Photos
Reviews
4.4
226 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Trish Costello
· August 4, 2017
Nellies is my favorite place in Waldwick. Love the burgers, pizza, Elkins wings, chicken fingers and my favorite meal at Nellies is the Chicken Duffy. The Chicken Duffy is a real treat for your taste ...buds especially if you like a little zingy jalapeño spice. Oh and for dessert the peanut butter pie is to die for. See More
Sandra Johnson Frambach
· January 26, 2018
Nellies one pizza oven down. Can not control that. Shit happens. My pizza was delicious as always. So the person who was griping while waiting for their pizza RELAX. Try a little patience and unders...tanding. Nellies always does a fabulous job. Thank you Nellies!!!!!!! See More
Ed Sigler
· July 22, 2017
I have been living less than 2 miles from this place for 28 years. I finally come in to try their thin crust pizza and was amazed. We shared a meat lovers pizza with Bacon, sausage, pepperoni and meat...balls that was so good I ordered one to go! See More
Victoria Lisch Reczkowski
· July 24, 2017
We have been coming to Nellies for over 10 years, the pizza is fantastic (thin crust), the servers are friendly and accurate, prices are reasonable. On our most recent visit we discovered their "Gree...k Salad Pizza Pie".... it was amazing!!! They offer a lot more than pizza, the scampi is delicious too. See More
Denise Nicole
· January 21, 2018
The place was packed! We found two seats at the bar and enjoyed our dinner with some regulars! Everything was great!
Ramon Huertas
· November 3, 2017
First time in this place,food is amazing and the chicken wings are the best,plus the staff was excellent!!!
Megan Hogan Milchman
· May 14, 2017
States they have a gluten free menu. When I called they cook the gluten free items in the same pan and oil as the regular food. They need to become educated before adding allergy free items to the me...nu. That is not safe for people who have allergies. And all I was told was that they haven't had an issue yet. They shouldn't advertise gluten free if the food is not gluten free. Very dangerous. Beware if you have celiac or a gluten allergy. We will not be going back! Plus they lost our reservation after I confirmed it early that day. See More
Jean Paci Simonelli
· May 9, 2017
My daughter Terri always commented how great the food and service was at Nellies Place and how she wants to take me there and so she did. I have to say that she was so right. The appetizers were so de...licious and then came the pizza with our choice of onions and mushrooms and the sauce made it the best. Hanging out with my daughter makes for some great times and good food. See More
Pamela Bergstrom
· October 31, 2017
Love the staff and wings. Pass on the " steamers" . Tiny little clams, not steamers.
Simon Wheatley
· November 20, 2017
Great thin crust pizza, buffalo wings & beer as always!!
Serafim Reppas
· November 5, 2017
I had the Roma Panini and it was delicious! The fries were good. too. The service was outstanding!
June Tesoriero
· January 27, 2018
Love Nellies! It’s always packed which is a good thing!
Servers are so pleasant! Love it! 🍺🍺
Joseph Wahler
· August 3, 2017
Atmosphere 10+
Service 10+
Pizza 10+++++...
Bar 10++++
Over all exceeded all my expectations �
Bring friends and family you can't go wrong. I deliberately ordered one more pie to go after my meal �so so good
See More
Kim A. LaBelle
· October 3, 2016
We walked in the door and a gal just stood there looking at us. No smile. No "Hello". No "how many in your party?" She took us to a table and we said we would both like to watch the game and did she ...have a table that we could both face the tv. She said no and just walked away. We took ourselves to the bar where the bartender (Kevin) came and put a couple napkins in front of us. We ordered drinks that we had to ask for them to be refilled 2 or 3 times. We asked if a specific game was going to be played there at 1:00, he said he didn't know.
Kevin did have good menu knowledge and the food was good. But the salesmanship was no where to be found and the friendliness was (between 1-10) about a 4. He answered every question, and it was clear we were there to socialize, but we ended leaving because when we spend $75 on lunch, we would like to be waited on
See More
Carol Tyler
· June 4, 2017
Nellies place my favorite kitchen away from home. Never fails to please me, variety of menu, courteous service, and great prices
Debbie Grinwis
· June 4, 2017
So happy my fiancé brought me here. It's a place he's been going to for years and has a lot of fond memories of being there with his dad. We always sit at the bar and receive quick friendly service an...d great food! The pizza is awesome!! See More
Sal Schifano
· March 12, 2017
We've been going to Nellie's for years and a lot of my friends longer than that. We all agree...this is a GREAT place! The place is always mobbed and food is excellent and, yes, especially the thin-cr...ust pizza! See More
Christopher Salge
· March 31, 2017
After waiting for 30 min with myself and my son they would not let him sit at the bar table because of the "new rule" saying Evan was too short. News flash, he's only about 15 inches shorter than me!!...! We left and it's gonna be a while before I go back, if ever. Poor management of the tables, with 2 separate lists in the front and the back. I could understand if there were other empty options but it was very busy. Party of 4 walked in and got a table right away, we could have been done and gone. Terrible. See More
Andrea Frangipani Darienzo
· December 18, 2016
We went to Nellies this afternoon with our daughter for a late lunch on a dreary Sunday afternoon. I could not believe how rudely we were treated by the management. Shame on you for treating good cu...stomers that way in front of our daughter. We will never step foot in your restaurant again! Your loss Nellie, not ours! See More
Daniel Brizek
· November 3, 2015
My wife's food wasn't cooked all the way through and they took my meal away before I was done with it. Also, the service was very slow for a lunch visit. I mentioned to the waitress that we were in a ...hurry and she still took a long time getting us our check and our change (she actually took two table's orders before she finally came back with it). Maybe dinner is better. See More
Christina Beckerman
· November 6, 2015
Some of the best pizza on the planet! I've been eating Nellie's since I was a kid, and have to have it anytime I visit the area! Came in for lunch today with my mom and sat at the bar. My grandfath...er lived in the area for a very long time and used to be a regular, the owner and staff still remember him! See More
Russell Damis
· August 21, 2017
Best pizza ever. Place is always jammed. Haven't been let down yet!
Spencer Hanly
· December 28, 2014
One of my favorite places in the world to eat. My grandparents to my parents now my self have all enjoyed this spot over many years. Some of the best wings (the Elkin Wings are a must try!) and pizza ...anywhere. The staff is great and make it feel like family there. And even tho the remodel has taken some of the atmosphere away it still has the magic that has always been Nellies. See More
Karen Chappell
· May 4, 2016
Stopped by recently on a weekday for lunch. Had traditional cheese thin crust pizza and it was very good (came highly recommended from some friends). Also tried the salad bar, which is certainly a mea...l in itself. Many selections including various pasta, potato, and bean salads. Place is casual and family-friendly, service was attentive and efficient, and restrooms were clean (very important!). Will definitely come back and sample something different from the menu. Thanks for a relaxing and pleasant dining experience during a day off from work. See More
Stacey Brann Hotchkiss
· September 27, 2016
It's a neighborhood joint at its best. My family has been coming here for years and they always are welcoming with good service and excellent food! Wings are a must!
David Edwards
· November 27, 2015
Great place for drinks, pizza and dinner.
My wife and I had my father's 90 birthday party. Chris one of the owners help us arrange the party. Mike the waiter did a fantastic job making sure the food w...as plentiful. See More
Tim Ketchell
· September 28, 2015
Artichoke Spin dip is amazing. Best around since I order it everywhere they have it.

