229 Reviews
Tell people what you think
Stacy Hunt DuVall
· December 18, 2017
It's hard to decide what to say is the best about the store - the folks there or all the nifty stuff! I had brought in a substantial collection to sell; the owner and the guys were the best, from me carry the boxes inside to offering fair prices for the items. They made what could've been a chore into an enjoyable experience.

I was able to also find a perfect present for a friend. The selection is great, the prices are good, everyone was fun and friendly to talk to, and the music playlists are A+. I'm looking forward to going back for more shopping.
See More
Jesse Vasquez
· November 5, 2017
I’m the type of person that is beyond skeptical about purchasing stuff online. I️ Saw they had an item I️ wanted on amazon. I️ Verified by calling them, they were very helpful. Ordered the item and it... came in 3 Days. I️ live in TX and the item came in great condition for a 15+ year old toy in a box. Happy with the purchase, just wish they had a better website to know the inventory, for us that aren’t close to there store. If they ever have an item I️ want, will definitely purchase through them again! See More
Daniel Grose
· February 7, 2018
I will preface this review as I am a Hot Wheels Collector and this was not somewhere I'd expect to walk into a toy establishment like this and expect they would carry such an array of Hot Wheels/ inventory, anything from multiple dump bin like models to high-end RLC models and collectibles you would be proud to show other collectors!!

I was helped in a first-class manner by a Zac, He was quick and on the ball getting me prices and wheeling and dealing. I was pleasantly surprised He knew His stuff...

....and to top it ALL OFF, it's the simplest thing's that make me come back, He offered me a bag (basic store bag), but I recently purchased cars from Hobby Town and spent more there and every time I've purchased die cast from there, I've always had to ask for a bag. I PROMISE you I'll be back and you like me NEED TO ASK FOR ZAC!

*I didn't give the store a 5 stars rating because there's always room for improvement where ever you go - and maybe somewhere in the future I can use the 5 stars when they call be by my name because I'm a VIP member! ;)
See More
Bryan Vaughn
· October 16, 2017
Best action figure store around! I live in Texas and they always help me out when I have inquiries on figures. I find it amazing that y’all ship out of state. Very reasonably priced figures. I recomme...nd this place to everyone! See More
Sam Swaim
· February 26, 2018
Great store, Great people. Always willing to work a deal that is fair and they have a great selection Star Wars toys and just about anything else toy related you would want.
P.j. Carr
· April 16, 2018
This store is AMAZING! Everyone is extremely helpful and super nice! Toy collectors you need to check it out. Thanks for shipping our toys back to Florida!
Chris Palmer
· October 23, 2017
The place was filled with amazing toys from my childhood. I bought some things to move my collections a long. Go check this place out!
Joshua Milburn
· February 1, 2018
Super friendly and awesome prices. I went back a second time because I couldn't pass up on some of the deals!
Quinn Hurley
· July 19, 2017
You probably had dreams as a kid of walking into a toy store where you had to step over toys to get to more toys. A dream land that TV commercials promised you but never fulfilled. But the Toy Pit is ...that place. It's not an artificial, corporate toy store filled with people trying to sell you credit cards or protection plans. It's genuine. Authentic. Indiana is lucky to have this place. See More
Richard Denney
· November 22, 2017
Great place and run by very nice people. I definitely recommend checking The Toy Pit out with your kids or for yourself.
Justin Sweigart
· September 28, 2017
Best Toy Store In Indy! Go there for all your collectible needs! Mike and the rest of the crew are awesome! My favorite place and people in the hobby!
Brandon J. Benfield
· October 20, 2016
Sometimes when you go to sell your beloved collection, you think you're going to get screwed. Not with these guys. Not only are they fair, more times than not you come out with a better deal than what... you would have gotten somewhere else. If you're looking for a rare item for your collection, whether it's a full fledged complete figure or even just an accessory, they almost always have it. The staff is always extremely nice and you can tell they love they're job and know what they're doing just by talking to them. Great experience, great store. I'd say they're Indianapolis' best toy shop around. See More
Pat Staubach
· October 15, 2016
The Toy Pit is a buy, sell and trade toys in a business sense. What they do not advertise is the personal attention and passion these guys give to my 7 year old son (and to everyone, I imagine!) each... and every time we walk into their store. He feels like a million bucks with everyone asking what kind of figure he's looking for, the extra effort they go through to seek out whatever random Batman or Star Wars toy he decides is his desire for that moment, and one other amazing thing that compelled me to write this review.....A little over a month ago we went to the Toy Pit in search of Star Wars figures. One gentleman said he had a specific character at home my son was looking for and he would bring it in. As promised, he had the figure and it made my son's day. That kind of service goes beyond anything I would expect. Then he went on to say how now that he knew how much my son liked Star Wars, he would keep various figures off to the side for the next time we came in and we could take a look. A kind thing to say, and no way I expected The Toy Pit to actually do such a thing, they were already awesome in our book! Fast forward to mid-October. We walk in, my son immediately scouts out the Star Wars figures, and low and behold, here comes the same gentleman, 4 figures in hand, telling my son, "Hey, I know I told you I'd hold some figures for next time you came in, so, no pressure, I just wanted to show you some and see what you thought." My son's eyes lit up because of the cool figures and my eyes lit up because of the incredible gesture that I just witnessed.
You will never find a store that gives that kind of attention to a seven year old. Based on what I've seen with other customers that have been there, I know they give that kind attention to everyone, collectors, kids, parents looking for that perfect gift, everyone!
Thank you, Toy Pit. My son was having a rough day when we saw you, and you had no way of knowing it, but you made his day. You made his Dad's day too. You all do so much more than buy, sell and trade. See you soon.
See More
Anthony Scalzitti
· September 22, 2016
Sorry to say I have to update my original post about The Toy Pit. I have been on hiatus from my beloved Toy Pit for the past few months and went back over this past weekend. The store itself was a dis...aster, messy and difficult to find things. Lots of items on the floor, easy to step on or trip over. The staff was polite but didn't provide that personal connection that the "regular" staff did. The prices also seemed to be higher on all items across the board. Really disappointed and didn't have the sense that I needed to return to The Pit.

