148 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Wally Kulick
· April 2, 2018
This was the second Easter we attended at Fire and Ice. Last year we opted to try another. That we will not discuss. Fire and Ice has a beautiful Easter dinner. We had our sons fiancé family join us ...they drive about hour or more. It was such a great experience. From great service to great food. Now there was such a variety that if you did not find something that would be a problem. I loved everything. The chef and owner making his presence known throughout was a pleasure. Our Taya was loving it all he gave her a chefs hat. For which now she will wear as we prepare dinner. We are going to make a point of visiting on a more regular bases for just getting out for a nice dinner and date nights. Love love this place. If I could give an extra five * I would. Thanks for a great Easter for our family Mr Kevin & Wally Armitage and family. See More
Roy Calvey
· February 21, 2018
Tonight my wife and I finally got to have a Valentine's Dinner. Our waiter was very professional , kind , very aware of what the specials were , the veg, etc.. His service was very good . My wife the clay baked chicken parm , I had the monk fish , mussels, lobster special . We also both had house salads and shared a colossal shrimp cocktail, and of corse we had the fresh bread , love that hummus, wife choose the thyme honey butter, both salads were crisp and fresh, shrimp cocktail was good , entrees were piping hot and very good. Thank you for the good dinner we look forward to comming back.. Jobs well done . See More
Jaime Beierle Lisman
· January 21, 2018
Absolutely the worst meal I’ve ever had. Actually there were 13 ppl in our party & no one enjoyed our barely warm food. My children were served raw meatballs. I politely sent them back, asking the wai...tress for another order of well done meatballs. (The waitress was wonderful btw) The chef had her come back out to tell me that they were sautéed & then cooked in sauce for 45 minutes. Ok, they were still completely raw in the center. Even though I did graduate from culinary school in New York, you don’t have to be trained to see, & feel, that these meatballs were clearly undercooked. They then told me it would take a very long time to cook them well done and suggested chicken tenders. About 20 minutes later, the waitress came back with 4 meatballs in a cold casserole dish but they were firmer in texture & luke warm. My children ate half of them. Another hour later the waitress came back and said the chef said they were out of chicken fingers??? What?? I also had asked them to sub the spaghetti for French fries, not only did they charge us $17.99 for the raw & then barely warm meatballs, but they charged us for the fries too. 3 people at our table had the Gorgonzola risotto with shrimp. The only edible food on the plate was the shrimp & they were over cooked. The gorgonzola was too much, the rice was hard, whatever that dark red stuff was??? Was waaaaaay too overbearing & unpleasant looking. The plates were extremely hot & the food luke warm. The calamari appetizer was a joke. A total mess. Globs of WARM aioli on every corner, no dipping sauce. The $6 Caesar salad was anything but. Terrible dressing. The US just had a terrible life threatening outbreak of ecoli & you can see that the lettuce was not washed. The hearts of romaine were still in tact & dry as a bone. No one enjoyed their meal. I had mentioned two weeks before that we’re bringing a cake to celebrate. The waitress brought out the filthiest knife I have ever seen to cut it. I’m 99% sure it was dried, caked on fish. I could go on. Never again. See More
Corey Bartell
· November 9, 2017
I and the other person in my party visited this place for the first time tonight and it wasn't what we expected. After our pizza appetizer which was good, we ordered entrees and the waitress whose nam...e was chars I believe asked each of us "soup or salad". I got a salad, the other soup.

My entree was lukewarm. Didn't see any steam coming off of it. The chef came out and said "apparently" we made a mistake, which gave me the intention that I was stupid and didn't know what I was talking about. After offering free desserts to us, we got our bill. There was a three dollar up charge for soup. Our waitress didn't even inform us that there would be this substitution charge when we she asked us soup or salad. She just said something to the sort of "yeah there is an extra for soup, sorry."

We had to get our food to go. The other person I was with didn't finish her French onion soup and she had a ton left. They brought out a really small container of it ...and what she had left definitely could have filled more than that. When we got out to our car, we noticed the one bad had food on the bottom of it because the one container wasn't secured tightly.

