25 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Joe Walsh
· November 25, 2016
Sorry to hear that you're permanently closing the store in early 2017. You guys deserve to retire but just know that both of you will be missed. I will be coming in a few more times before you close.
Michelle Mohr
· November 15, 2014
This toy store is awesome. My kids love seeing all of the unique toys (and filling their Christmas lists!). And I love supporting this local business that has great products, great service, and helpfu...l owners that really care about their customers. See More
Seldom Seen Shirley
· July 4, 2015
My daughter, my husband and I all love this store and its wonderful owners, and visit as often as we can. We see something new every time we're in that gets us thinking, wondering, and playing. Thanks so much!
Rob Gallegly
· January 2, 2017
Told them when I saw them at Pags how much that store meant to me and my family. Where else can someone go to get awesome toys that encourage creativity and imagination. We love you guys. Enjoy you...r retirement. See More
Vanessa Fay Witt
· January 9, 2016
Very lovely store. The prices are reasonable and the staff is wonderful. I highly recommend this unique and magical toy store for all ages.
Susan Pearlman
· October 5, 2014
I love this store! As an early childhood educator, I can vouch for its high-quality inventory. If you are looking for wonderful toys, this is the place to go.
Marsha L. Evans Boyd
· September 29, 2016
Quality toys and such a good selection to choose from!
Alison Fuhrhop
· January 10, 2015
Unique toys. Love the Indestructibles books and Green Toys. Owners are always super helpful.
Paul Sloboda
· August 15, 2013
First business I've ever recommended on FB or internet; surely that says something. This store = awesome. There! It's on record! :)
Albert Parr
· July 30, 2014
When I go in I always find something for my grandchildren.
Hannah Creamer
· January 15, 2016
I love the variety they have there! And everyone is so friendly.
CJ Nelson
· November 21, 2013
High quality toy store with excellent selection and wonderful staff.

We have four units of 12-ft Closetmaid ventilated wire shelving (16 inches deep) available for immediate purchase. Price is $7.00 each! Message us by Thursday! Here's a picture:

No automatic alt text available.

So it's the last chance at remaining stock today at My Favorite Toys! 75% off everything! The gate drops for the last time at 5:30 p.m.!

Words can't describe our gratitude for all those who have supported us these past 11+ years. It's been wonderful to see kids grow from infants to middle schoolers, and those who were elementary kids when we opened now returning as young adults. We've met and become friends with countless people, and we greatly value these experiences.

We also appreciate the kind words and best wishes directed to us this past month as we make plans to retire!

No automatic alt text available.

Three days left, and we're going out with a bang at My Favorite Toys! Today through Saturday everything is 75% off!!

We still have a good selection of Safari figures, books, the famous flying/screaming monkey (!), some Melissa and Doug infant, toddler and arts and crafts, windups, Poppers, and miscellaneous fun stuff!

Come see us, today, Friday and Satur,day 10 am to 5:30 pm.


Everything is 75% off! Share this if you can! Thanks!

See More
No automatic alt text available.

Our last camel and next-to-last poodle left My favorite Toys this afternoon into the safe care of these two young ladies!

We still have goodies left, but Saturday is our last day! Come see us!

Image may contain: 2 people, people smiling, people standing, dog, child and outdoor

50% off the entire store through closing day, Sat. Jan 7 at My Favorite Toys!

We're open at My Favorite Toys through Saturday, January 7!

We still have a number of Melissa and Doug baby and toddler items, arts and crafts selections good for birthday party gifts, Safari animals, etc. Come see us during these last few days!

No automatic alt text available.

So here's the offer you can't refuse at My Favorite Toy's Retirement/Store Closing Sale. Beginning today, the ENTIRE store is 50% off! This INCLUDES Legos and Calico Critters! We also have one new Thomas Playtable left, and we're reducing it to $99.95 (Regular $239.95!)!

But here it comes, here's the phrase, never more true: "At these prices, they won't last long!" Hurry in! Share this post if you can!

No automatic alt text available.

At My Favorite Toys' Store Closing Sale, there's still time! There are Legos, Melissa and Doug items, Calico Critters, airplanes, cars, large plush animals, arts and crafts, etc. waiting for you at great discounts!

But NOW is the time! Hurry in! Share this with others if you can. Thanks!

Image may contain: text

"Last night I dreamed there were still good selections of Legos (30% off), Calico Critters (35% off), Melissa and Doug items (50% off), and many other great buys at My Favorite Toys' Retirement/Store Closing Sale...."

That dream was true! Even the Calico Critters are visiting the Toy Shop! Hurry in today!

No automatic alt text available.

Wow! What a start to our Retirement/Store Closing Sale today. Thanks to all who came by to shop and say hi!

But wait, there's more! We have plenty of Legos, Calico Critters, Melissa and Doug items and many other great buys left. Come see us throughout this next week or so (we're not certain of our exact close date)! Best advice, though, is to hurry in as soon as you can!

No automatic alt text available.

Merry Christmas and Happy Hanukkah to all our friends throughout Facebook Land!

You probably know by now, but on Monday, Dec. 26 at 8 a.m. we start our Retirement/Store Closing Sale, with the entire store on sale at 30% - 60% off! Specifically all Melissa and Doug is 40% off, all Green Toys and Safari figurines 50% off, all Legos 30% off, all Calico Critters 35% off, all Christmas and other seasonal items 60% off, all Science items 40% off, and the rest of the store 50% off!... Fixtures, supples and demos are also on sale at great prices!

Stock up on birthday gifts and other treats for the entire year! Don't miss the toy sale of the year!

Please share this with others if you can!

See More
Image may contain: 1 person, text

Tomorrow is Thames and Kosmos Thursday at My Favorite Toys. All Thames and Kosmos science products are 30% off!

No automatic alt text available.

Tomorrow is "Doctor Who Whnesday" at My Favorite Toys at University Mall in Carbondale! We have a few Doctor Who Disappearing Tardis Mugs and Sticky Notes left and they're 30% off! Come see us!

No automatic alt text available.

Tomorrow is Truck Tuesday at My Favorite Toys! All Green Toys trucks and Battat Trucks are 30% off!

No automatic alt text available.