157 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Solaris Buddy Gregory
· March 23, 2015
Excellent food...and great people that work there. They treat you like family! I got the tuna poke as an appetizer and gluten free rasta pasta with a filet on top. Both were amazing! My wife got t...he no worries shrimp curry rice bowl. I'd give the place an 11 out of 10! Love the atmosphere!!! See More
Jennifer DeMaria
· August 18, 2014
Kaya Island Eats is FANTASTIC. The food is consistently delicious, and the presentations are beautiful. There is no other place in the Keys that I have been (I live here full time) that time after tim...e hits a home run as Kaya does. The service also is always friendly, but not pushy. Noteworthy is that for me, as a vegan, there is no other place that puts as much joy and passion into their food in all the Keys. Whether I'm ordering something "accidentally vegan" straight off the menu, or whether Scott is making some type of evil-genius meal for me on his own, I have NEVER been disappointed here. The food combinations are flavorful, and you will not get this level of quality any place else down here. Scott, thank you! You are a testament to what any real chef should aspire to, your creativity seems to know no bounds. Your passion for your craft shines through over and over. You make dining out a pleasure! Thanks for so many great meals, so many more to come, and best of all I'm absolutely freaking delighted to be able to refer so many people to you knowing they're in such capable, caring hands! Long live Kaya Island Eats, Scott, and your whole amazing crew! See More
Made Motto
June 22, 2013
Good morning,
We were there this Tuesday. We are a group of asian. Our server is Britney. We enjoyed our dinner very much. I had fish n chip. We were about ready to go n decided to try the famous Key... lime pie. OMG, it's soo good...
The of our order was 2 min late witches it's not a big deal. Suddenly the manager came up and offer a free drink. We said it's not necessary. What an awesome service.
I definitely will eat here if i come back to key west... Great job guys.
See More
Robert Thompson
April 17, 2013
We just left there and this is one of the best restaurants I have ever been to... Between the gorgeous views, extremely friend and very knowledgeable staff about the food they are serving, to the abso...lutely fantastic food. I had a blackened Asian/Cajun mahi mahi with a ginger carrot salad that was fantastic... I cannot say enough good things about this place! See More
Mindy Budden
· July 5, 2014
We bought a house here 3 years ago & Kaya Island Eats has been open for 3 years too. We love this place! Always have wonderful food, drinks & service. Our favorite!
Scott Davis
· December 31, 2014
Kaya cooked up out fresh grouper tonight. I had the sesame and my wife had the coconut crusted dishes. Extraordinary flavor and fantastic presentation. Thanks Kaya.
Andrea Pateras
· March 9, 2014
The best crab cakes I've ever eaten! Best over all food I've eaten. Same goes for my husband. Very nice atmosphere. Very friendly and helpful staff.
Mark Certonio
January 22, 2012
We went to dinner the other night and it was the best, service was great and to die for conch fritters and fresh fish
Maria Giangrande Cotelo
· December 8, 2014
Our first dining experience at Kaya the food was delicious the service was impeccable ! I would def recommend it !
Michael Td
· December 10, 2014
One of the best in the Lower Keys! Great staff, creative recipes, Island atmosphere. Scott does it all in his own inimitable way. Great Job!
Kathy Waters Jones
· August 27, 2013
Food was outstanding and the service was excellent......thanks Matthew!!!! My new favorite restaurant in the keys!!! Even if u r in the Middle Keys, it's worth the drive!!!!
Darice Lane Horachek
· October 7, 2013
We love this place. We take our catch here and Scott also amazes us. Love his great attitude which trickles down to his staff.
Jill Edwards Snodgrass
· December 31, 2014
Everything was awesome - food, presentation, staff! Korean tacos and tuna poke not to be missed!
Josh True
· December 18, 2014
Wonderful overall experience, staff and food was phenomenal. The owner made us feel comfortable and made sure we were taken care of.
Pamela Ann Parkhurst Kanarr
· November 2, 2014
great food gourmet quality at an affordable price. i will definitely be here next trip
Dennis OHalloran
· November 13, 2013
No better place to have my birthday dinner! This place continues to impress!
Aubrey Ann
· August 27, 2014
Amazing dining experience, superior staff, beautiful views, food lovers you must go!
Tommy Tran
· December 5, 2014
the food was delicious, plating was exquisite and customer service was top notch!
Ashley Leyfert
· March 9, 2015
Fabulous food, a wonderful staff, and the most beautiful restaurant in the Keys. I Kaya!
Mark Gregorski
· March 9, 2014
Best place I ever ate, staff and owner went above and beyond, from the ice tea to the entree, no detail was overlooked
Kaya Island Eats updated their cover photo.
No automatic alt text available.
Kaya Island Eats added a new photo.
June 3, 2015
No automatic alt text available.