It's pretty ridiculous when you get told about an up charge after the fact it happened. We were told they pride themselves on their food but really do need to work on their service. Tell your customers about these up charges if they do in fact exist. We saw no where that it stated this. My food lacked the fire and we definitely got iced with
And unforeseen substitution charge weren't told about during the order.
See More
Julie McDonald Wilson
· January 20, 2018
Went for dinner tonight with my husband, the food wasn't great. I ordered French onion soup which was salty. I also ordered tuna with spinach and jasmine rice. The rice tasted like paste and the was not seasoned, the tuna was decent. See More
Michele Brunges Yagloski
· February 9, 2018
Had a great dinner with my husband. The only down fall was the waitress was overworked and couldn’t get us drinks - hire more waitresses. It is good for business. Overall a good time, great music an...d atmosphere See More
Stephen Motil
· February 15, 2018
First timer. Nice place with some of the best food we have ever had locally. Service was top notch as well. Very reasonable priced!
Elizabeth Berilla Kavanaugh
· April 3, 2018
This is a go to for my family since we moved to the area five years ago. Always delicious, and Gary knew all the right touches to make our baby shower perfect!
Kevin Armitage
· April 1, 2018
Love the Easter buffet, fantastic food and great service. Everything was top notch and everyone in our party of 8 enjoyed it
Jon Frisvold
· April 1, 2018
Like normal...absolutely amazing!!! Not a single complaint. Amazing food. Great staff. My favorite place, and I love that the special changes every day!
Michele Christine Rosemellia
· October 10, 2017
Fire and Ice catered our wedding this weekend at the barn at glistening pond. I can honestly say I have never been so impressed in my life. Gary grilled the steak right on site. Every person that I sp...oke with that attended our wedding was asking who catered our event. Everyone said it was the best food they have ever had at a wedding. They described it as phenomenal. Some guest even said it was the best meal they've ever had in their entire life. It was worth every single penny. Hearing the guests complement the food the entire night, receiving text messages,calls just to say how absolutely amazing the food was felt great. The bartenders were spot on also. Once again great job to Gary and his team! See More
Catrina Oz
· February 16, 2018
Definitely on my list of top favorites ! Excellent food along with great service ! ! A must try ! !
Gay Domkowski
· February 18, 2018
Just love the soup and salad bar for lunch. The sandwiches are great. And the soup has no msg in it so I can eat there and never get a migraine.
Angie Murphi
· October 4, 2017
One of my favorite places! The staff is always very nice and go out of their way. My favorite things are the starburst martini, orange cognac salad, and the calamari appetizer is just perfect. Honestl...y, I have calamari everywhere and they just do something special with it. See More
Jessica Trescavage
· July 21, 2017
This is one of our favorite spots! Tonight, I had the Cajun grouper special with blueberry compote and lemon risotto, a pear lavender martini, and my hubby and I ordered the crab béchamel pizza specia...l. WOW! One of my favorite meals ever! (We always get amazing food and wonderful service there!) See More
Gerri Morreale-Vickers
· April 9, 2018
Wonderful restaurant. Great selection of food and drink. A must try.
Rachel Hawk
· July 13, 2017
Our first time at Fire and Ice and the food was amazing! Our server John, was also amazing! Thank you for the wonderful experience! Compliments to the chef on the best crab cakes I've ever had!! �
Darlene Beagle
· July 30, 2017
Nice place. Food was great and the server's were fantastic! I was impressed. Hats off to the server's who knew the menu well, presented the days specials,describing them with confidence and pride! Wel...l done my friends! See More
Cristy Mishkula
· March 16, 2018
Great food and great service from our waitress Madison.
Mike Hage
· October 20, 2017
I asked for the bruschetta, and nothing on the plate was crunchy or bright. Way to soggy, and service wasn’t good.
Selene Marie Karolchik
· February 14, 2018
So good...everything was great! Especially the calamari appetizer!
Lee M. Evans
· January 1, 2017
New Years Eve is always hard to plan for to go out. Most, if not all restaurants have special menus that are limited and expensive. This was the case At Fire and Ice except the menu had more than choices for a four course meal. Price? Yes, pricey but the service, food, atmosphere, and the combination of 4 courses made it worth it. Nice job chef and staff. See More
Louise Alabre Trumm
· January 13, 2017
