Jump to
Press alt + / to open this menu
CommunitySee All
Highlights info row image
7,839 people like this
Highlights info row image
7,734 people follow this
Highlights info row image
8,354 people have visited
AboutSee All
Highlights info row image
(301) 432-5809
Highlights info row image
Typically replies within minutes
Highlights info row image
Opens at 1:00pm
Closed Now
Popular hours
673 Reviews
People talk aboutbanana split, hot fudge and kiddie cone
Tell people what you think
John Bonbright
· June 21, 2017
Truly a local institution, been going there since the 90s. Excellent quality, huge portions, and shockingly cheap prices when compared to chain ice cream shops.... The place always has a line but the hard-working employees always keep it moving. Remember to bring cash (no plastic accepted) and don't be afraid to use the tip jar, people! See More
Aj Weiss
· May 26, 2017
Nutter's ice cream is a little hole in the wall with real old fashioned ice cream dishes such as banana splits. Their prices are more than reasonable but they ...only take cash. Love the ice cream and love the value!!

There are plenty of places outside to sit as it's located in the heart of this quaint town. Expect to wait in line; its a very popular place for good reason!!
See More
Brandi Shanholtz Collis
· July 31, 2017
Nutter's has the best ice cream. The employees are very friendly. The prices are even better. This is the only place we can go as a family of 6 and spend $23 and get mounds of ice cream. Keep up the great work!!
Jessica Safreed Thomas
· April 16, 2017
Stopped here while on vacation in the area. The ice cream was delicious and a good price for how much you get. It was pretty crowded since it was one of the fir...st nice days of spring, and the workers handled the crowd pretty speedily. The only thing that detracted from our visit was the attitude of the worker (owner?) Doris who snapped at customers and the other employees. It made waiting in line very stressful and uncomfortable! See More
Debra Hedge Hunsucker
· August 21, 2017
Nutters ice cream the best little shop. Stopped by on Sunday 50 people in line. Ladies worked fast and served everyone. Delicious as always might go back tomorrow ❤️
David Flamand
· June 20, 2017
I will never eat there again as a company named drakes heating and air cond was there spraying a air cond right above my head with some chemical while my self a...nd wife was eating ice cream at a table,the table was right underneath the air cond that he was working on and the spray was coming down on our food I went to say something about this to a older woman and she told me to get out of her place and never come back this woman does not even know me from atom so we went out side to eat our ice cream in the heat on the benches out side I will never go to this place again See More
Christi McCormick
· August 7, 2017
This place is AMAZING!! We were suggested to visit this place & we pulled up on a Sunday early evening and there was a line down the sidewalk and about 20+ eating ice cream outside.. Delicious & the staff so pleasant and quick! Bring Cash!! No credit or debit cards and who cares 👍🏻☺️
Jo'Anna Stine
· June 30, 2017
By far the best place to get ice cream in the area! Gotta try the banana split, but you better take a friend to help you finish!
Randi Agetstein
· July 10, 2017
The best chocolate chip ice cream ever!
The prices are very reasonable if not cheap.
There is typically a line, but well worth the wait.
Deborah Jones Saenz
· July 8, 2017
This is our absolute FAVORITE place to get ice cream! The ice cream is beyond amazing and you get MORE than your money's worth with VERY large portions!! We love it!
Bettina Barton Kingree
· July 30, 2017
I ordered a small ( 2 scoops is a small)frozen yogurt with chocolate and strawberry in a cup. Very large for a "small" and very creamy. Delicious! And only $2.00. Seriously!
Harry Dillon III
· August 15, 2017
A wonderful place for some ice cream while visiting Sharpsburg and the Antietam battlefield. We stopped two days in a row...LOL Great service and prices too. We will be back for sure.
Rick Wurtz
· April 13, 2017
Stopped in with my wife on the way home from Shepherdstown. We each got a small cup... for one scoop, it was HUGE. Really good ice cream and really reasonable prices too. Will be coming back with our kids.
Amber Woodruff- Fuller
· August 8, 2017
Small town feel, great quality ice cream & you can't beat the price! It was a favorite when I was in University and it's a Family favorite now. I tell everyone to go to Nutters!
Christianna Bonk
· March 31, 2017
Oh man, this is some incredible ice cream! So smooth and rich and creamy, and just soft enough that if you wanted to, you could mix it into a thick ice cream soup. :9
Thomas G. Kelliher
· July 15, 2017
I have been taking students from Chicago on Civil War Trips every summer. We have stopped at Nutter's two or three times during the trip for the past 20 years! Thanks for everything!
Whitney Mellott Hoch
· August 8, 2017
We love Nutters! You can't beat the price and it's so nice to sit in Sharpsburg while enjoying this treat on a Summer day.
Alan Daniel
· May 2, 2017
Ms. Deb and the staff are great! There is a reason the line wrap around the block. Small Town Americana at its finest
Amanda LaVigne
· August 12, 2017
Some of the best ice cream I've ever had at the most reasonable prices I've ever seen. I'll definitely return next time I'm in town.
Elizabeth Power
· August 8, 2017
Great Ice Cream. Large portion for the price. Definitely remembering this place for our next visit to Harper's Ferry.
Nutter's Ice Cream shared their photo.
21 hrs

