42 Reviews
People talk aboutgarlic bread
Tell people what you think
Robert Klemm
· January 4, 2018
I've been cooking for 22 years ... And this place is wayyy under rated and totally flew under my radar! The deep dish pizza was killer and the staff super friendly and fun. Thank you! We will be back soon!
James Nielsen
· September 24, 2017
Service was outstanding. Food was excellent! We'll definitely be back and recommend to other people!
Gerri Mehlberg
· June 28, 2017
Their lasagna and garlic bread is the best. I believe theirs are better then mama Mia's and even better then Ann's in Milwaukee . Fabulous !
Brett Faux-Stir
· November 23, 2016
It had been a while since we ordered from Mario's, but decided to get a family supreme delivered this evening. AWESOME pizza, and it came with a free cheese for the kiddo! Will be ordering more freque...ntly, as I think you guys have surpassed the other local pizzerias in quality. Keep up the quality and good work! Cheers See More
Sheri Williams
· September 12, 2017
Love their lasagna and huge garlic bread! Staff is always super nice.
Deana Hibbard-Frost
· October 19, 2015
Clair, a young waitress here, is such a nice person and makes you feel welcome. A small restaurant with a huge talent of making amazingly good, tasteful food. Pizzas are phenomenal, but I just recentl...y had their lasagna; oh my gosh, yummy!! Enough for 2!
You'll want to make the trip!
See More
Barbara Trumble Cowsert
· July 29, 2015
I absolutely love this pizza! I moved to Whitewater and miss it so much! Char the owner brings an extra special warm fuzzy kind of feeling when we see her♡
Karen Scharnick
· October 11, 2014
Kudos to the management of Marios. Our order was not ready when we came to pick it up and we were offered a free appetizer for our trouble. How very generous! That gesture just ensured that we will b...e return customers and pass it along to our friends and family See More
Terry Brookshire Owens
· December 10, 2016
We love the fish fry! But, everything we have had there has been excellent! Plus, the price is right, too!
John Zimmerman
· October 18, 2015
Small town feel, quiet, clean, and friendly service. Food is made fresh with true Italian flavor. Best garlic bread anywhere. Large portions at a fair price.
Tony Piontek
· February 7, 2016
They really came through during Super Bowl 50. Highly recommend. Great service and great food!
Mario Julie Scarpace
April 11, 2013
What a great time we had at Marios pizza for my daughters
sweet sixteen pizza party with family , great food!!! The service was wonderful, Thank You Marios!!!
Angela Marie
· October 24, 2015
Very friendly staff! Food was amazing and great portions. I will be coming back very soon!
Marc Cesarec
· May 18, 2014
You guys should have let me do your website. They really destroyed the logo that I made for you.
Jody Comer
· October 1, 2015
Awesome staff and the food is delicious! . Located perfectly off hwy.43 for those that travel from out of town.
Rita Harvey Klauser
· November 7, 2015

We hope to see everyone tonight for some good food made by good people!

Mario's Pizza Mukwonago added a new photo.
No automatic alt text available.

Delicious hand breaded cod served with home made tartar sauce, cole-slaw, seasoned potato wedges, and applesauce served every Friday night!!

No automatic alt text available.