566 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Nicole Marie Houghton
· March 19, 2018
My grandmother and I came in and ordered a birthday cake for my daughter who just turned 3 and I can’t believe how beautiful it came out and it wasn’t just a regular happy birthday cake my daughter l...oves the movie coraline and the picture I showed them doesn’t even compare to how beautiful the cake came out we absolutely loved it and everyone and the party said it was beautiful and so delicious I will definitely be ordering my cakes from them! See More
Alicia Johnson
· January 30, 2018
A great big thank you to Traubs Bakery and their staff for making the best Star Wars cake for my husbands 50th birthday!! Not only did it look fantastic it was delicious!! This is not my first time Traubs for cakes! I have been a satisfied customer for quite a few years! Oh and the donuts are to die for!!! See More
Tina Marie
· January 30, 2018
I am a long time customer. Traub's Bakery is my go to place whenever I need a cake or cupcakes. They always hit the mark with whatever theme I'm looking for and the cakes taste great! I don't live but they are definitely worth the travel. See More
Michele Sinick Doyle
· May 17, 2018
What has happened to the Traub’s we all know and love.? Donuts are completely different and cakes are dry and smaller in size. My past few experiences have been awful. So sad this place is not the same.
Jacqueline Torres
· January 31, 2018
I have been eating delicious cakes and donuts from Traubs Bakery for a very long time now. Every family get together has included something from Traubs, they are the best at what they do! Everyone I, from family to neighbors has a favorite from Traubs. See More
Carimah Wingate-Laws
· April 21, 2018
This is always my go to place. I bring them pictures and they make the cakes just like the pictures. I love their donuts, cupcakes, and sticky buns!
Mandy Roseboro
· March 17, 2018
The cake for my sisters baby shower today was beautiful and of course was delicious! Thank you so much for customizing the blue and pink colors. Everyone loved how great it turned out. I tried to post... a picture but I couldn’t. See More
Ryann Olivia
· January 31, 2018
I am an event coordinator and Traubs is the #1 spot I order all of my fun custom cakes from! Every one that I have ordered was given to me better then I could ever imagine and on top of LOOKING GREAT,... they TASTE even BETTER! See More
John Lauser
· March 4, 2018
Just as good as I remember it growing up. Love this place. Only problem is trying to walk out of there without doing some serious damage to my diet.
Megin Topolaja
· February 11, 2018
I've used Traub's Bakery for several occasions and they've exceeded my expectations every time! Not only are the cakes delicious but the custom work is beautiful! And their prices are very reasonable.... Highly Recommend! See More
Sue Clark
· November 4, 2017
I'm a long time customer who had a complaint - a $44 cupcake-cake that was stale. I left a message in person at the store, I sent an email, and I sent a message on facebook. I think that Traub's has... a zillion customers, and they simply don't care about one customer who was dissatisfied. Now I'm no longer a customer, not because of the stale cake, but because of being completely ignored. Now they have a zillion customers minus one. See More
Megan Jacobs
· October 25, 2017
I had a bad experience with my wedding cake � An apology from the owner would have been nice and a refund for my missing cake topper. I will not be returning as a customer. Dineen (spelling?) was very... very nice to me about the whole thing. See More
Edward Kerstetter
· April 1, 2018
Crum cake: you changed the dough used on the Crum cake. It is the dough you use on cinnamon buns. Did you change bakers?
Mona Green-Blount
· May 6, 2018
I have been using this bakery for years and they never let me down! Great job with my grandson Blaze birthday cake
Jenna Mahalik
· January 30, 2018
Ordered my sisters baby shower cake from here & it was absolutely beautiful!
David Cohen
· May 10, 2017
Stumbled upon this gem passing through the area. This bakery would bring me back for no other reason than to get their pastry. Places of this quality are harder and harder to find in part because of t...he junk supermarkets make easy for people to buy. I live a little over one hour from here. See More
Heather Anne - Author
· January 13, 2018
Thank you traubs my sons Green Ninjago cake is awesome!!!!!
Lori Wojciechowski
· January 19, 2017
Best donuts in town!! When I lived in prospect park this was my favorite place for donuts, so fresh and delicious. When I visit family Traub's is always on my list of must haves!!
Amy Corona
· February 19, 2017
We went in with an idea that my almost 7 year old son had for his birthday cake - a Chinese dragon. They made an awesome cake that he is so excited about! It not only met, but far exceeded our expec...tations! Thank you so much for taking what was only an idea and turning it into reality. :) See More
Karen Krushinsky Deal
· January 19, 2017