Bartenders are good people as well....

Trivia on Wednesday nights are fun. You can actually hear the questions!!! Plus I have heard the funniest team names there and we all know that is the best part of trivia.
See More
Matthew Patonni Bayat
· June 27, 2017
Amazing everything 😊 Food is so fresh and delicious. The pizza and onion rings are my favorite.
Jeannie Hensz
· March 18, 2017
Nellie's has always been a favorite of mine. Many a celebration we've had there with excellent food, service, and family atmosphere. Highly recommend!
Joe Talkiewicz
· February 16, 2017
My cold French fries and raw cheeseburger were very disappointing.
No thanks, never again..
I should have stayed with the wings or pizza.
Carol Seavey Seely
· July 29, 2016
Been here a couple of times with our NJ family. Food is dellicious, staff is efficient, it's always crowded which is a good sign!Hope to eat ere again when visiting the area.
Larry Israel
· May 11, 2016
The food is really great, but you go there for more. The atmosphere , people, waitresses, and waitstaff are as nice & friendly , like your supposed to be there.
Laurie Bizzoco-Cassidy
· September 9, 2016
Love the pizza! Love the fried ravioli! Love the spinach dip! ...Love everything! The staff are great!!!
Brian Vanderhoff
· October 28, 2015
Place is simply awesome. Great food at a great price. Friendly local neighborhood place to take yourself or the whole family. A+
Matthew Reid
· November 17, 2015
What can I saw awesome tasting very thin pies and the elkin wings with that chunky blue cheese were delicious the corn chowder soup was great too.
Jan Van Dyke Blumenfeld
· July 4, 2016
Tonight just ok. Jalapeño poppers - good. The thin crust pizza we usually love, not so much tonight. Crust was soft and greasy.
Kathy Hall
· July 7, 2017
Great place to hang with friends . Pizza is delicious!?
Eddie Hamilton
· October 13, 2016
Went with my daughter we had a great time great service food was great definitely would come back again
Mo Locke
· January 15, 2017
Service was extremely slow. It took 20 minutes before a waitress came and asked if I needed a drink. She never asked about a refill either. Food was good though.
Jimmie Rivera
· April 29, 2017
The customer is always right....wanted to watching boxing. Told me no but I said I'm a paying customer. Still get a no
Posts

We hope your taste buds are ready.

Image may contain: food

Calling all photographers -- share your favorite photo that you've taken at our place!

Image may contain: one or more people and camera
Posts
Get the latest New Jersey local, sports and national breaking news.
nj.com

We're interested to hear what you have to say!

Image may contain: stripes

Let the good times pour.

Image may contain: drink and indoor

Tell us what it was!

Image may contain: text

How you feel when you see your food coming.

Image may contain: one or more people, shoes, sky, child and outdoor

Just a little something we hope meets your a-brew-val.

Image may contain: drink and indoor

Can you put a number on it?

Image may contain: text

We're proud to be serving the local community!

Image may contain: text

Made with fresh ingredients, delicious flavors, and lots of love -- just for you.

Image may contain: pizza and food

What do you savor more: The first bite or the last bite?

Image may contain: food

Good food, great people, and plenty of seats. All that's missing is you!

Image may contain: people sitting and indoor

New year, same fun atmosphere!

Image may contain: people sitting, table and indoor

Drinking champagne isn't the only way to ring in the new year!

Image may contain: people sitting, drink and indoor