***Original Post Sept 2016
Cannot say enough nice things about the store and staff. Everyone on the staff is extremely nice and knowledgeable. The prices cannot be beat anywhere online or in other stores. Staff takes time to help out and always feel welcome while in the store. The store itself is quite amazing. The items are organization and they still have spots to "dig" for treasure. If in the Indianapolis/Fishers area, it's an great little gem to visit.
See More
Amy Pauszek
· May 26, 2017
If you need to start or complete your Superhero collection or just want rare and cool collectibles from Wonder Woman, Superman, Batman to Star Wars or Barbies ... and more - grab your Capes and get to... my fav toy store : The Toy Pit! Stop by the store in Fishers,IN or go online. The Superhero Staff at The Toy Pit will find you old and new childhood favs!!! I give this store a 10 star and above rating! Get to The Toy Pit TODAY!!! See More
Bunny Navarro
· December 2, 2017
Amazing place and very friendly staff
I loved it.
Nicole Batalis
· October 3, 2016
If you collect Transformers, this is the place to go. My boyfriend has had a huge collection for a long time, and he got me very into it as well. It's always fun to dig around the bins and see what go...odies you can find! The guys that work there are so amazing too! And love the donations that they do!!! Super awesome store, and pretty dang organized. I will be a very loyal customer. See More
Chris Thornsberry
· September 14, 2016
What an amazing place to relive your childhood! These guys have just about everything you can imagine and if they don't...just wait a few days and they will. Mike and crew are always the best. Alwa...ys willing to talk shop and cut you a deal. There is no way you can leave empty handed or unsatisfied. See More
Julie Makingithappen Pinner
· September 13, 2017
I love these guys they are soooo helpful. If you want to buy, sell or trade THE TOY PIT is the place to be. Don't believe me go see for yourself you won't be disappointed.
Wendi Bertram
· April 6, 2017
One of the best toy stores in Indiana that I've found! And the funko selection is PHENOMENAL!!! I found one of my grails at this store for an amazing price!!! I won't be shopping anywhere else from no...w on! This place is DEFINITELY a honey hole! I'm so happy I discovered The Toy Pit! I can't wait to go back!!! See More
Your Local Toy Paradise!
The Toy Pit wants to wish everyone a very merry Christmas and Happy New Years! #happynewyear #merrychristmas #toy #toystore #toyshop #toysforsale #toysfortrade #buyselltrade #buytradesell #nightmarebeforechristmas #christmaseveeve