Photos
Reviews
3.9
84 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Chad Springs
· January 27, 2018
We went there 2 weeks ago and had a wonderful waitress and had a great time. We bragged so much to our friends we came back with a group of friends this past Friday and the restaurant did a 180°

We ...had the manager as our waitress this time we waited 20 minutes for our drinks. Once the drinks came we ordered our food and didn't have anyone acknowledge us for the following hour. Multiple people at my table sat with an empty glass for 30 plus minutes. The restaurant began to clear out where there was only people at the bar and we was the lone table. At 930pm I finally Expressed to my wife that I think we should leave and she goes up and tells the lady behind the bar that we are going. Which she replies did you guys even order food? We walked out and I had one foot in my car about ready to sit down and the manager Runs Out and demands we pay for our drinks. By this point I lost it with the blatant disrespect the manager quickly saw by my choice of words and body language that I was past the point of being frustrated. She returned with a infuriated tone and closed the door on me. She never communicated with us or let us even know the food was almost done until we was walking out then demanded we pay for the one drink we was given with no refills. They lost 4 separate families that would have brought in business. Had there been any communication or simple acknowledgements this would have been a completely different situation. See More
Cory Butcher
· January 17, 2018
We recently held my step daughter’s sweet 16 bday party upstairs and I can’t say enough nice things about this place! Kate was very professional on getting everything we asked for set up, the staff wa...s amazing, the food was amazing! Great job to y’all! We had about 60 guests and each was of them were very impressed! See More
Brittany Gibson
· October 22, 2017
We stopped while exploring in town and stopped to check it out only to find an awesome place! We had the Reuben sandwich and the special of the day of a Lamb Gyro and both were absolutely FANTASTIC! O...ur server was awesome and the atmosphere was laid back and relaxing! 10/10. We will be back!! See More
James Juliano
· September 17, 2017
Floor was sticky, service was just this side of nonexistent. Employees seemed like we had interrupted their day to do their job. I'm not sure if I am used to the city pace now, but it was hard to come... back to my hometown and get this as my memory. See More
Michael Dunfee
· December 16, 2017
We had our Knights of Columbus Christmas dinner and it was great.
The new chef did a great job. The food was fantastic! Everyone had a great time. I love the atmosphere at the Old Horseshoe.
Jay Stanley
· August 27, 2017
Rode our bikes to Johnstown looking for a nice spot for lunch. We both had the Cob Salad and it was very nice. Nice beer and cider selection too. Sat on the back porch. Friendly servers and guests the...re with us. See More
Todd Huber
· June 28, 2017
Stopped by to have a beer on the patio and maybe get some food. I waited for 10 mins for a server so i went in to tell them i was here. Told them what i wanted to drink. She brought out 1 beer told me... they were out of the other beer and it took 20 mins for me to go back in and ask where my other drink was at. I was going to order food but at this pace i would be here until close. Btw i'm still waiting for my check.... 15 mins later.��� See More
Kenn Kiser
· October 27, 2017
Everyone at our table of 5 enjoyed the food and atmosphere. The mushroom appetizer was huge and tasty. Fair prices and great service. I'm looking forward to returning.
Tracy Fetters Matheny
· May 26, 2017
Our server was very nice! We did go in early, so it was not busy and the food was good. I had the Fish and Chips! The homemade slaw was excellent! The blackberry tea was awesome too! We just moved to ...Johnstown and it was our first time there! We'll be back! See More
Gretchen Booth
· August 11, 2017
We ordered a variety of dishes and all were delicious! Very generous portions! The peanut butter pie is a must!
Lauren Hansel
· November 15, 2016
I've been coming here for 3 years (when you're a local there aren't many other places to go in Johnstown) and unfortunately inconsistent is the perfect word to describe it. You honestly never know wha...t you're going to get. The menu changes all the time, the wait staff changes all the time, and lunch time is more often than not a disaster. Last week we were there for lunch and there was one waitress for the entire dining area that had 11 tables with guests. It took nearly 2 hours for 5 people in my party to get seated, served, and out the door. She was visibly frazzled. This place has all the potential in the world but unfortunately the service and inconsistent menu are what the main constraints are. See More
Emily Pontious Walker
· August 13, 2016
We had our wedding rehearsal dinner at Old Horsehoe Tavern on August 4th. We were a bit concerned two weeks before when someone called us from Old Horsehoe telling us they were taking over the banquet...s and they only had one phone number (my father in laws) and they didn't know what menu we wanted. But that was quickly figured out and taken care of. The facility looked great the day of. I really love that upstairs setting. The staff was great! The only thing I was disappointed about was the food. It was not what I was expecting. We had chicken tenders, fried fish and French fries. We wanted that because it was so good when we had had it for dinner one night at Old horseshoe. The problem was the chicken, fish and fries were not the same as on their menu. It seemed to be bulk made food. I understand why they did that but if I would have known that would be the case I most likely would have picked a different menu. But over all it was a great experience and I am glad that I found Old Horsehoe to host our rehearsal dinner. It was a great location since we were having our Wedding at Irongate Equestrian center and our hotel was in new Albany. I also hope that now that the banquets are being run by a new person that they will work more than Tuesday-Saturday 11-3. That made it very difficult for me to find time to call.
Thank you for everything!
See More
Mary Leach
· July 11, 2017
The Old Horseshoe Tavern was where we held our son and fiancee's rehearsal dinner. Food is excellent! Service is superb! The tavern is quaint, homey, and I highly recommend it for your event or sim...ply a meal out. See More
Meghan Swad
· September 4, 2016
First of all, let me share that we come the Horseshoe at least once a week. We thoroughly have enjoyed the food while Jojo was running the kitchen. After she was fired, this place is a trainwreck. We ...came in tonight and they are serving a "limited" menu due to no show of staff. Our waitress proceeded to tell me that I can only order beer, not wine. (She said they don't have a license to sell wine on Sunday, which is odd because I had wine last Sunday.) Other then Kristina (who is amazing), this place needs a major staff make over. See More
Bonnie Sciacca Riddlebarger
· July 15, 2016
We want there on Sunday July 10 and ordered the Buffalo Chicken wrap it was excellent. The wrap was grilled, and the sauce they put on it was great. I bragged about it to friends throughout the week. ...Decided to go out to dinner tonight less than a week later. We ordered the same wrap. It was not grilled not hot and did not have the same sauce on it. We told our server what we thought about the meal, and she could not have cared less about our concerns. It's hard to believe that you order the same meal and less than a week and it taste like crap. Will not be going back again which is a shame because I believe in supporting our town and the small business owners. See More
Angie Scheu
· August 31, 2016
My husband and I brought our kids to Old Horseshoe one evening after work, and we thought "What a gem!" We enjoyed the Chicken Parmesan and the Andouille Sausage and Grits entrees. We were curious abo...ut the old building, so our server took the time to show us the room and patio upstairs. Awesome to see the old building re-purposed and cared for so nicely. Thanks for such an enjoyable evening! We will be back! See More
Judith Waite Allee
· September 11, 2015
What a treat! The Old Horseshoe was recommended by several friends and I finally made the trip the night they were having an open jam session in the upstairs bar. Wow! Lovely venue. I want to have a p...arty there sometime! They make the effort to include food from local farmers & use excellent ingredients. I tried a veggie platter, & it was wonderful, especially the garlic mashed potatoes. The jam session was awesome, & everyone was welcoming and friendly. I went by myself & never felt out of place. Thanks, Mary Miller and Allen Schwartz, for recommending this place--you were right! See More
Caitlyn VanDyke
· September 12, 2016
I ordered one of the burgers during one of my visits and really liked it. I had speedy service and did not have to wait long at all to get refills on my drink. I do not come into that part of town oft...en, but I will definitely make a point to come again! See More
Jane Otten Szalankiewicz
· November 15, 2017
The food was great!! Thanks Logan for taking care of us!! It was an awesome experience!
Emily Firman Clegg
· June 14, 2017
What a gem! The food was great and the service was great as well! We will definitely be back! Keep up the good work!
Videos
Scotty Bratcher performing at our place...
18
1
Posts

