132 Reviews
People talk aboutdelicious crab legs and good prices
Tell people what you think
Matt Rogers
· November 22, 2017
My wife and I moved to the area 2 years ago and wanted to celebrate closing on our house so we figured we would try the joint just up the road from us, support the local economy and all. We went aroun...d 7:30 on a Friday night which you would figure to be "prime time" at such a restaurant, we bought the buffet dinner and in the hour we were there they never replenished the clams, what had been in the pan was maybe a dozen dried up pieces of rubber, the lobster was horrible, the prime rib was dry and essentially tasteless, the desserts were placed on the table straight from a box. The carpeting was torn and frayed edges, the service was slow, and everything was way way overpriced, we spent $80 for one of the worst dinners we have ever had. That was two years ago and not only have we not been back we have warned our friends to avoid the place.

I'm all about fresh starts and this place definitely needs one, I hope the new owners can bring this place into the current century (quality-wise, I don't mind the decor, just don't let is be so run down). Quantity is not quality and on or visit we didn't even get that, fingers crossed that this corner of town gets a great new eatery so we don't have to keep going to Kinnelon and Butler for a dinner close to the house.
See More
Ilona Felso
· September 13, 2017
Prime rib is the best. that is all I can say, the seafood looks good but I dont like sea-food. So I cant rate it.Service is great too.
NJ Hiker
· March 11, 2018
Have been a few times, but not since last St Patricks day. Food on the buffet is often not warm - and although we have gone on March 17th the past few years, I doubt we will go again - Although they ...advertise an opening of 5pm, they are not ready for the many customers that are at the door waiting. The food is not ready, much of it is still cold. They don't have music playing even though its St. Patricks day - they advertise giving hats away but ours must have come from a box in the basement because it had staples still in it from last years decorations. They charge a good price for this celebration, and they need to actually PREPARE for an opening. Music playing (lets make it festive), HOT food (ALL READY TO BE SERVED), Fresh decorations, Clean up the place; soap and water is cheap, Replenish dishes when almost empty, FRESH deserts (Not ones people can put their hands all over) - We know its expensive to run a restaurant and we want to support locally but lets get our acts together and make this St. Patricks Day GREAT. See More
Ken Robinson
· February 19, 2017
We got the seafood buffet. The peel & eat shrimp were excellent. The warm crab legs were very good. I didn't have the cold crab legs. On the regular buffet items, not all the items were identified. I ...took one dish that I thought was chicken, but it turned out to be fish. It was quite good, but the first bite was not what I was expecting. Also many of the items were not hot. Now, if you could add lobster to the buffet... :) See More
Tina Snyder
· April 28, 2017
This place is a wonderful place for seafood and more. Great service, amazing seafood and succulent prime rib. The prices are so good too! Come with the family and fill up on high quality food. This is... our first visit and we plan on bringing the family for Mothers Day Buffet! See More
Ricky Roder
· December 20, 2017
Always good food & service. Have been going there for 25 years. West Milford for the last 20 and Little Falls before then.
Darryle Ziegler
· September 3, 2017
Best seafood and steak restaurant in the area.
Family oriented.
Great spot for good eats.
Robin Kaszas
· June 17, 2017
Sorry to say , disappointing ... crab had no taste and was very watered down.. Spent 70 bucks and it was terrible.. likely wont be back. Its just not worth it
Edie Goldstein Tolchin
· February 19, 2017
Food is good; I would give 5 stars if they would expand the building in the back to include a ladies room that accommodates modern-sized people and not residents of Munchkinland. Buffet items (great s...election) need to be kept warm. See More
Emily Clouse
· June 23, 2017
It was the worse time ever! First time there. Took forever to get the food and they gave my brother a completely raw stake that smelled like cat food! Will never go back again!
Margaret Swart
· July 11, 2016
A fun place where you can bring the whole family for an evening out. You can also celebrate a romantic evening together. The food is wonderful, reasonably priced and the drinks are terrific. I have... been a customer for as long as the Zieglers have purchased it and always enjoyed it. I would recommend it to everyone. See More
Don Webb
· January 4, 2017
Love the buffet here. All you can eat and many tasty choices. Go for the surf and turf. You won't regret it.
Pam Jorlett
· April 17, 2017
Loved the seafood buffet on Easter. The crab legs were delicious and the service was great!
Christine DiazLemay
· July 15, 2015
Great place to be with friends and family. The food is excellent. The staff is very kind and helpful.
Deborah Rose Carolla Witkowski
· July 28, 2014
same here chad - it looks like they took my review off - my total was 70.00 and we got there before six - only 2 beers added to my food - 31.00 a person for a buffet which really has not much to choos...e from - very disappointed and will definately not go back and will spread the word also. See More
Sue Dutcher Mathews
· September 11, 2016
Food was great. The burger was excellent. Our server needs to retire. She was very forgetful and a little off.
Neil Ottens
· April 30, 2017
A huge sign out front attracted me in. The sign said ALASKAN KING CRAB ALL YOU CAN EAT!! I paid for the all you can eat buffet.. no king crab anywhere.. waitress says the sign said jumbo crab.. nah ...... wrong .. See More
Jess Thompson
· November 20, 2016
So much food!!! Awesome atmosphere, awesome employee's, plenty of parking, stiff & great tasting drinks!!!! What more could you ask for! Thank you for a great nite out!
Debbie Best Kibitlewski
· September 30, 2016
Always enjoy coming here! Food and desserts are always wonderful! And the owners are so gracious!
Kathleen Gannon Longo
· April 17, 2017
Great Easter buffet. Really enjoyed the turkey with stuffing.
Town Tavern Country Inn updated their cover photo.
No automatic alt text available.
Town Tavern Country Inn updated their cover photo.
No automatic alt text available.