97 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Frank LoDuca
November 1, 2017
my parents live down the block from this pastry shop and are in it every day, weather it's for just a loaf of bread or for an expensive cake. my wife and I moved to long island and have 2 children. we... have been coming to tasty for years. ive always been proud about growing up in Brooklyn. it's always been a very tight knit community. threw the years it's changed, but not so much in a bad way. a lot of people from different backgrounds have migrated to Brooklyn but for the most part have participated in our ways, like checking out the Christmas lights on 10th ave. I have a problem with the fact that our small community will wait an hour outside in the cold for some over priced cookies but come Halloween Tasty pastry Shoppe will close for the day. the money spent in this shoppe on a weekly basis is crazy. so many stores on 13th ave help celebrate this wonderful holiday with our families but Tasty hasn't been one of them. I'm disgusted and ashamed that my family still goes to this establishment! See More
Lisa Romano
February 3, 2018
The rice balls are amazing the best I鈥檝e ever tasted my goodness I can鈥檛 wait to buy more everything from this place I put in my mouth is delicious and the pizza amazing cookies are delicious but the...m rice balls unbelievable 锟斤拷锟 See More
Anthony Marino
December 26, 2017
With such a wide selection of fresh baked goods that range from amazing Italian specialties to Bagels and even pizza, you鈥檒l quickly realize why Tasty Pastry is the go to place for residents of Dyker ...Heights and beyond! Make sure to get there early on Sunday for the freshest donuts - they sell out quick! Love this place. See More
Nellie Bloom
December 23, 2017
Their bakery items are fantastic and their gluten free items are out of this world. So sad I don't live in Brooklyn
Anna Barker
September 17, 2017
Tasty pastry is wonderful I love everything that they family and I get cakes ,pastries, cookies here every time we gave a party.excellent people, excellent dessert's........
Julie Elias
November 20, 2017
Thank you for these beautiful and delicious that鈥檚 giving cupcakes for my daughters daycare party tomorrow.
Phyllis Graziano Kovaleski
February 4, 2018
I sadly haven鈥檛 been here in years, but I miss the delicious pastries. The BEST lobster tails ever!
Danielle Curiel Gaffney
November 27, 2017
Amazing cookies, cream puffs, raspberry squares and cannolis
Ilene Schuss
December 29, 2017
Their cinnamon bread and cannolis are my favorites!
Rosie Nochella
December 4, 2016
All though I love everything that I have ever purchased & Ate from tasty I have to say the Seven layer cake pops were horrible. Sorry to say I'm sorry I didn't buy just one to try. Taste nothing at al...l like a seven layer cookie. I think you can do better than that. See More
Cynthia Galvin Kamp
August 1, 2015
Thank you Tasty Pastry for providing this BEAUTIFUL cake for our wedding on June 27th!!!

The cake was exactly what I wanted and I was sooooo excited to see it when we got to the venue!...

Oh and did I forget to mention, it was absolutely delicious as is everything we get from your shop!

The only flaw was that it was soooo good everyone ate it all up (no leftovers to take back to the hotel with us since we are saving the top tier for our First Anniversary)