Happy Valentine's day everyone ... get your reservations in for tonight's couples special.. 740-967-3663

Image may contain: food and indoor
Image may contain: food and indoor

Looking for a great destination for your Valentine dinner?

Old Horseshoe Tavern

Valentine’s Day special

$50.00 per Couple…
Includes

...

1 Appetizer
2 Entrée’s
Dessert
Drinks include a choice of 1 bottle of house wine, 4 beers, or 2 liquor drinks

tax and gratuity not included

Call early for reservations. 740-967-3663

See More
Posts

Valentine’s Day special

$50.00 per Couple…
Includes

...

1 Appetizer
2 Entrée’s
Dessert
Drinks include a choice of 1 bottle of house wine, 4 beers, or 2 liquor drinks

tax and gratuity not included

Call early for reservations. 740-967-3663

See More

Got Cabin Fever...come out this Thursday, January 11th at 7 pm for the Acoustic Music Jam.

Acoustic Open Mic this Thursday, 7 pm (sign up around 6:30 pm). Come on out and join the fun!

Acoustic Music Jam...Tuesday, December 19th at 7 pm

Hello everyone, we will be closed at 2pm Friday December 15, 2017 for a private party. We apologize for any inconveniences. We will resume normal business hours on Saturday December 16th. Happy Holidays

The Old Horseshoe will be closed this Friday the 15 of December from 2:00 pm to close for a private event. Sorry for any inconvenience.

Acoustic Open Mic, Thursday, November 30th at 7 pm!

Acoustic Open Mic...this Thursday at 7 pm. Come play, sing, listen, eat & drink.

Acoustic jam this Thursday at 7 pm, come on out to eat, drink and have fun!

Acoustic Open Mic this Thursday at 7 pm, come on out to sing & play...or listen. Get some dinner and ice cold beverages, too!

Acoustic Picking Party/Jam...this Thursday at 7:30 pm...come on out & bring friends!

Acoustic Open Mic tomorrow (Thursday) 7 pm, come on out to sing , play, eat, drink, listen Always a great time!!!

Acoustic pickin' party this Thursday (August 10) at 7 pm, come on out to play and/or to listen. Great music, food, drink, friends and fun!