171 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Wren Solares
· March 22, 2018
I absolutely adore this place. It is tucked just out of the way of the city but still just a short (15 min) drive to get into town if you wish. I love that it is quaint and offers fabulous meals - I... especially love breakfast here! Great vibe, staff, food and customer service. Drop in for a light bite or coffee and then take a walk on the lake. Top 20 Milwaukee! Love... See More
Richard A. Cieslak
· April 2, 2018
Although this place is very good and we come here often, yesterdays Easter menu had a Salmon Benedict w/o an English muffin. Instead there was a very thin slice of tomato in its place. That’s a new one on me.
Kally Lowe
· February 22, 2018
The “Tuscany” room was absolutely amazing and very detailed and CLEAN! We also loved having the jacuzzi tub in the room. The owner was very welcoming as well. We both had biscuits and gravy for breakf...ast. Neither of us were a fan of those but we will come back just to stay in the hotel. See More
Joanne Turner Furmack
· December 4, 2017
I would have given a 4 out of 5, but I ordered a dish that had a poached egg. The yolk was more of soft boiled consistency as it did not ooze when cut into as a poached egg should. The rest of dish th...ough was very tasty! I had the pulled pork and potatoe hash See More
Amber Anderson
· December 10, 2017
The atmosphere is quaint and lovely. Their food is delicious and has never disappointed. Staff is friendly and very accomodating. I highly recommend Sheridan's! We went just the other day and it was s...o cozy with their holiday decorations and the fire going. See More
Mackenzie Certalic
· October 22, 2017
Sooo wonderful!! We threw a tiny surprise baby shower brunch for a close friend and it was perfect! Cute, classy place with delicious food and exceptional service. Highly recommend this hidden gem fo...r all occasions and dining. Thank you staff at Sheridan's café for helping me make this little 'event' here so special. See More
Richard Worrell
· April 23, 2018
Tasty food and good service. Our food was a bit slow to come out but was hot and delicious. I was there for a Sunday brunch with friends so it wasn’t a problem since we had time to catch up. Very nice... and bright atmosphere. See More
Sheila Semrou
· May 6, 2018
The lovely outdoor patio is a wonderful warm weather spot for brunch; Great menu; Delicious! And dog-friendly too.
Megan Marie Seppmann
· September 24, 2017
The food was fantastic and the atmosphere is great! There is a definite opportunity for staff service improvement. This is not a place you want to enjoy if you only have an hour for brunch. It took up...wards of 15 minutes to be recognized by a server and then it turned out, that wasn't even who was waiting on our table. Once we got our actual server we placed our food order with our beverages. Getting a refill on coffee and water was an unfortunate challenge.
The environment of the location was awesome and the seasonal hash and their take on eggs benedict was on point. I might suggest a staff member who just refills coffee and water... or even someone that upsells beverages at each table. There were a lot of empty glasses throughout out the dining room.
See More
Heather Underhill Lemcke
· May 3, 2018
Had half turkey club with house salad...AMAZING!! Love this little place, menu is unique and quite delicious 😋
Cezka Ronaldo
· March 4, 2018
The food was amazing! The atmosphere amazing! The staff all super friendly & very attentive. Definitely will be back!
Donna Laird
· February 14, 2018
The GEM of Cudahy dining ���
Very nice atmosphere , excellent service and delicious food.
My Husband and I loved our Valentines brunch��
Karen Matuszak
· August 28, 2017
Sheridan's has been a favorite since I moved to Cudahy 4 years ago. My 83 year old mother has driven from her home north of Green Bay on many occasions just to have brunch with me because she loves it... (and me 😊) so much. I'm curious, though, as to why the menu items seemed to have been reduced so significantly. No quiche? It was my favorite thing on the menu. No more turkey sausage? My mom always added that as a side and asked me when it was taken off the menu the last time we were there. These aren't deal breakers for us, we'll definitely be back again and again, just a bit of a disappointment. Please don't EVER get rid of the cinnamon & sugar toast!!
I would like to add we did have a great experience recently when we celebrated my birthday there. We had a fairly large group, some out-of-towners and everyone enjoyed their food and loved the space. And thank you to the owner for the complimentary cheese torte for the birthday girl! It was delicious!
See More
Brenda Avadian
· October 18, 2017
We stayed in the South African-themed room and it was a well appointed trip back in time. Loved it and the three shower options (tried all three: rain, body spray, handheld). We'll return.
Lara Pfeffer
· February 1, 2018
Great menu with plenty of flavor & artistry. Hidden gem.
Ashley Soule
· May 9, 2017
Such a shame. This place used to be my family's most favorite place to come. It's beautifully decorated and there is no other place like it in the area. We started coming here about 3 years ago and j...ust completely fell in love. However, in the past year, year and a half, this place has just declined terribly. The food is still decent, if you don't mind waiting 45 minutes for eggs. I worked in restaurants for many years and am always very sympathetic to the challenges of a busy place. However, it's never busy enough to justify the insanely long wait. I was there today and waited 30 minutes for pancakes, and eggs. There were only 2 other tables in the whole place at that time. Server was nice but the whole visit was frustrating enough to make me write this review. And it wasn't just this visit. The past 4 times my family has been there in the past year, has been frustrating and highly disappointing. I'm curious if this place even has a manager. I really hope someone comes along to get this place together because we'd love to make this "our place" again. However, until then we will absolutely not be back. There is so much potential in this cute little place, it's a shame to see it so terribly run. See More
Maria Lopez Bourgeois
· April 9, 2017
My husband and I went to Sheridan's this morning for brunch. As always, the food and service were excellent. Our waitress, Meg, anticipated our every need and then some. So many staff members were hus...tling around taking care of each and every customer. We have frequented Sheridan's in the past and have always been pleased. I love that there is such a nice place in my hometown! See More
Donna R Peterson
· July 5, 2017
Highly recommend if your in the Milwaukee area for a visit. The room was fabulous, extremely clean and very comfortable. The food is outstanding and the staff are very very courteous and friendly. ...The best place we have ever stayed. Great quality for a very comfortable price. See More
Matt Mulloy
· December 16, 2017
Only Sheridan's can screw up making Xmas with Santa fun. Dealt with the overpriced awful food to see Santa and Santa was "too busy" for our table. Nooo, nooo, nooo, Merry Xmas. Never again.
Norm Marraccini
· October 1, 2017
It was amazing, food was over the top and the service was wonderful. Already have plans to go back! The restaurant was spotless just so inviting.
Poached Pears in mulled wine infused orange zest mascapone, so good Chef Joe!

Talented Milwaukee singer songwriter is coming to Sheridan's for a special free acoustic concert to play songs from his new critically-acclaimed album "Midwestern Comfort"! Doors open at 6:30, show goes from 7 pm-8:30 pm. Cash bar.
Find out more about Ben at His CD "Midwestern Comfort" is available for sale on Spotify

Fri 6:30 PM CDTSheridan'sCudahy, WI

LATTE OF THE WEEK...Iced Blueberry Chai! Blueberry simple syrup, chai and milk over ice. It will put a SpRiNg in your step!

Image may contain: food