66 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Kelly Shaw-Mikel
· January 17, 2018
The new restaurant at Market Street shopping center is fabulous. We have had breakfast and lunch, both times the food was delicious, and the service impeccable! So happy to have this lovely addition our little town! Kudos, and wishing you much success! See More
Karen Hawkins
· May 25, 2017
I feel sorry for your waitress. Why is she the only one here? It's not her fault but we're waiting on silverware to stir cram and sugar in the coffee, going on about 1/2 hour now, she's the only one c...ashing out, cleaning up and waiting one about 8 tables! Ridiculous See More
Scott Rouch
· October 6, 2017
Christina was great!!! So sometimes we have to wait, but breakfast and serving sizes are very fair
Jeremy Littlejohn
· February 28, 2015
I LOVE this place! It is the only place in town (not called McDonald's) that I eat breakfast. Occasionally, the number of customers overwhelms the minimal staff, and there is a bit of a wait...but only on Sunday when the church crowd lets out. The servers are always courteous, and because I eat there a lot, they usually remember my order! See More
Cristian Chairez
· April 29, 2017
Service is terrible, waited forever for our food (1hr+) 30 minutes to be asked what drinks we wanted. Food unimpressive, worth a drive to another restaurant.
Rating based on multiple occcasions it was...n't just once. I tried giving it a chance. See More
Darla McCuen
· August 3, 2016
We had a very large party tonight and our server was outstanding! I know what I ordered was well more than enough for another meal. Thank you for accommodating our little family reunion.
Brandon Hunt
· February 27, 2016
Waited an HOUR for a plate of biscuits & gravy. Then I tried to pay and they don't except debit? Cash only? I had to ask my friend to pay for my breakfast, was embarrassing..... It's 2016 WTF!!! Get s...ome internet and debit.. Will NOT be eating here again... See More
David Bentley
· April 13, 2015
I'm from South Bend IN. Worth the drive!! Best food ever!! You get sooo much for so little cost! I got a ribeye sandwich, fries, and pop for $8!! My girlfriend and I looked at the breakfast menu...I s...een steak & eggs for $10??? Whhhaaat??? That's awesome!!! We WILL be back!!!!! See More
Angella O'Dell Ashkins
· August 21, 2016
Waited 1yr and 20 minutes for food. And food was only warm when we received it. Will not be back.
Alan Liechty
· October 23, 2015
The Quality of the food makes up for the lack of good service that I often get here.
John D Pappas
· August 19, 2015
Special treat to find a Greek restaurant nestled in Amish Country. We both enjoyed the Athens Greek Chicken! Super Value!
Pat Wyant
· June 16, 2015
The portions are huge and the prices are VERY low. Great food!
Jennifer Hren
July 13, 2013
Just tried your restaurant today for the first time. Excellent gyros and excellent service from Francis! Thank you!
Christina Kritikos
· November 21, 2013
It's amazing.I love eating here, the food portions are Hugh. Never had bad service.
Jeremy Hochstetler
· May 29, 2014
Love the fact, that u get what u pay for and the food is perfect
Ashley Brown Hochstetler
· May 29, 2014
Best place in town hands down!
Sandy Worthen
· May 23, 2014
Very good. Best spanikopita ever and we travel a lot.
Sia Tammy Kritikos B
· February 4, 2012
Try some awesome Gyros, if you are ever in the area!!
James Hochstetler
· May 29, 2014
Never will u leave hungry....I PROMISE....

Greek Islands will be closed until Friday morning at 5am we apologize for the inconvenience to everyone .

Go on our Facebook page for Greek Island and see our weekend specials .. Look Forward to see everyone there ..


Hi Everyone we apologize for closing Athens but we are opening at a new place its at 1403 east market st called Greek Islands . New num 574 221-2279 please come in and see all the new changes .. Hope to see everyone there Saturday @ 5 am ..

Athens Gyros Menu 161 S Main St Nappanee, Indiana 46550 574-773-3391
Athens Gyros and Diner updated their status.

We will be opening tomorrow at normal hours 5am. Sry for the inconvenience we do sincerely apologize. Tomorrow free coffee 5am until 9am.. Hope to see everyone.

We got a new special going on Every Last Thursday of the month buy one Gyro get the second one free.. 2per person limit. Don't miss your free Gyros. Hope to see you at Athens..

Also Santa will be coming to Athens the 17 th of December bring the little ones to come and tell Santa there last things on there Christmas list... 9am until 11am..

We have buy one gyro get one gyro free every last Thursday of the month.. Limit 2 per person...

This year we will be doing our free Thanksgiving Dinner tomorrow from 11am- 2pm.. We will also be open for breakfast.. Hope to see you here. We also would like to give a special thanks to Rite Choice for donating the Turkeys.. Thank you ..

Help Wanted looking for Dishwasher and Waitress ..

We have a Early Bird Special going on from 5am until 9am that you won't get No where else; 2 eggs, potato, 2 slices of bacon or links, toast & coffee all for the price of $5.00. Come in early to get a great deal. Then 12/19 Santa will be at Athens so bring all the children in to tell Santa there last minute Christmas lists. Hope to see all you there. Have a Merry Christmas and a have a Safe New Year.

We want to Thanks our Customers for another successful year. So on October 8th, 11am-7pm we will be doing buy 1 Gyro get the 2nd Gyro Free. Limited one per customer. So again thanks for another year...

12eggs at one time...

Image may contain: 1 person

Santa is coming to Athens this Saturday between the hours of 9am to 11am please bring your children in so they can get an there early Christmas present from Santa ...

Athens Gyros and Diner updated their profile picture.
No automatic alt text available.