Happy National Ice Cream Cone Day!

Pumpkin ice cream has returned for a limited time!!

No automatic alt text available.

We will be closed Monday, September 4th in observance of Labor Day and open on Tuesday for normal hours. Have a safe and fun holiday from our family to yours!

No automatic alt text available.

We made the Hotlist 2017! Thanks for your votes!

by Matt Makowski, Steve Sears & Beth Vollmer and photos by Turner Photography Studio
Nutter's Ice Cream added 2 new photosfeeling frustrated.
August 8

Just a friendly reminder of rules we have for posting remarks or images, commenting on others, or posting a review. We at Nutter's have tried to play nice, but others do not seem to listen.

We DO NOT tolerate foul language, derogatory remarks about gender, orientation, race/ethnicity, or negative comments in any manner being used on our page whether used in a post to our page, comment/reply to another person on our page, or a review of our business. We do not care if the comm...ent is directed towards Nutter's Ice Cream (the business itself), our staff, or other customers- IT WILL NOT BE TOLERATED.

This will result in you being banned from the page. This action includes, but is not limited to, removing your previous posts and preventing you from ever seeing the page, as well as reporting your actions to Facebook for their review. Our Page Administrators (Anthony, Brenda, & Jennifer) will review each incident as they happen and take the necessary actions to ensure our page is a positive environment for all.

As of this morning two individuals were banned from our page and reported to Facebook for reprehensible comments that were directed towards others on our page using language we will not tolerate. Facebook has been notified and this can result in Facebook suspending their accounts indefinitely.

We thank you all for your cooperation and look forward to seeing everyone in the shop soon!


See More
Image may contain: 1 person, smiling, meme and text
No automatic alt text available.

Sugar Free Cherry Snowballs have arrived, Watermelon has left the building!

No automatic alt text available.

Special Hours Saturday August 5th: Open 1-5 and will return on Sunday for our normal 1-9.

Who doesn't dream about ice cream?! 😋🍦

No automatic alt text available.
July 18

Dreaming about the best summer food 🍦

"There's no right way to eat ice cream" - we agree, Snoopy & Woodstock! 😁🍦

No automatic alt text available.
July 17

There's no right way to eat ice cream 🍦

It's July 19th- Happy National Ice Cream Day!!

Image may contain: text

We made number three! Thank you everyone for another great year and here is to many more!

The tastiest way to cool down during summer.

Tuesday, July 4th we will be closed to observe Independence Day with our families. Everyone be safe and we will see you at our regular hours on Wednesday.

Image may contain: fireworks, night and outdoor

Special Hours: Saturday, July 1st we will be open at 12pm and close at 7pm so we can watch the Antietam Battlefield Fireworks Show with our families. We will resume normal hours on Sunday.

From our family to yours- Have a safe weekend everyone!

Image may contain: fireworks, night, sky and outdoor

Sugar Free Watermelon Snoballs are BACK!

Image may contain: food

Do unforeseen circumstances we will be opening late today. Our hours for today Saturday, June 24th will be 5 PM to 9 PM, tomorrow we will resume our normal hours. Sorry for any inconvenience.

From our family and yours- Happy Father's Day to all the Fathers! Also to those who step in and become the Dad, Mom's who pull double duty, and any others who fill that role.