88 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Nikki Bass
· January 13, 2018
They have made cakes for my family for years. Always a great experience with the most detailed work I’ve ever seen on a cookie cake! Thanks for all your quality work!
Thomas Williams
· October 23, 2017
Our go to place for cookie cake! We love picking up out cakes to see such artistic designs! Give them an idea and they won't fail. Over and over and over again!
Ashley Connell
· September 19, 2017
Went in yesterday to pick up my 10 year olds birthday cake, I had my 3 year old with me and they were so sweet to her and gave her a free chap stick! Made our day!
Brenda Hurndon Keck
· January 28, 2018
Our cookie looked amazing and tasted perfect!!! They always do the best custom work.
Deborah Bailey Griffiths
· February 1, 2018
Y’all did an amazing job!!! I could not have asked for anything more perfect!!! Thank you Kris & staff!!!
Karen Caldwell Dickson
· August 16, 2017
The Minecraft cake they made last year was awesome. We had my son and his cousin and she did two faces. One girl one boy. Super hero one was awesome too. Never disappointed. They are so creative. up a total totality one this weekend. :) See More
Brittany Goddard
· February 4, 2018
My husband loved his cake we ordered from here, fast easy service! Will be using them again!
Mandy Engle
· August 5, 2017
Usually this place is AMAZING!!!! Although I get here today to pick up a cookie cake that I ordered and paid for a week ago to find that it was never made!!!!! Very disappointing, especially when it m...ade me late for the party that it was needed for � See More
Jeremy-Jennifer McCain
· April 2, 2017
Seriously the absolute best place to order a cake! The creativity and customer service are like no other. Every single cake we have ordered from this store have been decorated far past our expectation...s and delicious! You can't go wrong with ordering or visiting this store! See More
Emily Nicole
· December 23, 2015
First of all, I love Great American Cookies! I've been eating them since I was a little kid - they were always my favorite part about going shopping. This location in particular is fantastic, and I've... been a regular customer for a couple of years. Each time I need a special order they listen carefully, are friendly, and deliver delicious perfection on time - everytime. Every flavor I've tried has been amazing, but I highly recommend their sugar cookies if you've never had one! Also, if you love a good Icee, that's the place! Pretzels were good too! Always clean and friendly. A little crowded, but that's the sign if a popular place! See More
Candi Waldrop Cygan
· April 14, 2017
I have always been happy with their products and services...until today! Ordered the cookie cake, left my contact information, came back to pick up cake and it is different than what I ordered. Two ho...urs before the event as I am picking up the cake and notice the wording is incorrect, the staff decides to tell me they were unable to write what I wanted. Do you think you could have told me at the time of order? If not, how about calling to say hey, we can't do this, will this other format be acceptable. At which point, I would have said no and taken my business elsewhere. The taboo wording that I wanted....WTF , written under it was to say Who is Turning Forty (hence the acronym). Thanks for ruining the day Great American Cookie Co! It will be my last visit at this store. See More
Melissa Remmark Morris
· January 25, 2017
Thank you for investing in our community and children. We enjoyed decorating cookies with Olaf. As always I love the cookies. They are my favorite.
Crystal Winkles Folds
· February 19, 2017
I love this store! Pretzels and cookies are always delicious! Prices are reasonable. Customer service is outstanding! I am never disappointed.
Courtney Lauren
· October 1, 2016
We always get a cookie cake for my daughter's birthday and this year was no exception. Michael made a Finding Dory cake that was perfect! My daughter loved it.
Heather Goodwin Bell
· September 18, 2016
Great American Cookie made my daughter's 5th Birthday "Hawaiian themed" cookie cake and they did an awesome job!! Couldn't have ask for a better job or service!!
Taylor Patton Summers
· June 4, 2017
The best! Always hit the nail on the head with designs!
Gallixy Turner Keahey
· January 15, 2016
They made the most amazing looking cookie cake for my son's 10th birthday. Thank you!!
Sheila Andrell Ivie
· August 22, 2016
My son works at great American cookies they have amazing cookies!
Michelle Lane Adams
· February 9, 2015
Love these guys! Always willing to help and so very nice!! Their art is fabulous on the cakes!!
Callie Mayfield
· January 25, 2017
Loved the pretzels and the staff were very friendly.
Come by and grab a sample and a picture with Stuart the minion!!!
We have some fresh Strawberry Crinkle ready for you today! Stop by and grab yours 770-954-1058 💕🍪
Olaf is ready to decorate a cookie with you!!!

You know you need a double doozie to get you through this Monday! We can make you a double doozie with any cookie that you like! Go ahead and get our buy 5 get 1 free and then everyone can get one!! Stop by today 770-954-1058 🍪

Image may contain: food

Love m&m’s? Love cookies? Well then you better stop by and grab a fresh m&m cookie today! We’re open till 7! 770-954-1058 🍪

Image may contain: food

Give us a call today to place your March Madness, St. Patrick’s Day and Easter cake orders ! 🏀☘️🐣 Locust Grove - 770-954-1058 McDonough - 678-272-6439

*** Meet our staff ***
Everyone meet Maddie! She is an upfront floater/ cake decorator here at our Locust Grove location! She has been here for about a year now. Her favorite product is our snickerdoodle cookie (y’all know it’s good). She is always eager to help any customer that comes in with a bright smile on her face! Her favorite part about working here is that this store is like one big family. Everyone here gets along. She feels like she’s at home when she’s here! We are so glad to have Maddie! Stop by and see her and the rest of our amazing staff!!

Image may contain: 1 person, smiling, food

It’s A Boy! We love decorating all these precious baby shower cakes! Give us a call and order yours today 770-954-1058 🍪💙

Image may contain: 1 person, food

Easter is less than a month away! Give us a call and order yours today 770-954-1058 🐰🐣🍪💛

No automatic alt text available.

Are you looking for a cute paint splatter cookie cake? Here you go! We love being able to make colorful designs! Give us a call and order yours today 770-954-1058 🍪❤️

Image may contain: food and text

Need a cute construction themed cookie cake for a sweet little boy? We’ve got you covered! Call us today and order yours 770-954-1058 🍪💛

Image may contain: food

Unicorns have been super popular lately! We love being able to come up with new designs! Give us a call today to order this super cute cookie cake 770-954-1058 🦄🍪💕

Image may contain: food

Did you know that each cookie cake is hand rolled each day?! We take pride in making sure that each cookie cake is perfect for you! Give us a call and order yours today 770-954-1058 🍪❤️

It looks like you may be having problems playing this video. If so, please try restarting your browser.

No MSG, artificial flavors or binders.... just the good stuff. Made with 100% fresh, domestic, Black Angus Beef. Try our mini pretzel dogs today!770-954-1058 😋

Image may contain: food

We are so excited to have Kate Spade as our new neighbors here at Tanger! After you stop and get a cookie, go by and check them out! 👛🍪💞

Image may contain: indoor
Image may contain: indoor
Image may contain: indoor
Image may contain: one or more people, people standing and indoor

St. Patrick’s Day is less than a month away! Call and order your cookie cake today! 770-954-1058 🌈🍀🍪💚

Image may contain: food