desserts looked wonderful. See More
Fawn DiPalma
December 19, 2013
Amazing!!! We had ultimate chocolate slice and a peanut butter slice... Not so good on Italian cookies, Oliver St. Bakery in NT is by far the best in town, but Caramici's takes the cake on cakes :)
Yvette Gordon
· August 18, 2016
The sesame seed cookies are out of this world!!! All of the cookies are the best in the city, hands down!!
Michael Kawa
· May 19, 2014
Stopped in for a late dinner on a Saturday with friends and family after coming from the North Park theatre. Very pleasant atmosphere and great Italian food! met the owners Diane and Rick Serra who us feel right at home. Our new place to hang out after going to see a flick. See More
Carolyn Quigley
February 19, 2013
We have a cassata cake from Caramici's that we froze in tiny pieces. Pretty much every other day we pull a piece of cake out of the freezer and anxiously wait while the masterpiece defrosts... and the...n we gobble it up in about two minutes. Delicious! See More
Karen Amber
· March 31, 2014
I purchased my sister's wedding cake here. All night everyone was telling me that it was the best cake they ever had. It even looked as great as it tasted!
Anastashia Bevenhower
· August 2, 2013
Best food I've had in a long time. The bakery is to die for and the caprese is heaven on a plate!
Taylor Paul
· February 11, 2016
I'm from Texas and had my first cannoli here And it was delicious! Can't wait to come back for more!!
Nancy Abramo
· December 31, 2016
Diane does the best work in town. We love Caramici's. Happy new year Diane and family.
Zirka Lelito
· August 13, 2014
Just had our one year anniversary cake on Sunday, and it was still as delicious as it was on our wedding day!! Thank you guys again!!!!!
Jane Rynaski
· February 18, 2014
Fabulous food, creatively prepared. Excellent service in every aspect.... friendly staff and personal touches. 5 stars all the way!
A preview of Higher Vibe's performance at Caramici's on Friday, August 2nd. Great job guys, thanks for playing for us!
Come see The Paradime tonight for our 1 year birthday party! Complimentary apps will be served :)
Cakes, cookies and pastries for any and all occasions! 716-874-CAKE.

Dorian has a baby sister who turned one. Happy Birthday Davina

Image may contain: dessert and food

Congratulations Niagara Regional Theatre Guild on 95 years of successful entertainment. Thrilled to be part of the Company!

Image may contain: dessert and food

Check us out at the Wedding Band Extravaganza at Paul's Jewelry Design. Today only until 5pm

Image may contain: table and food

Dead car battery. Hoping to get a ride to the bakery soon. Sorry if I missed you.

Christmas is busy for everyone. Let us make your cookies so you can spend time on all your other projects. Call 716-874-CAKE

We've got what you need for Christmas. Be sure to get your orders in asap. Also, shop from our full line of cookies, INCLUDING MAGIC CHOCOLATR CHIP AND RASPBERRY, and many others. AND DON'T FORGET OUR FRESH FILLES CANNOLI. Stop by Tuesday thru Saturday 12 noon till 6!

Join us for a Holiday Shopping Adventure!
Wednesday, December 6, 2017.
5:30pm - 8:00pm
Lilypad Boutique
3969 Main Street , Snyder, NY ...
(right next to Ziggys across from St. Benedict’s)

The Holiday Shopping Adventure features -
• Lilypad Boutique - jewelry, note cards and greeting cards,
soy and olive oil products like soaps, candles, body scrubs lotions and potions,
yoga mat spray’s, hand towels, coasters, gift plates, purses, scarves, and more.

• Caramici's Bakery will be offering the immediate purchase of
cookies, cupcakes, brownies etc. and, of course, cannoli YAY!
Also available will be order forms for holiday ordering with a discount.

Caramici's Bakery
711 Niagara Falls Blvd
(located in Trinity United Methodist Church)
Amherst, NY 14226

AND .... 10% of all sales is going to O'Connell & Company & their charity outreach!
The adventure features ... basket give away ... special deals ... Munchies and WINE!!

Join us! Invite friends! Let's put the Ho in Ho! Ho! Ho!

See More

We may be out of sight, but don't let us be out of mind. Taking orders for Thanksgiving through Monday, Nov 20

Need pies? Call me. They're fresh and delicious.

10 days till Thanksgiving. Get your orders in for pies. Delicious, made fresh. We bake or try our take and bake! Call 716-874-CAKE.

It is time to order your pies for Thanksgiving. 10" deep dish all butter crust, all made to order and all made fresh. We have all your, pumpkin, chocolate silk, banana cream, cherry, blueberry, coconut custard, pecan and more! Call 716-874-2253 for yours.

Caramici's Bakery

WHAT'S THE BUZZ you ask? Caramici's Bakery will be featured on The Daily Buzz on WBBZ MeTV, cable channel 5, Monday, October 23rd. The show airs from 10-11 am.... Join us as we discuss the art of cannoli, plus Chocolate Silk Pie. See our wedding cake display, tray of assorted Italian cookies and even a cinnamon roll. Can't watch? Feel free to DVR or Like The Daily Buzz on facebook where it will be streaming live!

See More

WHAT'S THE BUZZ you ask? Caramici's Bakery will be featured on The Daily Buzz on WBBZ MeTV, cable channel 5, Monday, October 23rd. The show airs from 10-11 am. Join us as we discuss the art of cannoli, plus Chocolate Silk Pie. See our wedding cake display, tray of assorted Italian cookies and even a cinnamon roll. Can't watch? Feel free to DVR or Like The Daily Buzz on facebook where it will be streaming live!