Disappointing service and food. The beer battered haddock is all batter. Although the batter was good, I doubt there was 3 oz of fish between the three pieces. Waited over 5 minutes before the wait...ress even acknowledged us. Wine poured by grasping the neck of the bottle and table not cleared. She clearly had no idea what she was doing although she was pleasant. Menu not very appealing. Definitely not worth it. See More
Matt Beck
· September 20, 2016
As a fellow restaurant owner this is truly one of my favorite spots and have never had a bad meal. No matter what you order you will be pleased from start to finish. Really one of the best restaurants... in all of NEPA. Keep up th great work! See More
Sherri Ann Fenton
· February 15, 2017
What an outstanding Valentine Dinner!!! Everything was fantastic. Our waitress was super great and it was obvious she was working hard because it was very busy. Loved her personality as well as the... great service she gave us. The food was so delicious. Can't wait to go there again. See More
Rachel Harding
· November 18, 2016
My husband has brought me here every year on my birthday (and we've been here other times) and the service is great and the food is AMAZING!! I'm constantly craving going there. Also, you can tell it'...s very well managed. Gary is also a wonderful guy who goes above & beyond, and we cannot wait to have Thanksgiving food from Fire and Ice this year! � See More
Shannon Benesky
· August 5, 2017
Service was great went for lunch and the food was the best! Will definitely go back many more times!!
Chris Kappler
· September 10, 2016
Ordered flet menon med rare came out well. Ordered a lobster with it came out over cooked and tough. Sent back flet came back cooked ok but was so tough and stringy. Felt should not be so tough.. Wait...ress didn't seem to know what was up and didn't even bring the bread to our table. Not a good experience overall. Won't be back, 2nd strike.. See More
Wendy Specht
· January 6, 2018
great food...great atmosphere. Chef Gary is amazing
Len Yashinski
· September 26, 2017
We had a wonderful dinner to celebrate my wife's birthday, everything was impeccable from the service to the menu to the final product! Great job!
Amber Williams
· December 17, 2016
What a wonderful time we had last night! Company Christmas party and the food was fantastic. The only problem was that the turkey & corn chowder and that delicious bread was so good, I was stuffed bef...ore the main course! See More
Maria Pizzo
· May 11, 2017
Delicious pizza and inventive salads. Their bread is out of this world! Nothing like having pizza from an old school brick oven ♥
Matt Navin
· January 11, 2017
Fire and Ice NEVER disappoints. The service was affable and polite, the food is unparalleled, and all for a price that's fair for the excellent ambiance, staff, and menu.
Patricia Zellers White
· February 14, 2017
Wonderful place to eat! The food and staff are amazing! Always try to eat here when in the area.
Suzanne Pudlosky Keller
· September 14, 2016
Stopped just for nitecap of the few places to offer a reasonably priced split of prosecco for two, love to have that option! �
Dylan Scherer
· July 15, 2017
Hands down the best burger in the area, accompanied with delicious fresh cut fries, for 12 bucks? You can not go wrong.
Marissa Udzella
· February 15, 2017
My husband and I really enjoyed our meal. The hummus was delicious as something different to put on the fresh bread. The waitress was very friendly and attentive.
Susan Stackalis Wylam
· May 8, 2017
My family went for dinner yesterday. The food was excellent! Everyone enjoyed their meal. Chef Gary couldn't have been more pleasant! I want to give a 10+ shout out to our waiter. I think John?... Absolutely the best EVER! Friendly.... Informative...... Attentive. Would definitely recommend!!! See More
Sarah Klass
· August 24, 2017
Excellent service AND food! Nice ambiance, too! I will SO tell my friends!
Laraine Nadolski Estes
· May 29, 2016
That a find!! Great restaurant. Great food! Can't wait to come back to the area and eat here again!! I forget the young lady bartenders name but she was very nice!
Happy Easter. Salads from our holiday dinner.
Happy Easter; our dessert offerings today.
Fire and Ice on Toby Creek will be making local Berkshire cassoulet With Asian goat cheese and arugula won ton organic Christmas beans Pork belly cracklings and pickled fennel.

Fire and Ice will be closed for lunch service Saturday April 14
To accommodate a funeral luncheon for a community member.
We apologize in advance to disappoint.
Thank you for understanding.

All great chefs started their careers learning the basic mise en place of the restaurants.
Plateware sanitation engineer position applications are being accepted. If your interested in a rewarding career in the culinary arts stop by.