So disappointed that the place we had make our wedding cake is promoting their support of the worst thing to ever happen to our country. Please don't try to defend saying they're being patriotic as th...ey didn't do this when President Obama was elected. Cupcakeology for me from now on!!! See More
Angela Marie
· February 26, 2017
Get all of my sons birthday cakes here every year and every year they do a great job!!! Got a Pokémon Charizard cake yesterday she drew it and it was awesome! Very great job and my son loved it. Will ...continue to come here every year. See More
John VonBergen
· January 20, 2017
My mom's a Saint and when I go over her house for visits I bring her Traubs sticky buns, I like the ones with nuts, my mom likes the ones with just raisin. So I get both! Nothing but the best for Mama Jayne!
Becca Zangari
· August 27, 2017
Did my husband's cake for his 30th came out awesome. I asked them to do a Dr. Who cake and they had no idea what that was but they said they would google it and did I great job drawing the Tardis! Tha...nks so much. See More
Tacie Remick
· February 16, 2017
Brought in a retirement cake to the office today. EVERYONE raved about how good it was, came back for seconds and wanted to know how to find you. I've ordered several cakes from Traub's in the past ...and always received compliments. (Donuts are awesome too!) Keep up the good work! See More
Bill Cropper
· May 8, 2017
I am a foodie. It is a blessing to have this Bakery in the neighborhood. The only problem is trying to decide what to buy. I almost always buy cannolis. They are too hard to resist, but sometimes I sw...itch it up. Get the upside down � pineapple cake. I bought an � apple pie there once. It was to die for! See More
Vince Shervin
· January 17, 2018
I love their crumb cakes, danish & their specialty cakes. Delicious!
Christy Marie
· January 20, 2017
This bakery is amazing and customer service and products are outstanding. I just picked up my Presidential cake the other night and love it. The entire office loved it and it was delicious. Great job:)
Flop Zambino
· January 18, 2017
Had a cake at a christening recently. Strawberry shortcake! A M A Z I N G!!!! Would go out of my way to buy here.
Now I do not normally rate businesses on social media, but heard there were some givin...g this bakery a hard time. So here I am! This time I am not just making a mental note of how good the food was. I'm speaking up and saying...DELICIOUS!!! loved the icing also!!! See More
Jo Ann Stover
· October 5, 2017
Best donuts around. And the raspberry layered pound cake is awesome!
Kimberly Dee
· July 6, 2017
I really enjoy Traubs bakery I went in for a chocolate moose cake They had it in the case ready to go then the young man working there asked if I wanted anything written on the cake which took me by ...surprise He did a great job the cake was beautiful & delicious ! Thank you ! See More
Brendan Sullivan
· November 6, 2017
I loved the make America Greta again cakes!!!! They were awesome and I hope you have some again
Sara McManus
· August 18, 2017
Traubs did a fantastic job whipping together custom Margarita donuts for a co-worker birthday breakfast celebration. Thank you Traubs Bakery!
Tom Tryson
· July 8, 2017
Cake is too dry and I'm not a fan of the icing. Canolis are good.
Kamala Spierfuhren
· January 20, 2017
I've never put anything so bitter and nasty in my mouth before. So disappointed. Make America Great Again cakes taste like sand, spittle, and orange hair dye.
Lyndsey Christina
· January 19, 2017
Traubs has been a staple in our area for a long time and everyone loves their goods. This recent attack on them over politics is quite sad and pathetic. The attack has backfired and gave them much des...erved attention and revenue. Congrats! See More
Vicenta Pyles
· April 3, 2017
LOVED everything we got! Only advice is to put a price list up somewhere... but the Raspberry cake was moist and tasteful. Will be back again soon.
Lukas Sunkler
· August 1, 2017
Awesome donuts and cakes! Go here every time family is in town
Brian J. Mason
· January 19, 2017
They are fearless. They make top notch cakes for top notch people.
Steven James Elliott
· January 19, 2017
I'm giving you 5 stars because it makes more sence to give you a 5 star review then 1 because you made a trump cake
Julia Bochanski
· January 19, 2017
Their brownies are amazing. No other bakery makes them like that. Beautiful cakes too! We love Traubs!!
And of course, the annual Donut Eating Contest with Jim Friskey winning AGAIN!!
Prospect Park Donut Eating Contest at Park Square on July 4, 2012
Annual 4th of July Donut Eating Contest in Park Square Park!! Winner Bob McArdle ate 3 OVERSTUFFED cream donuts in 1 min and 53 seconds! However, the guy to beat, Jim Friskey, ate 1 2lb donut in about that same time!!!
We have all you need to go with your Royal spot of tea!!!!

Small and large chocolate chip scones

Image may contain: food

Large and mini pigs ears

Image may contain: food and indoor

Wedding cookies

Image may contain: shoes

Royal wedding heels

Image may contain: dessert and food
Image may contain: food

HELP WANTED.....nights and or. weekends for store.....apply at bakery

Don’t forget your Royal Wedding goodies