73 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Robin Richards Johnson
· July 23, 2017
Their ice cream is always good! I had the smallest twist, kid's cone and it was a lot. Hubby got the small and we wondered how they would even pile one higher, and how anyone could eat one fast enoug...h to keep it from dripping! Have heard the food is good there too. See More
Suzy Friot
· June 6, 2015
As a child, every time we would go to Watertown to go shopping, or were simply passing through Gouverneur, my dad would always stop here and get ice cream. Now, following tradition, whenever we pass t...hrough Gouverneur we have to stop and get ice cream! It reminds me of where I came from. See More
Casey Hassett
· July 1, 2017
Fantastic as always, first time for the crew and they loved it. One thing though...what happened to Rochester root beer?
Chrishel Smith
· March 26, 2016
I have been going here since I was a kid it always has and always will be my favorite. My whole family goes and I'm passing the tradition down to my son. :)
BethAnn Gillette
· April 9, 2017
Black Cherry for breakfast and a dish of vanilla for Ruby, topped with dog � biscuits!
Craig Bunch
· May 29, 2017
The best plance to have icecream and eat in Gouberneur ! Highly recomend a visit !
Mitchell Carr
· August 1, 2017
Always Awesome look forward to it every year and I think they could be just as wonderful year round
Valerie Harris-Stephenson
· March 29, 2014
Love to eat at the Custard Cottage! The food is great and the ice cream is the best!!
Harvey Jenne
July 11, 2013
Nobody else has ice cream as good as you folks, also years ago I loved your root beer in frosted mugs with a couple of hot dogs.The best in the world.
Karen Napolitani
· July 6, 2014
Just called them and they are open until 9:00 p.m. Thank goodness they are not actually permanently closed!
Doni LaRock
· September 25, 2015
The BEST soft custard around. Love going here whenever I'm home!

Closed for the season. See you next year

Time ( and ice cream) is running out. Closing for the season on Sunday 9/11/16
Hurry in before it's gone!!!
Soft black raspberry Fri-Sun


🌞🌞gorgeous weather for ice cream🍦🍦!!! When you stop in , be sure to wish Phyllis happy birthday !!!🎈🎉🎁

We are open daily until 9pm. Flavor of the day is cherry🍒.
Tomorrow starts new flavor for a sunny weekend . Stop in & see what it is

It's snowing so it must be opening day!!! Custard cottage is open until 9 tonight . Welcome Phyllis out of retirement🍦🌭🍔🍤🍨

🍦🍦Buy one cone, get the same size or smaller FREE today , CLOSING day!!🍦🍦

Closing day!! Don't wait til tonight, get in and get your last ice cream of the season early!!

Closing for the season on Sept 13th. Don't wait. Come and get your ice cream fix today !🍦🍨🍧

Come and treat Dad for Fathers Day!!! Open until 9p for ice cream.

🐾We have doggy dishes (vanilla ice cream in a dish with a dog bone, $1.50)