Great Job!!!
See More
Sylvia Burns
July 3, 2017
Great pastries I ever had tasted...
Question do you deliver out of state?
My mother-in-law wanted to know she's from Kokomo Indiana and I show her a few pictures of the pastries and she said she wo...uld love to order because they look very delicious See More
Merav D
November 2, 2016
The best fruit tart and all around the most freshly baked and delicious bakery in all of NYC. Wonderful staff too!
Liz Franqui
April 22, 2017
Love my neighborhood and this bakery is a staple to our community and the best iced coffee 锟斤拷锟
Lori Carpino
July 13, 2015
I highly recommend Tasty Pastry, from their customer service to their cakes a truly wonderful experience. My cake was not only beautiful, but delicious too. Thanks , my granddaughters 1st Birthday cak...e was the talk of the party. See More
Cyderia Gates
January 30, 2016
I ordered a sugar free Top hat birthday cake for a senior citizen with diabetes. The cake was a huge hit and Tasty Pastry helped to make her birthday weekend really special! Thank you!
Laura Morgan
November 4, 2015
Best pastry shop I have ever been to. Love visiting here when I visit Brooklyn from my home in Wales. Great chocolate croissants. Better even than France.
Anthony Mazza
April 12, 2014
The best sugar free pastries you could find anywhere. Thank you for making sugar free items. They are so hard to find.
Amelia Robles Diaz
August 3, 2015
Love this place. I always go to them for customize made cakes and cupcakes always delicious and reasonably priced.
Michael Arpino
June 26, 2016
I have been eating their cookies and pastries since I was a 4 years 34 years old. Still the Best Pastry Shoppe in Brooklyn!
With this weather, it's nice to cozy up with a giant cup of hot cocoa!!! Giant Hot cocoa chocolate cake that is!!!!! #letitsnow #mugcakes #chocolatecakes #customcakes #specialtycakes #christmascakes #snowmen鈽冿笍 #hotchocolate only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn
Preparing for thanksgiving ... turkey cakes are better than actual turkey!!! 馃槈 #thanksgiving2017馃馃崅馃崄 #turkeycakes #preparing #customcakes only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn
Don鈥檛 forget to place your orders for Christmas cakes!!! Last day for all orders is this Thursday, December 14!!! #christmascakes #ornamentcake #santabelt #santainthechimney #rudolphcake #christmaslightscake #santaface #yulelog #christmastraditions #christmas2017 only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

Happy St Joseph鈥檚 day! Celebrate with st Joseph鈥檚 bread and pastry!!! #zeppoleandsfingi #stjosephsbread #stjosephspastry #italianpastry #stjosephsday only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

Image may contain: food
Image may contain: dessert and food
Image may contain: food

Don鈥檛 forget to pick up your green bagels, Irish soda bread, rye bread, pumpernickel bread, st Patrick鈥檚 day cupcakes, st Joseph鈥檚 pastry, and Easter egg breads!!! Now fully stocked!!! Egg breads available in multiple sizes!!! #irishsodabread #ryebread #pumpernickelbread #stpatricksday #stjosephsday #greenbagels #stpatscupcakes #easterbread only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

Tasty Pastry Shoppe added 7 new photos to the album: Specialty Cakes.
March 15 at 11:23am

What a fantastic baby shower theme!! Story book baby shower #babybook #storybook #bedtimestories #babyshower 馃懚 馃嵓 #babyshowercake #customcakes only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

No automatic alt text available.

What a fantastic baby shower theme!! Story book baby shower #babybook #storybook #bedtimestories #babyshower 馃懚 馃嵓 #babyshowercake #customcakes only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

No automatic alt text available.
Tasty Pastry Shoppe added 6 new photos to the album: Holiday Treats.
March 11 at 12:42pm
Tasty Pastry Shoppe added 7 new photos to the album: Specialty Cakes.
March 10 at 12:41pm

Who loves Cardi B???? And who thinks a cake with their face on it would be a great birthday cake?!?! Tag a bestie below to send them a hint to order your cake! #birthdaycakes #cardibcakes #makingmoneymoves #picturecakes #yourfaceonabirthdaycake #customcakes only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

Image may contain: 1 person, smiling, food
Tasty Pastry Shoppe added 2 new photos to the album: Specialty Cakes.
March 8 at 5:49am

Think there鈥檚 no such thing as a sugar free Easter treat? Think again!!! Just in sugar free chocolate eggs and bunnies... don鈥檛 forget Tasty has the largest selection of sugar free products in Brooklyn!!! #eastertreats #sugarfree #chocolateegg #chocolatebunny only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

No automatic alt text available.
Tasty Pastry Shoppe added 13 new photos to the album: Holiday Treats.
March 4 at 7:02am

We鈥檝e got love on the brain.... come pick up a Valentine鈥檚 Day cake today and celebrate early 馃槈 #celebratelove #champagnecake #popchampagne #valentinesday #valentinesdaycakes #specialtycakes only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

Image may contain: food

This cake is definitely boho chic!!! Perfect for birthday cakes or smash cake... order yours today #dreamcather #bohochic #pastelsandgold #floral #chic only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

Image may contain: food

Don鈥檛 forget to preorder your Super Bowl goodies !!! #footballcake #footballcupcakes #superbowl2018馃張 only at #tastypastryshop #dykerheights #brooklyn

Image may contain: food