Reviews
4.3
269 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Ellen J. Brown
· August 17, 2017
One of our favorite places to dine, lunch or dinner. It is my "go to place" for out of town company and My Tomato Pie does not disappoint. Service is consistently good, love the coffee (important to m...e) and the food is delicious. My new favorite is the strawberries and goat cheese salad but I substitute crumbly blue with no problem. Pizzas are the best. Steak sandwich always done to perfection and the burgers are the best, bar none. Been eating at "the Pie" since they opened. See More
Jessica Senek
· October 8, 2017
Just got a pizza and it is the most pathetic looking thing ever. The bottom crust is like cardboard -- and thin cardboard. There isn't even fluffy crust on the outside either it is burnt and flat. Wha...t is this? See More
Bobby Jo Monroe
· July 16, 2017
In the past, I had nothing but good things to say about My Tomato Pie. The food has been great, the service has always been great. A friend of mine who lives in WNY introduced it to us, and we loved i...t so much that we always stopped in for lunch when I made the 2 hour drive out that way. But our experience this past weekend was different.

It was a special day, because it was my sisters birthday. We had ordered a peanut butter pie in advance (a full pie), and had hoped to surprise her with a slice for the first time. Ordering was the first snag, because although we have ordered these pies consistently for the past two years, this is the first time they mentioned using a credit card or paying a "cash advance" first. Apparently the manager has decided this is how it works now. But it depends on who you talk to because their staff doesn't seem to be on the same page with this at all.

Fast forward to Saturday when we showed up for lunch. The place was clean as always, staff was pleasant, and our appetizers and main entrees were delicious. The peanut butter pie that we'd had a hassle ordering however, was not. We hyped how amazing this pie was to my sister for weeks, and when we bit into our slices we were absolutely disgusted. Something was wrong with the crust. This isn't even close to how it usually tasted. We proceeded to eat the pie filling and leave the crust on our plates.

Considering that this pie was almost $40 with tax, we talked to our waitress, who in turn said they could take it off the bill. But when she returned, she said their offer was only $10 off and we take the rest of he pie home. I would have preferred to leave the pie. I had others who knew and loved the flavor of this pie try it, and they couldn't even stomach swallowing the crust.

This experience was so disappointing to me. I don't think that I would ever feel comfortable ordering another pie, and will probably avoid My Tomato Pie in the future in general after this.

Yes, I probably should have stayed and fought it. But I was on a time schedule to get my kids from the sitter, being that I live 2 hours away. And I probably should have had the manager taste the crust. It was that bad.
The waitress had initially mentioned taking it off my bill. Then came back with the $10 off. I sent a private message, hoping to get a response. And although the message was read, no response was given.
See More
Deb Lynn Lynn
· September 20, 2017
When I order a hamburger with bacon,cheese,an onion ring and barbecue sauce I do not want an apple as a side. I want french fries like the rest of the world ! The only choices for a side were chips, p...asta salad which I got and was VERY disappointed with or an " apple " . Whoever thought of offering these options instead of just plain fries should be fired. I ended up ordering the loaded fries and they were great for an extra 9 dollars. I don't go to a restaurant to get an apple...I go to a farmers market or the grocery store See More
Ryan Wagner
· October 28, 2017
Pizza we ordered was the wrong kinda and both entrees had tomatoes when we specifically ordered no tomatoes! Then double checked before we hung up! I don't get it ... waste of 30$
Shannon Furtak
· July 23, 2017
We were so excited to find out that my tomato pie had vegan cheese ! It's a bit pricey for a large pizza but fed two people for two meals. It was delicious and well worth it, and the service was excellent.
Charlie Brown
· December 4, 2017
Delicious food, as always. Wait staff was fantastic with our 16 person party. Highly recommend!! We will definitely be back again. Thanks!!
Heather Barnett Gelowitz
· October 19, 2017
Stopped in for lunch. Everyone in my party ordered a personal pizza. We all thoroughly enjoyed our lunch and look forward to returning!
Kelly Scott Cerifko
· April 30, 2017
We just had my daughter's first communion dinner at My Tomato Pie and everything was outstanding!! The baked penne, chicken parmesan and roast beef were all delicious! Our service was excellent and th...e entire evening was perfect!! This is not our first banquet here and it will not be our last! Thank you to Tony and everyone for always proving a wonderful dining experience!! I will continue to recommend you to everyone I know!! See More
Leesa Muhree
· January 4, 2018
Phenomenal! The food is fabulous, very classy restaurant, servers were caring and catered to our reservation. 1st time, but not my last.
Jenn Zawadzki
· March 20, 2017
First time trying this place and the last!!! My husband been wanting to try this place out for a while but the Food wasn't great at all!! The sauce had a plain taste to it. Not my liking (we been to ...many many Italian places from NYC to Toronto to Ohio to buffalo)The pizza bread was awful. It's plain and not much of a taste I was expecting the bread to be inspired by pizza I order a buffalo chicken finger pizza I said no onions and their was onions all over it.The chicken parm was over cooked the chicken was rubbery and breading was dark with a burnt taste not a nice golden brown color! At the end of our time their I ordered a steak wrap and I didn't want to eat a sandwich wrap at a Italian place, to me that is not why to go to a Italian restaurant! Terrible experience!!! See More
Princessa Figueroa-williams
· November 19, 2017
Love the food. Everything was great, even the staff.
Marisa Lucci
· July 27, 2017
Best gluten free pizza I have ever had. Great service as well!!! Highly recommend
Connor Schloop
· October 26, 2016
My husband and I are trying a new place each week, I heard about their new location from a Facebook post and I thought we should check it out. The outside was a little misleading, but the atmosphere i...nside is beautiful. There was a very good crowd for a Wednesday night. The menu is pretty big, I had the chicken parm calzone and I can't wait to come back and explore more of the menu. Service was great, food was good, and the chocolate peanut butter pie was delicious. Dinner for two plus drinks and dessert came to less than $60. Definitely will be a regular customer! See More
Tommy Milsher
· August 29, 2016
Milsher floor hockey father son big little big brother little brother 30 and over 16 and under Sunday morning draft floor hockey league game time eight nine ten. $50 sign up fee and 2 payments of $50 ...by the 5th week of a 15-week season. Goalies play for free. We are only accepting 30 kids and 30 adults. And six goalie. Sign up now. Spots are filling up quick. $50 deposit guarantees your spot. Call 716 812 5055.

