658 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Joanne Adams Seay
· March 9, 2018
This place has the best ice cream ever!!!! Such a sweet place with lots of flavors, old fashioned hand scooped and the best soft serve I have ever had. The prices are so reasonable it's refreshing. Ve...ry pleasant visit...highly recommend Nutter's Ice Cream! See More
Shirley Williams
· March 26, 2018
I love this place!! You definitely get more than you pay for!! The banana split is so big that 3 people can eat it.
Mike Allan
· February 4, 2018
Excellent ice cream, large portions, friendly service, and reasonably priced. How could you go wrong? Best ice cream shop around.
Charity Wilt
· January 27, 2018
Their ice cream is delicious! Good thing they are a nice drive away, or I would probably eat there more than I should. I will return!! ;)
Tonya DiNolfi
· April 20, 2018
The absolute best ice cream shop in the four state region!! ����
Claudine Fran Weddle Moore
· April 20, 2018
Great find awesome ice cream Thank you to the darling stranger ( young lady ) that bought my husband and I ice cream. ��
Tina Myers
· October 7, 2017
Hot apple sundae made with apple pie ice cream was delicious. Be warned though...CASH ONLY. Drove from Mercersburg, Pa just for the sundae and had to leave to drive around and find an ATM first.
John Bonbright
· June 21, 2017
Truly a local institution, been going there since the 90s. Excellent quality, huge portions, and shockingly cheap prices when compared to chain ice cream shops. The place always has a line but the har...d-working employees always keep it moving. Remember to bring cash (no plastic accepted) and don't be afraid to use the tip jar, people! See More
Brandi Shanholtz Collis
· July 31, 2017
Nutter's has the best ice cream. The employees are very friendly. The prices are even better. This is the only place we can go as a family of 6 and spend $23 and get mounds of ice cream. Keep up the g...reat work!! See More
Debra Hedge Hunsucker
· August 21, 2017
Nutters ice cream the best little shop. Stopped by on Sunday 50 people in line. Ladies worked fast and served everyone. Delicious as always might go back tomorrow ❤️
Aj Weiss
· May 26, 2017
Nutter's ice cream is a little hole in the wall with real old fashioned ice cream dishes such as banana splits. Their prices are more than reasonable but they only take cash. Love the ice cream and the value!!

There are plenty of places outside to sit as it's located in the heart of this quaint town. Expect to wait in line; its a very popular place for good reason!!
See More
Jessica Safreed Thomas
· April 16, 2017
Stopped here while on vacation in the area. The ice cream was delicious and a good price for how much you get. It was pretty crowded since it was one of the first nice days of spring, and the workers ...handled the crowd pretty speedily. The only thing that detracted from our visit was the attitude of the worker (owner?) Doris who snapped at customers and the other employees. It made waiting in line very stressful and uncomfortable! See More
David Alvord
· February 12, 2018
Great place that has been a staple of bringing smiles to people's faces for a LONG LONG time.
Michael Farrie
· November 1, 2017
Excellent place for ice cream. I highly recommend going there sometime and checking it out. You'll keep returning for more. 🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧🍧
Harry Dillon III
· August 15, 2017
A wonderful place for some ice cream while visiting Sharpsburg and the Antietam battlefield. We stopped two days in a row...LOL Great service and prices too. We will be back for sure.
Jessica Rogers Jaworski
· October 22, 2017
Great little place! The atmosphere is very Americana. Great prices and value! Love love love it!
Balleli Stewart
· March 26, 2018
No banana split for me way to big. Chocolate Almond two scoop for me.
Angela Foss
· March 4, 2018
Great place for ice cream and the price very cheap
Amber Woodruff- Fuller
· August 8, 2017
Small town feel, great quality ice cream & you can't beat the price! It was a favorite when I was in University and it's a Family favorite now. I tell everyone to go to Nutters!
Deborah Jones Saenz
· July 8, 2017
This is our absolute FAVORITE place to get ice cream! The ice cream is beyond amazing and you get MORE than your money's worth with VERY large portions!! We love it!

The first warm Saturday of spring has our customers lined outside the door and down the sidewalk ever since we opened for business at 1 o’clock! 😃

Image may contain: one or more people, car and outdoor

Warm weather is upon us... you know what that means!

No automatic alt text available.

Summer weather towards the end of the week... bring on a Banana Split or two!

Image may contain: dessert and food

Blueberries and Cream has returned!!

Image may contain: food

Reminder: We are closed for Easter and will reopen in Monday, April 2nd for normal hours.

No automatic alt text available.

Happy Easter! 🐰

Nutter's Ice Cream shared their post.
March 21

We will be closed Wednesday, March 21st because Mother Nature has skipped her meds again and it is still snowing. Everyone enjoy watching the snow fall and stay safe!

No automatic alt text available.
Nutter's Ice Cream

Closed Tuesday, March 20th due to the icy weather. We will evaluate road conditions in the morning to determine if we open tomorrow or not.

Stay safe everyone!

Closed Tuesday, March 20th due to the icy weather. We will evaluate road conditions in the morning to determine if we open tomorrow or not.

Stay safe everyone!

No automatic alt text available.

If you stop in the shop today, don't forget to wish both Deb and Doris a Happy Birthday! They each turn 25 (and some change)!

Image may contain: text

A cold and rainy night is the perfect time to dig into one of our banana splits! Then again, anytime is the perfect time for a banana split!! 😋

Image may contain: food

Red Devil Cake ice cream is back! Are you ready for it? (Picture of cake is not how ice cream looks)

Image may contain: dessert and food

Sunday, February 4th we will be closed due to snow.

On another note: While none of our teams made it... Go Eagles!

No automatic alt text available.

How much do you love Nutter’s? Hannah Grim (pictured) grew up next to Deb (Owner) and loves our ice cream. What would be more fun than to eat ice cream and have a photo shoot?

A “menu” of our current offerings! Keep in mind that several of our ice cream flavors are seasonal, and can be gone at any time.

From a photo shoot done in the shop. Hannah Grim enjoying some ice cream. All photo credits to the photographer.

Image may contain: 1 person

Stock up today! We will be open till 9 PM tonight, then we will not see you until Tuesday at 1. Again, from our family to yours have a safe and Happy New Year!

Image may contain: text
Nutter's Ice Cream

We want to wish everyone a Happy New Year! We will be closed New Years Eve and New Years Day. We will reopen Tuesday, the 2nd for normal hours.

Everyone be safe!