Jump to
Press alt + / to open this menu
See more of Fenicci's of Hershey on Facebook
See more of Fenicci's of Hershey on Facebook
Create New Account
Reviews Containing: x

Never would have crossed my mind, but holy moly this is good!

eating Shrimp Scampi Pizza with Etta Nichols and 2 others at Fenicci's of Hershey.
Image may contain: 2 people, pizza and food
Allison Cline Saia added a new photo.

Dark Side of the Moon cake. How fitting before Brit Floyd! He's a happy guy tonight!

— with Dan E Saia at Fenicci's of Hershey.
Image may contain: 1 person, smiling, sitting, drink, table and indoor
Wendee Q Lewis reviewed Fenicci's of Hershey5 star
January 27

The calamari salad was overloaded with calamari and so good! I took more than half home.

But the best part of the visit was the staff. Our server, Lisa, was awesome. I arrived well before the rest of my large party, and she was wonderful! Another staff member caught me out on the phone in the ladies room and apparently my friends had wondered what happened to me and we had some laughs over that. The atmosphere was lively and fun and credit for that has to go to the staff.

Can't wait to go back. Wish I lived closer.

Ed Velez reviewed Fenicci's of Hershey3 star

For a Sunday, we were surprised that we needed reservations. So due to that we had to eat at the bar. Being we were on a schedule and needed to get to the Giant Arena for a concert, we didnt want to trek around town so we opted for the bar experience. Bartender was not totally with familiar with the menu so when I placed my order he had to come back 3 minutes later and ask me what I wanted and I showed him the special sheet that was with the menu and then he figured it out....

My beef marsala was alright. It was beefy for sure! could have used a little more mushrooms and perhaps a little more marsala (was hard to taste it). My wife ordered the 'homemade' lasagna and thought it tasted like store bought Stouffers. I had her leftovers the next day and albeit edible, it was different tasting. Perhaps my tastebuds are not used to homemade...Could the quality of the dining room food have been different? In a pinch, it was good but I have had better at smaller and less noted eateries.

See More
Megan Nye reviewed Fenicci's of Hershey5 star

First timer, and I'm so mad at myself for waiting this long! Came in tonight for my birthday dinner with the family (all first timers). Made an online reservation which was super easy! Walked in and greeted by the sweetest girl and shown right to our seats (we scored the corner table overlooking chocolate ave) The food, OMG I've never had food like that! The crab dip is to die for, I'll be dreaming about it for days lol, and the seafood Alfredo....perfection! We can't wait to come back! Your staff was so friendly and accommodating. Our waitress was a rockstar and delivered everything we asked for and even when we didn't! Thank your for an exceptional birthday dinner

Last minute dinner reservations and they were able to accommodate. Prices were fair and the food was excellent. The wait staff was very polite and I can’t say a nicer thing about our waitress, Dede. She was great and very knowledgeable about the menu. My wife and daughter requested a dinner to be split and they didn’t hesitate. If you plan to go, request a table In her area. You will not be disappointed.

Jennifer Schaeffer reviewed Fenicci's of Hershey5 star
February 11

Never disappointed!! Made a lunch reservation for a Saturday afternoon. We chose a booth near the bar and received the same great service as the dining room. All our food was amazing; appetizers, salad and entrees all came out well spaced and not rushed. We always make room for dessert and we were not disappointed. Obviously we will be back again!!

Christa Gaspari- Herrick reviewed Fenicci's of Hershey1 star

Gross. Pasta was undercooked and starchy. Husbands veal was tough. Sent everything back and said no thanks, no time for a redo since we have comedy club tix. Manager had an attitude and still tried to charge us for an entree even though we ate none of it. Will NEVER be back. The fact that I had to walk out of a restaurant hungry because their food was that inedible is sad. I used to love this place �
I spent some time reading your comments on here to unsatisfied customers. They were rude and painfully obvious that you do not care about your customers if they are unhappy.

Max Jamelli reviewed Fenicci's of Hershey5 star
January 15

My favorite place in Hershey. It’s one of the places I meet my parents since we live 2 hours apart (Hershey is a midpoint)

We just sprung a 14 seater birthday table on Sunday and the food was on point as usual. Our waitress was friendly and attentive - always a great time here.

Will keep coming back!

Dave Brennan reviewed Fenicci's of Hershey5 star

This was the first in a long time that we visited. It was following the Jewel concert at the Hershey Theater. The pasta, salad, and bread rolls were very good. The music added a nice touch for the Christmas season. Alexis was very courteous. Unfortunately, we missed being able to use the discount with our key from the Days Inn. We'll be sure to come again.