Starting mid October. Sign up now. Spots will be reserved for the first 30 adults and first 30 kids that pay the $50 dollar registration fee.
See More
Peter Spanyi
· January 21, 2017
Before we went here I had seen some negative reviews but I very quickly realized you just can't satisfy some people. Everyone who works here is super friendly, the portions are gigantic and the food i...s delicious. It was fish fry Friday and OMG the plates were heaping with food. Highly recommend this place if you're in the area. See More
Craig Coronado
· March 8, 2017
My Wife and Myself were there on Friday Night the Pizza Bread, Loaded Fries, Chicken Fingers, and Onion Rings as well as the service were all great. My only complaint was the double order of wings wer...en't cooked all the way so I just got a to go box and finished cooking them at Home. So its a 4.5 out of 5 for everything else and a 1 for the wings. See More
Jamie Curran
· February 19, 2017
To be honest, I've never had their pizza. However, their tomato basil soup and Tuna Diablo wrap are to die for. I've been going to this location and the previous one for years. I've also had meetings ...and parties catered at their old location with awesome results. See More
Bianca Hayward
· February 25, 2017
We frequently visited the old location, and decided to give the new location a try with our family of 4 last night. The food was great, service was fast. We decided to leave a generous tip for the qui...ck service, as we had 2 hungry/miserable little kids... and food coming out fast was very much appreciated. Our bill came to $57, and we left $74 for our waitress. All was fine, until we were chased down in the parking lot and accused of not leaving enough money to cover our bill. The waitress miscounted and failed to see a $20 bill. All was great with our experience, until we were embarrassed in front of other customers who believed we were trying to skip out without paying our entire bill. A bit insulting when you leave a $17 tip on a $57 bill. Not sure if there was some preconceived idea that because we are a young couple with little kids, that we would rip off your restaurant and waitress or something. I understand and am sure this happens. However, I would be 100% sure I was being ripped off before chasing customers out in the parking lot and embarrassing them (especially after my husband made a point to personally thank the waitress on our way out.) Do not think we will return after this. See More
Pamela Savage Martin
· September 15, 2017
Always love it... Go often, so happy it's now around the corner from my house.
Photos
Videos
My Tomato Pie TV Commercial
6
2
My Tomato Pie TV Ad
1
Joe Webber Live at My Tomato Pie
21
Posts

What's your favorite dish?

Image may contain: food
My Tomato Pie updated their cover photo.
Image may contain: food
Posts

Our homemade Caesar Salad is one of the best in Buffalo.

Image may contain: food

Who wants a Strawberry and Goat Cheese Salad.

Image may contain: 1 person, food

Join us for a Cobb Salad today.

Image may contain: food

2 for 1 drafts all game, 17 beers to choose from including Ballast Point Brewing Company, Ellicottville Brewing Company, Peroni Nastro Azzurro, Great Lakes Brewing Company, Samuel Adams, Blue Moon Brewing Company, Allegheny Brewing Company, Molson Canadian, Coors Light, Long Trail Brewing, Angry Orchard, Southern Tier Brewing Company, to name a few.

FREE halftime buffet for everyone at the bar during the entire first half.

FEB4
Sun 6:00 PM ESTMy Tomato PieAmherst, NY

Join us today for lunch or dinner.

Image may contain: food

One of our number one selling sandwiches. Steak Portobello.

Image may contain: food and text

Tonight's Special - Classic Pan-Seared Ribeye with Cognac cream sauce, bacon sauteed beans, and cheesy potato croquettes.

Image may contain: food and text

Tonight's Special - Scarlet Snapper - Pan Seared with white wine butter sauce with fresh spinach.

Image may contain: food

Who is eating health Today? We have a salad for you.

Image may contain: food

Who wants a Shrimp Scampi today?

Image may contain: food

Have you tried Our Steak Portobello Focaccia Sandwich yet?

Image may contain: food